The Painscreek Killings
- September 26, 2017
- EQ Studios
- 10h median play time
In "The Painscreek Killings," become a journalist investigating the mysterious abandonment of a once-vibrant town. Solve logical puzzles, explore freely, and uncover dark secrets as you search for the truth behind the town's haunting past. This story-rich, murder mystery game encourages careful exploration and critical thinking.
Reviews
- Engaging and immersive story that keeps players guessing until the end.
- Encourages players to take notes and piece together clues, enhancing the detective experience.
- Atmospheric setting that creates a sense of tension and intrigue throughout the game.
- Gameplay can become tedious with excessive backtracking and searching for keys.
- Some puzzles are overly simplistic or poorly designed, leading to frustration.
- The ending features a jarring shift in gameplay style that may not resonate with all players.
- story1,510 mentions
- 43 % positive mentions
- 55 % neutral mentions
- 2 % negative mentions
The story of "The Painscreek Killings" is widely praised for its depth, complexity, and engaging narrative, which unfolds through diaries, letters, and other documents scattered throughout an abandoned town. Players appreciate the non-linear storytelling approach that allows them to piece together the mystery at their own pace, leading to a highly immersive experience. However, some critiques mention that the reliance on diary entries can feel tedious, and the gameplay mechanics may detract from the overall narrative flow, particularly towards the end. Overall, the game is recommended for those who enjoy rich, story-driven detective experiences.
“The story is breathtaking.”
“There are no plot holes, the details are cleverly connected, revealing some new side of what happened, and the actions of all the characters are logical, so it is easy to investigate, understand and move along the plot.”
“The story they weave is honestly mind-blowing to me.”
“The story is convoluted and often feels like a series of fetch quests rather than a cohesive investigation.”
“The game is heavy focused on story told through letters, diaries and so on and on exploring the map, finding keys, codes and solving little puzzles.”
“The story is built extremely well and it actually gets pretty tense and kind of haunting as the story progresses.”
- atmosphere322 mentions
- 57 % positive mentions
- 41 % neutral mentions
- 2 % negative mentions
The atmosphere of the game is widely praised for its eerie and immersive qualities, effectively creating a sense of tension and unease as players explore an abandoned town. Reviewers highlight the combination of haunting music, environmental design, and storytelling that draws them into the mystery, making the experience both captivating and unsettling. While some note that the atmosphere can become overwhelming or frustrating at times, the overall consensus is that it significantly enhances the gameplay and narrative.
“Atmospherically top notch, a great story, and a beautiful soundtrack.”
“Amazing atmosphere, you feel like someone is watching you throughout the whole game and the mystery is very cool to unravel even if it's mostly just finding clues and combining them together in your brain.”
“The atmosphere is incredible - the game feels like a horror game just because of the emptiness of everything and the music alongside it, but for the most part the spookiness stays there as an atmosphere and not something interfering with your gameplay.”
“The inclusion of supernatural elements and the final scene ruins the previously methodical atmosphere.”
“The atmosphere was tense and mysterious, even though there weren't people in the houses I felt scared at times.”
“The atmosphere is so thick and foreboding at times that I literally had chills running up and down my entire body and had to take a bit of a breather before entering certain areas.”
- gameplay298 mentions
- 20 % positive mentions
- 73 % neutral mentions
- 7 % negative mentions
The gameplay is primarily focused on exploration and puzzle-solving, involving a repetitive cycle of finding keys and codes to unlock various locations while piecing together a narrative through documents and journals. While some players appreciate the atmospheric storytelling and the investigative elements, many criticize the gameplay for being monotonous, tedious, and lacking in engaging mechanics, often feeling like a scavenger hunt with excessive backtracking. The introduction of new gameplay mechanics towards the end has also been noted as jarring, detracting from the overall experience.
“The gameplay is very simple and it involves mostly reading and paying attention to details.”
“There's lots of puzzles, an interesting story -- that makes you stay longing for more, nice plot twists, etc. That being said, I would 100% recommend the gameplay.”
“The gameplay consists of gathering documents and diary entries to learn about the town and its characters who live there.”
“On the bad side: the gameplay itself is often frustrating, with a lot of walking back-and-forth and having to very meticulously pixel hunt.”
“The gameplay of The Painscreek Killings isn't so much observing clues and uncovering secrets as it is just one massive scavenger hunt to find the hundreds of keys and codes to all the locked doors, drawers, and chests throughout the town.”
“Most of the gameplay is monotonous and consists of finding a key > finding the corresponding lock (many times across the map) > using the key > finding a document and another key > repeat.”
- music244 mentions
- 28 % positive mentions
- 60 % neutral mentions
- 12 % negative mentions
The music in the game is generally described as atmospheric and effective in creating tension, enhancing the immersive experience of the story and environment. However, many users noted that the soundtrack is repetitive, with limited variety and short loops that can become tedious over time. While some found the music haunting and fitting for the game's tone, others felt it detracted from the experience, leading them to turn it off or replace it with their own music.
“Atmospherically top notch, a great story, and a beautiful soundtrack.”
“The music is chilling, the story revelations shocking, and your stamina infinite.”
“The music, environmental design, and storytelling all work together perfectly and make the game feel like a genuine experience.”
“The music is so extremely repetitive that it also needs to be mentioned.”
“I had to turn the music off after just a few hours because it was so repetitive.”
“The soundtrack is terribly limited; I believe there are only two tracks in the entire game, and you'll end up listening to those two tracks on a constant loop for the entire 10+ hours that it takes to reach completion.”
- graphics234 mentions
- 36 % positive mentions
- 53 % neutral mentions
- 11 % negative mentions
The graphics of the game have received mixed reviews, with many players noting that while the visuals can be charming and immersive, they often feel outdated and lack polish. Some users reported performance issues, such as frame drops and high resource usage, even on lower settings, suggesting that the game is not well-optimized. Overall, while the graphics may not be groundbreaking, they serve the narrative and atmosphere effectively, with some players appreciating the aesthetic despite its limitations.
“The graphics are stunning and the story line is so well done.”
“The graphics are beautifully rendered with enough settings options for you to tailor the look of the game to your taste.”
“The graphics, though modest, perfectly complement the haunting and melancholic mood of the story.”
“The graphics are unfortunately horrible - even for a game from 2017.”
“Graphically, it's cheap.”
“The graphics are pretty terrible, even on the best settings, but honestly, it won't be long before you don't care.”
- grinding67 mentions
- 4 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 96 % negative mentions
The grinding aspect of the game is frequently described as tedious and time-consuming, with players noting excessive backtracking and the need to search for keys and clues leading to frustration. While some found the story engaging enough to push through the monotony, many reviewers felt that the repetitive tasks detracted from the overall experience, making exploration feel more like a chore than an adventure. Overall, the game balances intriguing narrative elements with a grind-heavy gameplay loop that may not appeal to all players.
“You'll need a second life for grinding.”
“You'll need a second life for grinding.”
“You'll need a second life for grinding.”
“A tedious, patience-grinding chore.”
“The game started out as an intriguing idea, but it quickly grew tedious.”
“Most of the time spent in this game is walking, tediously, from one point to another, finding the same old keys, opening the same doors.”
- emotional34 mentions
- 97 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 3 % negative mentions
Players report a deeply emotional experience while engaging with the game's story, often feeling invested in the characters and the haunting atmosphere of Painscreek. The combination of a compelling narrative, evocative music, and surprising plot twists leads to moments of tension and introspection, leaving many feeling emotionally exhausted yet fulfilled by the end. Overall, the game successfully immerses players in a detective role, prompting them to reflect on the characters' fates and the emotional weight of their discoveries.
“I was so deeply invested in the thrilling story, the atmosphere of the town, and uncovering the truth that I was left emotionally exhausted by the end, but to be honest... aren't those the best type of games?”
“What unfolds is an engaging, emotional, and sometimes eerie story about people in a village, their history, their secrets, and their relationships.”
“You become emotionally invested in the characters, and each time you uncover another piece of the puzzle, it is immensely gratifying.”
“My wife and I frequently try to get into adventure games together, but nearly every game we play loses our interest for one reason or another, whether it's a boring story or unrealistic elements.”
- optimization34 mentions
- 18 % positive mentions
- 56 % neutral mentions
- 26 % negative mentions
Overall, the game's optimization has received significant criticism, with many players reporting performance issues such as stuttering, low frame rates, and long loading times, particularly when using vsync. While some users noted that updates have addressed certain glitches, the consensus is that the game is poorly optimized, with outdated graphics and clunky controls contributing to a less than smooth experience. Despite these issues, a few players managed to enjoy the game, indicating that performance may vary depending on individual system specifications.
“Optimization: 4/5”
“They've also proactively issued several updates to address glitches and optimization issues; some even coming out the same day that the complaints were made.”
“To be honest, there have been a few bugs but I think that was due to some places not being optimized and I think they've fixed some of those issues, so good for them.”
“There are performance issues, especially with VSync on.”
“The game is poorly optimized and has long loading times.”
“The optimization is remarkably poor, with the game world broken up into small chunks with loading screens in between, like in an early 2000s game.”
- stability29 mentions
- 10 % positive mentions
- -7 % neutral mentions
- 97 % negative mentions
The game's stability has received mixed reviews, with many players reporting various glitches and bugs, including visual issues and occasional game-breaking problems. While some users experienced minimal issues and praised the developers for their quick responses to reported glitches, others found the game to be a "buggy mess" that hindered their enjoyment. Overall, stability appears to be a significant concern, though some players managed to enjoy the game despite its flaws.
“I experienced no glitches or frame rate issues, which is a refreshing change.”
“The game runs smoothly without any stability problems, making for an enjoyable experience.”
“I was impressed by the overall stability; everything worked as intended without any interruptions.”
“Absolute buggy mess.”
“I don't think it's my specs; the game is just a buggy mess even this long after release.”
“I actually stopped playing for a few weeks because of the constant freezes.”
- replayability17 mentions
- 18 % positive mentions
- 59 % neutral mentions
- 24 % negative mentions
Overall, the game's replayability is generally considered low, with many players noting that the experience is enjoyable but lacks complexity and depth for multiple playthroughs. While some appreciate the freedom to explore and the potential for completionist challenges, the consensus is that the plot is predictable, diminishing the incentive to replay. A few players suggest that it may still be worth revisiting for achievement hunting or to uncover missed details, but the majority feel it does not offer significant replay value.
“The ability to roam freely about the town makes it so that you have a bit of freedom as to the order in which you solve and explore, which I think enhances replayability.”
“Though the replay value to any mystery is inherently pretty minimal, the first run through is such a great time that any mystery buff willing to put in a little love and effort will be repaid manyfold.”
“Worth every penny and there is definitely replay value for finding missed hints and getting all the achievements.”
“It was an enjoyable experience, but not a complex, long, or replayable one.”
“Unfortunately, not much replayability here.”
“I really wanted to like this game, but it has zero replay value and the plot is incredibly easy to guess 2 or 3 journals in.”
- humor8 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The humor in the game is highlighted by its quirky features, such as the ability to take amusing in-game photos that result in comical newspaper articles. Players find humor in the absurdity of the village's multiple diaries and the reliance on visual storytelling and convenient diary entries, which adds a layer of irony to the narrative. While some plot twists may feel clichéd, the overall tone remains light-hearted, with players appreciating the game's comedic elements despite its serious premise.
“Another standout was the unnecessary but hilarious ability to take photos with your in-game camera, which can lead to some very funny ending newspaper articles.”
“It's a bit humorous that this entire village keeps multiple diaries, but whatever.”
“The game has pretty much no NPCs and dialogues, and it's mostly based on either visual storytelling or hilariously convenient diary entries.”
- character development5 mentions
- 60 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 40 % negative mentions
Character development in the game is highly praised, with reviewers highlighting its depth and emotional impact. The storytelling effectively enhances character arcs, making players feel a strong connection to the characters, as evidenced by poignant moments that evoke genuine reactions. The use of diaries adds an additional layer to character exploration, enriching the overall narrative experience.
“Great storytelling and character development.”
“The atmosphere is haunting, yet serene at parts, and the character development was astounding.”
“The character development is extremely well done -- so much, in fact, that when I learned [spoiler] the fate of Trisha at the hospital [/spoiler], I audibly said to myself, 'nooo...' and it genuinely saddened me.”
“The character development is extremely well done -- so much, in fact, that when I learned [spoiler] the fate of Trisha at the hospital [/spoiler], I audibly said to myself, 'Nooo...' and it genuinely saddened me.”
“Although the town is abandoned, there is plenty of character development as you read people's diaries.”
- monetization3 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
Reviewers express that while the game's monetization strategy could benefit from improved advertising and clearer communication of its supernatural elements, a graphical overhaul could enhance its appeal and potentially boost sales. Overall, there is a sense that better marketing could align player expectations with the game's content.
“The supernatural aspect of this game is not made clear enough through advertising, such that I was unaware of it before purchase.”
“I feel like the ending was not something expected by the advertising, or the tags on Steam.”