Games like Mysteries Under Lake Ophelia
Looking for games like Mysteries Under Lake Ophelia? Here are top casual simulation recommendations with a horror focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Dredge, Fatum Betula or Wretched Depths.
1 89%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, replayability96% User Score 42,766 reviewsCritic Score 82%48 reviewsDREDGE is a single-player fishing adventure with a sinister undercurrent.
View GameView Game
2 
93%Game Brain Scoreatmosphere, graphicsgrinding, replayability96% User Score 775 reviewsCritic Score 83%3 reviewsPlaced in a world without change, you must create fate by watering an ancient plant. Determine a future and live with it.
View GameView Game
3 
97%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregrinding97% User Score 378 reviewsPlay as Sam and fish to your hearts content, sell fish you've caught, collect better gear, and use it to explore the depths of the mysterious lake, but be warned as no one knows what lies at the bottom. Wretched Depths is a PSX-style horror fishing game created by students at the University of Utah.
View GameView Game
4 
96%Game Brain Scoregameplay, graphicsstory, grinding96% User Score 4,071 reviewsCast n Chill is a cozy idle (and active) fishing game where you explore serene lakes, rivers, and oceans. Catch rare fish, upgrade your gear and reel in legendary catches - all with your loyal companion by your side.
View GameView Game
5 
83%Game Brain Scoremusic, storyreplayability, stability88% User Score 1,006 reviewsCritic Score 70%3 reviewsDreaming Sarah is an adventure game where you explore the dream world of a young girl named Sarah, who is in a deep coma. Collect items and abilities as you solve puzzles, interact with people and objects to try to wake up.
View GameView Game
6 
85%Game Brain Scoreatmosphere, storygrinding, replayability85% User Score 3,070 reviewsThe Convenience Store is a J-horror game about a college girl on a night shift.
View GameView Game
7 
91%Game Brain Scoremusic, atmospheregrinding, stability91% User Score 11,674 reviewsLunacid is a first person dungeon crawler inspired by old FROMSOFT games like Shadow Tower and King’s Field.
View GameView Game
8 
76%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplayoptimization, replayability91% User Score 3,881 reviewsCritic Score 57%8 reviewsInspired by Gone Home and Dear Esther, Scanner Sombre is a cave exploration experience. With stunning visuals and a terrifying theme, it is the 6th major video game released by Introversion Software.
View GameView Game
9 
88%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, grinding92% User Score 1,512 reviewsCritic Score 77%2 reviewsA serial killer is terrorizing the city, and Sara's deadbeat boyfriend hasn't done the laundry. Can Sara survive a late-night trip to the laundromat, or will the Womb Ripper perform an early delivery?
View GameView Game
10 
70%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregrinding, character development70% User Score 1,736 reviewsFollow us About the GameHome is a unique horror adventure set in a beautifully-realized pixel world. It’s a murder mystery with a twist—because you decide what ultimately happens. Awakened by an oncoming storm, you open your eyes to discover yourself in a strange, dark room—tucked away in a house that’s not yours. As you play the game, it changes—subtly, almost imperceptibly—to reflect your pe…
View GameView Game
