Games like Sinking Island
Looking for games like Sinking Island? Here are top arcade puzzle recommendations with a mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Black Mirror, Sherlock Holmes: The Silver Earring or The Testament of Sherlock Holmes.
1 77%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregameplay, grinding76% User Score 550 reviewsCritic Score 80%1 reviewsBlack Mirror is a dark adventure game that details the aftermath of the tragic death of William Gordon. Playing as his grandson Samuel players must unveil the truth behind the events of that fateful, stormy night.
View GameView Game
2 
53%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgameplay, stability53% User Score 542 reviewsThe party Sherlock Holmes and his trusted friend, Dr. Watson, have been invited to turns into tragedy: a murder is committed right before their very eyes. Our famous detective is on the case immediately, but the list of suspects is getting no shorter, while other crimes are being committed. Will you succeed in uncovering the truth before other innocent people suffer? Experience an amazing plot, wr…
View GameView Game
3 
77%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, stability76% User Score 2,124 reviewsCritic Score 80%2 reviewsBuzz About the GameYOU ARE SHERLOCK HOLMES, AND THIS IS YOUR INVESTIGATION! Become the greatest detective of all time in The Testament of Sherlock Holmes, a twisting, turning investigation game set in a faithfully-reproduced London of 1898. Suspected in a case involving theft, fraud and double-crossing, Sherlock Holmes will undergo a descent into hell in what will doubtlessly become one of his …
View GameView Game
4 
67%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, character development67% User Score 332 reviewsRunaway: A Road Adventure is a point and click adventure game developed by Péndulo Studios, S.L. in 2001. The game follows the long tradition of two-dimensional adventure games like the first two installments of the Broken Sword series. It enjoyed immense popularity in countries like Germany and France, where the adventure genre is still popular.
View GameView Game
5 
49%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygraphics, stability49% User Score 306 reviewsAfter returning to the quiet streets of Paris to pursue a life of painting, Gus Macpherson could not escape his true art… The former New York detective finds himself walking the beat once again, when hired by a sensuous woman to investigate the gruesome beheadings of her sister and brother-in-law. In the dark and mysterious streets of Paris and plagued by his clairvoyant sixth sense, Gus will unc…
View GameView Game
6 
73%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, grinding77% User Score 1,363 reviewsCritic Score 65%11 reviewsThe ABC Murders is an adventure and investigation game adapted from the classic Agatha Christie novel. You are the famous private detective Hercule Poirot and, once again, you find yourself up against a mysterious serial killer who goes by the name of "ABC".
View GameView Game
7 
85%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsstability, grinding87% User Score 1,106 reviewsCritic Score 81%11 reviewsUnforeseen Incidents is a classical style interactive mystery set in a beautifully hand-painted world. Join Harper Pendrell and experience a challenging investigation, smart dialog and a rich cast of characters in this thrilling new adventure game.
View GameView Game
8 
73%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, replayability74% User Score 506 reviewsCritic Score 69%4 reviewsDiscover an untold crime story from the mysterious youth of the famous detective Hercule Poirot.
View GameView Game
9 
49%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregraphics, gameplay49% User Score 136 reviewsAfter returning to the quiet streets of Paris to pursue a life of painting, Gus Macpherson could not escape his true art… The former New York detective finds himself walking the beat once again, when hired by a sensuous woman to investigate the gruesome beheadings of her sister and brother-in-law. In the dark and mysterious streets of Paris and plagued by his clairvoyant sixth sense, Gus will unc…
View GameView Game
10 
76%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplayoptimization, grinding78% User Score 2,466 reviewsCritic Score 74%34 reviewsIn this story-driven detective thriller, a young Sherlock Holmes struggles to prove himself as he navigates an exotic, dangerous island in the Mediterranean to investigate the mystery of his mother’s death. As Sherlock, your legacy is written by the decisions you make in this open world. Deception, violence, and deduction are just a few resources in your arsenal—your mysterious companion and soun…
View GameView Game
