In "The Painscreek Killings," become a journalist investigating the mysterious abandonment of a once-vibrant town. Solve logical puzzles, explore freely, and uncover dark secrets as you search for the truth behind the town's haunting past. This story-rich, murder mystery game encourages careful exploration and critical thinking.
Engaging and immersive story that keeps players guessing until the end.
Encourages players to take notes and piece together clues, enhancing the detective experience.
Atmospheric setting with a haunting vibe that adds to the overall mystery.
Gameplay can become tedious with excessive backtracking and key hunting.
Some puzzles are overly obscure or frustrating, leading to potential confusion.
The ending feels rushed and lacks the depth of the earlier parts of the game, with a jarring shift in tone.
story
1,863 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
43%
55%
2%
The story in "The Painscreek Killings" is widely praised for its depth and complexity, engaging players as they unravel a rich narrative filled with twists and turns. Players appreciate the non-linear storytelling approach, which requires them to piece together clues from diaries and letters, creating a sense of immersion and detective work. However, some critiques mention that the gameplay can feel tedious due to the constant backtracking and reliance on finding keys, which may detract from the overall experience despite the compelling plot.
“The story in this game is fantastic, and I loved how I genuinely needed to take notes.”
“Every storyline and twist kept me genuinely hooked.”
“The story is very compelling once the first twist hits, and it hits hard, and keeps a very good pace after that.”
“The story is relatively simple, but it's the details and incremental building that kept me coming back.”
“The story itself is rooted in people simply being people (don't worry, no spoilers), for better and for worse.”
“The story is too fragmented, not engaging and too slow.”
atmosphere
390 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
58%
40%
2%
The atmosphere of the game is widely praised for its eerie and immersive qualities, effectively creating a sense of unease and tension as players explore the abandoned town. Reviewers highlight the combination of haunting music, well-crafted environments, and a compelling narrative that draws players into the mystery, often making them feel as though they are being watched. While some found the pacing and gameplay mechanics frustrating, the overall consensus is that the atmospheric design significantly enhances the experience, making it a standout feature of the game.
“The atmosphere is incredible - the game feels like a horror game just because of the emptiness of everything and the music alongside it, but for the most part, the spookiness stays there as an atmosphere and not something interfering with your gameplay.”
“The atmosphere and environment were beautiful, eerie, and definitely reminiscent of a good murder mystery show or book.”
“The atmosphere is so thick and foreboding at times that I literally had chills running up and down my entire body and had to take a bit of a breather before entering certain areas.”
“Can't get into the atmosphere because I'm just sprinting around empty rooms, too many locked doors and empty drawers.”
“The inclusion of supernatural elements and the final scene ruins the previously methodical atmosphere.”
“The atmosphere was very well done and the town seemed real.”
gameplay
370 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
20%
73%
7%
The gameplay of "The Painscreek Killings" is characterized by a repetitive cycle of finding keys and codes to unlock doors and drawers, which some players found tedious and frustrating. While the investigative elements and story are engaging, many reviewers noted that the gameplay lacks depth and can feel monotonous, particularly due to the absence of meaningful puzzles and the reliance on exploration and document reading. Additionally, a sudden shift in gameplay mechanics towards the end left some players feeling jarring and detracted from the overall experience.
“The story is satisfying to piece together, solving puzzles and finding items generally isn't frustrating, and I like that there's no fast-travel mechanic-- walking through the town helps you digest what information you've just gotten and think about the story and characters.”
“The gameplay consists of gathering documents and diary entries to learn about the town and its characters who live there.”
“The gameplay is intuitive, and I never really felt like I was stuck on something.”
“The gameplay is very simple and it involves mostly reading and paying attention to details.”
“The gameplay of the Painscreek Killings isn't so much observing clues and uncovering secrets as it is just one massive scavenger hunt to find the hundreds of keys and codes to all the locked doors, drawers, and chests throughout the town.”
“Most of the gameplay is monotonous and consists of finding a key > finding the corresponding lock (many times across the map) > using the key > finding a document and another key > repeat.”
music
316 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
28%
60%
12%
The music in the game has received mixed reviews, with many players appreciating its atmospheric qualities that enhance the eerie and tense environment. However, a common criticism is its repetitiveness, as several tracks are short and loop frequently, leading some players to turn off the music entirely after a while. Overall, while the soundtrack effectively sets the mood, a desire for more variety and longer tracks is prevalent among reviewers.
“The atmosphere is spot on, the music is great, the controls are good.”
“The music and overall ambience make it anxiety-inducing at times but play into the experience the game is trying to give you.”
“The music creates an air of suspense as you investigate this abandoned town.”
“The music is horribly boring and repetitive.”
“The music is so extremely repetitive that it also needs to be mentioned.”
“The soundtrack is limited to like 4 repeating 30-60 second songs, which get quite old fast.”
graphics
289 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
36%
53%
11%
The graphics of the game receive mixed reviews, with some players praising their beauty and atmospheric quality, while others criticize them as dated or lacking detail. Many appreciate the immersive environment and the way visuals complement the storytelling, though technical issues and performance problems are noted by several users. Overall, while the graphics may not be cutting-edge, they effectively contribute to the game's engaging narrative and exploration experience.
“The graphics are beautiful and comparable to Bethesda.”
“Captivating story and gorgeous graphics & perfect atmosphere.”
“The graphics are stunning and the storyline is so well done.”
“The graphics are mid, with the design of the notes and newspapers just taking me out of the immersion.”
“The graphics and models are also horrendous; the ending borders on hilarious because of this.”
“The graphics are unfortunately horrible - even for a game from 2017.”
grinding
81 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
1%
4%
95%
The grinding aspect of the game is frequently described as tedious, with players noting the excessive backtracking, slow movement, and the need to search for keys and clues as particularly frustrating. While the engaging storyline and atmosphere help to mitigate some of the tedium, many reviewers feel that the constant roadblocks and repetitive tasks detract from the overall experience, making it feel more like a chore than an enjoyable exploration. Overall, players suggest that those who dislike meticulous detail and extensive exploration may find the game overly tedious.
“You'll need a second life for grinding.”
“A tedious, patience-grinding chore.”
“The only reason I swung towards negative (despite being really torn) is because of a few details: even the running is way too slow, it was tedious, a lot of the diary pages were in tiny fonts which I could not zoom in on which made it very frustrating to read, keys were so scattered that I had to go back and forth to different locations, there was no notepad in-game so I had to write my notes in real life (which isn't a huge problem but it would have been so much more convenient to be able to take notes in-game) and the locations had to be searched in a particular order with no guide at all so it's basically running around useless trial and error trying to figure out where to go and what to do without the map marker to even point out where you are.”
“Constant retracing of your steps in this game is another feature you have to endure to make any headway whatsoever and matching and looking for keys leading you on to one house to the next gets tedious.”
optimization
43 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
19%
46%
35%
The game's optimization has received significant criticism, with many players reporting performance issues such as stuttering, lag, and long loading times, particularly on systems that should handle it well. While some updates have been issued to address these concerns, the overall consensus is that the game is poorly optimized, leading to a frustrating experience for many users. Despite these issues, a few players noted that the game runs smoothly on higher-end systems, but the optimization remains a major drawback.
“They've also proactively issued several updates to address glitches and optimization issues; some even coming out the same day that the complaints were made.”
“To be honest, there have been a few bugs, but I think that was due to some places not being optimized, and I think they've fixed some of those issues, so good for them.”
“It can cause performance issues, but for the great gameplay and story, I guess we can look over that with a smile.”
“Either it's a problem with the Unity engine or the game's just not optimized correctly.”
“The game is poorly optimized and has long loading times.”
“The optimization is remarkably poor, with the game world broken up into small chunks with loading screens in between, like in an early 2000s game.”
emotional
41 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
98%
2%
The emotional aspect of the game is highly praised, with players expressing deep investment in the narrative and characters, often feeling a range of emotions from intrigue to heartbreak. The story's captivating twists and the haunting atmosphere contribute to a sense of immersion, making players feel like true detectives as they unravel the mysteries of the town. Many reviewers noted that the emotional weight of the plot left them feeling exhausted yet fulfilled, highlighting the game's ability to evoke strong feelings and create a memorable experience.
“It is a very unique game and I really enjoyed unraveling the mystery slowly, the story turning out quite heartfelt, with many different events tying everything together into a very cohesive narrative.”
“The story is emotional; I really liked it, it's tragic and has drama, and in the end, everything falls into place. There are no loose ends here, which I always love!”
“What unfolds is an engaging, emotional, and sometimes eerie story about people in a village, their history, their secrets, and their relationships.”
“My wife and I frequently try to get into adventure games together, with the detective/mystery genre being our favorite. However, nearly every game we play loses our interest for one reason or another, whether it's being too easy or difficult, having a boring story, being too unrealistic, or being too action-oriented.”
stability
37 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
8%
97%
The game's stability has received mixed reviews, with many players reporting various glitches and bugs, including visual issues and occasional game-breaking errors. While some users experienced significant problems, others noted that minor glitches did not detract from their overall enjoyment, and the developers have been responsive in addressing these issues. Overall, while the game shows promise, its stability remains a concern for many players.
“I experienced no glitches or frame rate issues, which is a relief compared to other games.”
“The game runs smoothly without any interruptions, making for a seamless experience.”
“I appreciate the stability; it allows me to fully immerse myself in the gameplay without distractions.”
“The game seemed promising, but it glitches out on newer systems.”
“Absolute buggy mess.”
“I encountered multiple glitches throughout my game, one of which prevents me from finishing the story/game at all.”
replayability
23 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
13%
65%
22%
Overall, the game has limited replayability, with many players noting that once the mystery is solved, there is little incentive to play again. While some appreciate the opportunity to explore for extras and achievements, the general consensus is that the experience is more of a one-time enjoyment rather than a game that invites repeated playthroughs. A few players mentioned that the freedom to explore enhances replayability slightly, but the predictability of the plot significantly diminishes it.
“The ability to roam freely about the town makes it so that you have a bit of freedom as to the order in which you solve and explore, which I think enhances replayability.”
“Though the replay value to any mystery is inherently pretty minimal, the first run through is such a great time that any mystery buff willing to put in a little love and effort will be repaid manyfold.”
“Worth every penny and there is definitely replay value for finding missed hints and getting all the achievements.”
“I don't feel like there is much replay value because once you know, you know.”
“It suffers from a lack of replayability due to the mystery being a one-and-done.”
“I really wanted to like this game, but it has zero replay value and the plot is incredibly easy to guess 2 or 3 journals in.”
humor
14 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The humor in the game is described as a mix of unintentional hilarity and intentional comedic moments, with players finding amusement in awkward graphics, goofy gameplay scenarios, and absurd plot twists. While some elements, like the ability to take funny in-game photos and the presence of cliché storylines, contribute to the humor, the overall experience is a blend of amusing and frustrating moments that may not appeal to everyone. Despite its flaws, players appreciate the lighthearted aspects that emerge throughout the gameplay.
“When I reached the hospital’s second floor, I couldn’t figure out where Sofia wanted me to go next, so I ended up juking the killer in the gym, which made for some funny, goofy moments.”
“Another standout was the (unnecessary but hilarious) ability to take photos with your in-game camera, which can lead to some very funny ending newspaper articles.”
“The story is very intriguing and the endings can range from funny to still kinda funny, fantastical, and stupid nonetheless.”
character development
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
67%
33%
The character development in the game is widely praised for its depth and emotional impact, with players highlighting the effective storytelling and the ability to evoke strong feelings through the characters' experiences. The use of diaries adds an additional layer to the narrative, enriching the player's connection to the characters even in an abandoned setting. Overall, the character arcs are described as astounding, contributing significantly to the game's haunting yet serene atmosphere.
“The atmosphere is haunting, yet serene at parts, and the character development was astounding.”
“The character development is extremely well done -- so much, in fact, that when I learned [spoiler] the fate of Trisha at the hospital [/spoiler], I audibly said to myself, 'nooo...' and it genuinely saddened me.”
“The character development is extremely well done -- so much, in fact, that when I learned [spoiler] the fate of Trisha at the hospital [/spoiler], I audibly said to myself, 'Nooo...' and it genuinely saddened me.”
“Although the town is abandoned, there is plenty of character development as you read people's diaries.”
monetization
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The monetization strategy of the game has received mixed feedback, with some users suggesting that improved advertising could enhance sales, particularly if a graphical overhaul is implemented. However, there are concerns that the marketing does not accurately represent the game's supernatural elements, leading to unmet expectations among players.
“I feel like the ending was not something expected by the advertising, or the tags on Steam.”
“The supernatural aspect of this game is not made clear enough through advertising, such that I was unaware of it before purchase.”