Games like The Painscreek Killings

"Goetia" is a single-player horror point-and-click game with an intriguing story set in the abandoned village of Oakmarsh. The game features sensational gameplay, delightful graphics, and an awesome atmosphere, accompanied by a sensational soundtrack. However, be prepared for some grinding. The story revolves around the mysterious disappearance of the village population during WWII, with the ruins of Blackwood Manor holding potential answers.

Quern: Undying Thoughts is a first-person puzzle adventure game. Explore the mysterious ancient island of Quern and solve its challenging puzzles to uncover the secrets of the island's past. Immerse yourself in the game's rich atmosphere and intricate story, and discover the island's connection to your own past.

"The Inheritance of Crimson Manor" is a narrative-driven mystery game set in a Victorian-era mansion. Players step into the shoes of a detective, unraveling the dark secrets of the recently deceased Lord Crimson and his family. Through exploration and puzzle-solving, unearth clues, interrogate suspects, and June 12, 2022 update: now features voice acting and new animations to enhance the storytelling experience.

"The Eyes of Ara" is a puzzle-based exploration game where players uncover the mysteries of a forgotten castle. Interact with objects, decode intricate puzzles, and search for hidden secrets to restore the castle's lost grandeur. With stunning visuals and an immersive atmosphere, this game offers a captivating single-player experience for all puzzlers at heart.

"Ether One" is a first-person adventure game that explores the human mind's fragility through two paths. One path is a story exploration without puzzles, while the other involves solving complex puzzles to restore patients' life-changing events. The game offers accessible and optional challenging environmental puzzles, encouraging players to solve them with friends and family. It brings back pen and paper puzzle-solving for a nostalgic experience.

"Call of the Sea" is a first-person adventure game set in the 1930s. Play as Norah, a woman searching for her missing husband in the uncharted islands of the South Pacific. Uncover the secrets of a lost civilization and solve intricate puzzles to advance the narrative-driven story. The game features stunning art deco-inspired visuals and a captivating original soundtrack.

The Vanishing of Ethan Carter is a first-person story-driven mystery game focused on exploration and discovery. As occult-minded private detective Paul Prospero communicate with the dead to discover the fate of a missing boy and the mystery behind a dark ancient force lurking in Red Creek Valley.

INFRA is a single-player adventure game with a stunning story, excellent gameplay, masterful visuals, and stellar music. As a structural analyst, you'll navigate a labyrinth of debris, solve puzzles, and uncover a massive scheme in the crumbling city of Stalburg. With high replayability, INFRA offers a gun-free puzzle adventure that will make you laugh, despite its numerous bugs and dense atmosphere.

"Paradise Killer" is a first-person investigation game set on an island outside reality, where a rogue human civilization seeks to resurrect dead alien gods. When the Council responsible for this process is murdered and the island is destroyed, "investigation freak" Lady Love Dies is called upon to solve the crime and uncover the truth behind the chaotic events. Uncover the facts and ponder the nature of truth in this stylized, psychedelic murder mystery.

"The Sexy Brutale" is a puzzle-adventure game where players attend a masquerade ball in a mansion, but time repeats in a loop. As a guest with the ability to be unseen, you must prevent the deaths of other guests by learning their routines and manipulating objects and the environment. With each successful prevention, you uncover more of a sinister plot.