Games like Pony Island
Looking for games like Pony Island? Here are top simulation recommendations with a horror focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with The Hex, There Is No Game: Wrong Dimension or Superliminal.
1 91%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, replayability94% User Score 2,961 reviewsCritic Score 80%2 reviewsIn a creaky old tavern, in a forgotten corner of the video-game universe, a storm is raging. An anonymous caller suggests that a murder is being planned. Six video game genre protagonists are the only plausible suspects...
View GameView Game
2 
94%Game Brain Scorehumor, storygrinding, replayability97% User Score 9,663 reviewsCritic Score 88%5 reviews"There is no game: Wrong dimension" is a Point&Click comedy adventure (and Point&Click only!) that will take you on a journey you never asked to go on, through silly and unexpected video game universes. Will you be able to play along with the "Game" to find your way home? We sincerely think NOT.
View GameView Game
3 
84%Game Brain Scoregameplay, storystability, grinding94% User Score 9,988 reviewsCritic Score 73%31 reviewsMind-bending Optical Puzzles
View GameView Game
4 
94%Game Brain Scoregameplay, storystability, grinding94% User Score 11,345 reviewsYour estranged father, a theme park engineer riddled with lawsuits dubbed "the Escape Artist", has died. You inherit his decrepit shack in the middle of the woods. The shack, and the objects within it, distort reality and break the laws of physics. A game made in collaboration between the University of California, Irvine and the Laguna College of Art & Design, The Escape Artist is a single-play…
View GameView Game
5 
85%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, replayability87% User Score 4,068 reviewsCritic Score 80%1 reviewsStories Untold is a compilation tape of four experimental text adventures, including a remaster of the original episode The House Abandon.
View GameView Game
6 
85%Game Brain Scoremusic, graphicsstory, replayability87% User Score 2,596 reviewsCritic Score 80%3 reviewsPlease, Don’t Touch Anything is a cryptic, brain-racking button-pushing simulation. Covering for a colleague who is taking a bathroom break, you find yourself in front of a mysterious panel which only component is a red button. And since you’ve clearly been instructed not to touch anything, the only thing you want to do now is push that damn button. Push it and expect to be held liable for any u…
View GameView Game
7 
92%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, monetization97% User Score 131,036 reviewsCritic Score 82%39 reviewsFrom the creator of Pony Island and The Hex comes the latest mind-melting, self-destructing love letter to video games.
View GameView Game
8 
88%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, stability94% User Score 2,729 reviewsCritic Score 82%9 reviewsJoin Brian Pasternack on his first day at one of the world’s largest companies, Sintracorp. Uncertain, unprepared, and massively unqualified, will Pasternack have what it takes to shine in Sintracorp's hierarchy? It all depends on how he performs on his first assignment… and whether he survives it.
View GameView Game
9 
85%Game Brain Scoreatmosphere, storyreplayability, grinding92% User Score 20,194 reviewsCritic Score 75%7 reviewsUncertain of his sister's fate, a boy enters LIMBO
View GameView Game
10 
91%Game Brain Scoregameplay, musicgrinding, optimization92% User Score 5,600 reviewsCritic Score 90%1 reviewsYou play an explorer stranded on a dangerous alien planet. Low on fuel, your only hope for escape is to find the planet’s core in this incredibly clever action-puzzle-platformer.
View GameView Game
