Games like Only If
Looking for games like Only If? Here are top puzzle recommendations with a horror, fantasy and mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Serena, Lucius or Escape Room: The Sick Colleague.
1 77%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospherereplayability, grinding77% User Score 4,318 reviewsSerena is a freeware horror adventure game developed by several video game development companies, including Senscape, CBE Software, Infamous Quests, Digital Media Workshop and Guys from Andromeda.
View GameView Game


2 72%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, replayability79% User Score 2,613 reviewsCritic Score 45%5 reviewsWhen Lucius was born on June 6th, 1966, nobody expected him to be anything other than a normal little boy but everything changed on Lucius’ 6th Birthday, when his true calling was revealed to him. Equipped with supernatural powers, take control of Lucius as he begins his blood-filled tour of horror through his own house, using Hell’s powers of telekinesis and mind control to orchestrate deadly acc…
View GameView Game


3 80%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, grinding80% User Score 4,672 reviewsYou only wanted to make a visit to your sick colleague, but what you encounter is beyond your imagination. Discover the secrets of your colleague and find a way to escape the trap.
View GameView Game


4 54%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsstability, grinding54% User Score 1,172 reviewsDream’s gameplay is strongly based around exploration with games such as Yume Nikki and LSD being the initial inspiration for the concept. On top of this we have been inspired by the narrative elements in Dear Esther and Deus Ex’s non-linear story telling and environments, the resulting gameplay maintains aspects of all 4 games. There will be many puzzles to solve, horror sections and some more na…
View GameView Game


5 73%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsoptimization, stability73% User Score 1,826 reviewsJOIN OUR DISCORD About the GameThe Timeless Child is a 2-player puzzle-adventure coop game with first-person view. Start an exciting and engaging adventure, a tale about family, bonds and secrets. You will explore Wells Manor, an ancient 16th century villa full of history and secrets, living the experience from two different temporal perspectives. Whether you decide to take on the role of Chri…
View GameView Game


6 72%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsstability, character development75% User Score 4,847 reviewsCritic Score 70%11 reviewsEnter the world of The Dark Pictures - A series of standalone cinematic horror games. Players will be challenged to explore and uncover each story with the knowledge that all their choices have consequences and all playable characters can live, any and all can die...
View GameView Game


7 73%Game Brain Scorehumor, storyoptimization, replayability81% User Score 1,725 reviewsCritic Score 65%14 reviewsChanneling elements of Monty Python and the funnier episodes of the X-Files, Maize is an absurdist, first-person adventure with a cornucopia of highbrow puzzles to solve, talking oddities to meet, and mysteries to be harvested.
View GameView Game


8 71%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, replayability69% User Score 6,360 reviewsCritic Score 76%5 reviewsBuy Twelve Minutes for PS4 & PS5 and solve a gripping mystery to break a nightmare time loop in this top-down thriller.
View GameView Game


9 82%Game Brain Scorestory, humorstability, grinding82% User Score 2,494 reviewsShowered in top-scores and awards, the Deponia-Trilogy, created by the developers of Edna&Harvey: The Breakout, The Whispered World and Memoria, managed to reach cult-status almost instantly. Thanks to its exciting story, likeable characters and hilarious dialogues and a finely crafted mixture of comedy and puzzles, Deponia is enjoyable for both, young and old. Join Rufus on his thrilling journeys…
View GameView Game


10 69%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregameplay, stability69% User Score 600 reviewsGod's Basement is a first-person, narrative-driven, single player horror game. Uncover the secrets of an afterlife shrouded in mystery, as an entity known as "The Operator" leads you deeper into fringes of a seemingly eternal purgatory.
View GameView Game












