Games like Evil Tonight
Looking for games like Evil Tonight? Here are top survival shooter recommendations with a horror, fantasy and mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Tormented Souls, Tormented Souls 2 or Silly Polly Beast.
1 View Game91%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplayreplayability, stability92% User Score 3,419 reviewsCritic Score 74%3 reviews"Tormented Souls" is a third-person perspective survival horror game. Players control Caroline Walker, a woman who investigates a series of disappearances in a mysterious abandoned convent. The game features puzzle-solving, resource management, and intense combat against grotesque creatures. With a nod to classic survival horror games, "Tormented Souls" aims to deliver a suspenseful and frightening experience.
View Game2 View Game87%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, grinding87% User Score 645 reviewsReturn to classic survival horror in this special demo version of Tormented Souls 2. Experience the opening section of the game as Caroline navigates the claustrophobic passageways of a shadowy convent in search of her missing sister
View Game3 View Game88%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, replayability91% User Score 590 reviewsCritic Score 70%1 reviewsSilly Polly Beast follows the unlucky Polly as she escapes a nightmarish orphanage only to become trapped in a deadly, fog-shrouded underworld. Players explore eerie realms, confront haunting figures, and master forbidden spells through unique battles combining side and top-down perspectives. The game challenges you to survive and escape before your inner demon consumes you.
View Game4 View Game90%Game Brain Scoregraphics, gameplaystability, grinding90% User Score 1,396 reviews"Alisa" is a single-player Horror Action game with an intriguing story, set in a 1920s-Armageddon-inspired universe. As Elite Royal Agent Alisa, you navigate an old Victorian mansion, battling mechanized doll-like humanoids while searching for escape. Despite some bugs and grinding, the game boasts masterful visuals, soundtrack, and sensational replayability. Available on itch.io and Steam, it runs smoothly on most hardware.
View Game5 View Game85%Game Brain Scoregameplay, storygrinding, stability91% User Score 1,221 reviewsCritic Score 80%10 reviews"CONSCRIPT is a single-player Horror Action game set during the Battle of Verdun in 1916, where you play as a French soldier searching for your missing brother. Experience classic survival horror gameplay with punishing mechanics, dense atmosphere, and various difficulty settings in a unique historical setting. With a fascinating plot, beautiful graphics, good soundtrack, and replayability through multiple endings, unlockable costumes, and bonus weapons, CONSCRIPT offers a challenging and immersive experience."
View Game6 View Game85%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, stability91% User Score 245 reviewsCritic Score 68%3 reviews"Lamentum" is a single-player Horror Role Playing game set in a pixel art survival-horror universe, featuring an intriguing story and awesome gameplay. Immerse yourself in a nightmarish world inspired by classics like Resident Evil and Silent Hill, as you uncover the dark secrets of Grau Hill Mansion to save your beloved wife. Every decision you make may alter the course of the story, and the unique atmosphere, amazing graphics, and exceptional music will keep you on the edge of your seat. Will you survive the horrors that await you?
View Game7 View Game89%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, optimization98% User Score 5,514 reviewsCritic Score 80%13 reviews"Crow Country" is a survival horror game set in an abandoned theme park, where players must solve puzzles and uncover the dark secrets of the park's past. As they progress, they'll encounter mysterious monsters and uncover disturbing rumors about the park's former owner, Edward. Exploration Mode allows players to enjoy the park's sights and sounds without the fear of attack. The game delves into themes of ambition, greed, and redemption as players uncover the truth about the park and themselves.
View Game8 View Game88%Game Brain Scoreatmosphere, graphicsgrinding, monetization93% User Score 1,241 reviewsCritic Score 60%1 reviewsLabyrinth of the Demon King is a first-person dungeon crawler set in a war-torn feudal Japan overrun by demons. You play as an Ashigaru foot soldier on a perilous quest to track down and defeat the Demon King responsible for your Lord’s death. The game challenges you with survival, resource management, and combat in a brutal, chaotic world.
View Game9 View Game82%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospherestability, grinding90% User Score 1,602 reviewsCritic Score 74%12 reviews"Hollowbody" is a single-player Adventure game with exceptional graphics, atmospheric music, and perfected game mechanics. As Mica, an unlicensed black market shipper, players must navigate through a dangerous exclusion zone to find their missing partner, Sasha, who went in search of answers 12 days ago. Players must manage resources, solve puzzles, and fight for their lives in this suspenseful and immersive gaming experience.
View Game10 View Game83%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplayreplayability, grinding86% User Score 806 reviewsCritic Score 80%35 reviews"Gunbrella" is a single-player platformer game with an interesting noir-punk plot, set in a world dependent on a scarce natural resource. As the player, you'll wield the Gunbrella, a versatile weapon/umbrella, to navigate side-scrolling action levels and uncover secrets. The game features exceptional mechanics, delightful visuals, a unique atmosphere, and plenty of humor, leading you through diverse locations filled with intriguing characters and challenges.
View Game










