Games like It Could Happen to You
Looking for games like It Could Happen to You? Here are top casual action adventure recommendations with a horror and mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with The Song Out of Space, The Long Reach or Dreams in the Witch House.
In 1962, during the height of the Cold War, twelve astronomers at a deep-space observatory were found dead. Because of the proximity of an important military base, two federal agents were sent to investigate any Russian involvement... And what they found was from beyond this world. Choose to play as federal agent Catherine Armstrong, a young recruit with excellent scientific skills, or as Stuart R… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Song Out of Space.
View Game


- 83%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgameplay, replayability83% User Score 328 reviews
"Calm down. This is all normal. Well, it’s a new normal. There was a malfunction that we can’t fix yet, but with your help I can make symptoms bearable. We’re all in the same boat here and should help each other." "I’m Shelly, a lead scientist in General Education research facility. The job title is longer, but it’s not important. Here’s what I know so far, though." "The experience-sharing program… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Long Reach.
View Game


- 92%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, stability92% User Score 317 reviews
Dreams in the Witch House is an open world horror adventure game, where you guide Walter Gilman, as he prepares to face the dreaded May-Eve witch ritual in the legend-haunted city of Arkham. Choose your own approach and reveal the secret of the Witch House before it's too late. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Dreams in the Witch House.
View Game


- 96%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, replayability96% User Score 923 reviews
Experience death from the comfort of your seat. A compilation of five short stories which occur in different eras and locations, touching on themes like time travel, black magic, and immortality. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Critters for Sale.
View Game


- 74%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospherecharacter development, replayability74% User Score 117 reviews
Saint Kotar is a psychological horror adventure set in an ancient rural town of Croatia. Take on the role of two godly men trying to unravel the terrifying truth behind the town's occult happenings and the disappearance of their relative. Find your humanity -- or descend into madness and death. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Saint Kotar.
View Game


- 85%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, character development90% User Score 210 reviewsCritic Score 70%3 reviews
Mothmen 1966 is a 'Pixel Pulp' - a visual novel fusing exceptional writing and stunning illustration, inspired by mid-20th century pulp fiction and 80s home computer graphics - set amongst the strange occurrences of the Leonid meteor shower of 1966. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Mothmen 1966.
View Game


- 84%Game Brain Scoremusic, storyoptimization, replayability89% User Score 1,104 reviewsCritic Score 60%1 reviews
The sequel to Off-Peak, The Norwood Suite is a surreal first-person adventure game by Cosmo D. Journey to the secluded Hotel Norwood, where odd characters, forgotten secrets, and head-nodding music await. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Norwood Suite.
View Game


- 87%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, replayability92% User Score 2,335 reviewsCritic Score 82%14 reviews
A Detective Is Born If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Kathy Rain.
View Game


- 89%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, replayability94% User Score 1,872 reviewsCritic Score 84%18 reviews
Norco is a Southern Gothic point & click narrative adventure that immerses the player in the sinking suburbs and verdant industrial swamps of a distorted South Louisiana. Your brother Blake has gone missing in the aftermath of your mother's death. In the hopes of finding him, you must follow a fugitive security android through the refineries, strip malls, and drainage ditches of suburban New Orlea… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to NORCO.
View Game


- 90%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, character development96% User Score 1,981 reviewsCritic Score 84%10 reviews
Dear Applicant, I am pleased to offer you the role of Apprentice Thaumaturge at Strange Antiquities. You show promise – a sharp mind and a strong stomach – exactly what this work demands. I need you to run the shop while I attend to other pressing matters. You will need a keen eye for detail as you provide the townsfolk of Undermere with occult objects for their arcane needs. Undermere might se… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Strange Antiquities.
View Game










