Games like Scarlet Hollow
Looking for games like Scarlet Hollow? Here are top casual role playing recommendations with a horror and mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Slay the Princess, The Letter or The Crown of Leaves.
1 View Game92%Game Brain Scorestory, musicgrinding, stability98% User Score 22,352 reviewsCritic Score 87%18 reviews"Slay the Princess" is a challenging 2D platformer that tasks you with defeating the titular princess across multiple stages. Use an array of weapons and abilities to navigate treacherous terrain and confront a variety of enemies. With tight controls and retro-inspired graphics, this game offers a satisfying and replayable experience for fans of the genre.
View Game2 View Game88%Game Brain Scorestory, musicgrinding, stability88% User Score 1,620 reviews"The Letter" is a horror/drama visual novel inspired by Asian horror films like "The Grudge" and "The Ring." Players encounter mature and disturbing themes, offensive language, and violence through the perspective of seven characters, with branching narratives and multiple endings. The game contains strong trigger warnings, advising players to exercise discretion.
View Game3 View Game95%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, optimization95% User Score 608 reviews"The Crown of Leaves" is a visually striking hybrid of non-kinetic visual novel and point-n-click adventure. Players follow the story of Roui, a resilient city dandy who returns to his rural homeland, Latori, after a failure. Struggling with local mystical beliefs and seeking a way back to his old life, Roui's fate becomes intertwined with a prosperous order, leading to mystical riddles, ghosts, and beasts. Handcrafted illustrations and original music enhance the immersive atmosphere in this intriguing debut game.
View Game4 View Game91%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, grinding98% User Score 3,156 reviewsCritic Score 85%16 reviews"Beacon Pines is a single-player mystery visual novel game with an intriguing story set in a mysterious book. As the reader and main character Luka, you'll uncover hidden truths, make friends, and collect golden charms with engraved words that can change the course of fate. The Chronicle, an interactive story tree, allows you to navigate turning points and alter the story's outcome."
View Game5 View Game93%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, stability97% User Score 5,442 reviewsCritic Score 89%12 reviews"I Was a Teenage Exocolonist" is a narrative-driven, life simulation game where your choices shape your character's development. As a teenager on a distant exoplanet, you'll manage resources, form relationships, and face challenges that determine your unique story. Every decision you make contributes to the person you become, offering a deeply personal and replayable experience.
View Game6 View Game95%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, grinding95% User Score 1,137 reviewsCabernet is a single-player horror RPG set in a 19th-century Eastern European-inspired world, blending supernatural and political intrigue. Play as Liza, a young vampire wrestling with morality, as you explore a hauntingly atmospheric story filled with decadence, sacrifice, and choice. Featuring exceptional gameplay, stunning visuals, and an emotional, replayable experience.
View Game7 View Game97%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, stability97% User Score 14,426 reviews"Sally Face" is a pixel art adventure game with psychological horror elements. You play as Sal Fisher, a boy with a prosthetic face, moving to a new apartment with his dad and uncovering supernatural mysteries in the building. The game features episodic storytelling, dialogue choices, and a unique cast of characters.
View Game8 View Game88%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, stability95% User Score 3,444 reviewsCritic Score 81%20 reviewsIn "The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood" , players step into the role of Fortuna, a Witch returning to her coven after a 200-year-long exile. Through Tarot-inspired card creation and divination, you'll explore the pasts and futures of your fellow Witches and navigate a political plot that will determine the fate of the Cosmic Witch society. This thought-provoking narrative experience delves into themes of identity, community, and personal responsibility within a hand-crafted universe.
View Game9 View Game87%Game Brain Scorestory, musicstability, grinding96% User Score 52,473 reviewsCritic Score 75%8 reviewsLife is Strange is an award-winning Adventure game that offers a stunning story with excellent gameplay and marvelous graphics, accompanied by excellent music. The game features a wholesome story that will make you laugh, but beware of the numerous bugs. Your choices in the game can significantly impact the story, making each playthrough unique.
View Game10 View Game96%Game Brain Scorestory, musicgameplay, character development96% User Score 469 reviewsA free horror Visual Novel about an ill-fated journey across Sinnlos, a lake where awful monsters lurk just beneath the surface. With times being so dire you'll need to decide what, and who, is going to be sacrificed. Anyone can be saved, but not everyone can be.
View Game









