Games like Aye Aye, Captain

"Abandon Ship" is a naval combat game set in a fantastical Age of Sail world, where you battle enemy ships and sea monsters in treacherous environments. With a wide range of unique, story-filled islands to discover, each voyage brings new challenges and the risk of permanent death. The game's Art Style is reminiscent of classic Naval Oil Paintings, adding to its immersive atmosphere.

Become king of pirates while sailing through seaports, battles, krakens & navy

"The Pirate: Caribbean Hunt" is a high seas adventure game that allows players to navigate the Caribbean in the golden age of piracy. Build and upgrade your fleet, engage in ship-to-ship combat, and explore ports while completing quests to build your reputation. The game features a variety of customization options, including ship design and weapon loadouts. However, some players have criticized the game for repetitive gameplay and a lack of engaging story.

Feral Blue is a strategic, pirate-themed MMO where players build and manage their own floating fortress while navigating a dangerous open world. Engage in real-time naval battles, trade, and diplomacy while battling other players and AI-controlled factions for dominance. With a focus on player-driven economy and politics, Feral Blue offers a unique and immersive experience in a vast, procedurally generated sea.

Her Majesty's Ship is a naval warfare simulation game that puts you in command of a 19th-century Royal Navy ship. Outfit your vessel with crew, weapons, and equipment, then sail into battle against enemy fleets and engage in strategic combat. With a focus on historical accuracy and tactical depth, Her Majesty's Ship offers a challenging and immersive experience for fans of nautical warfare.

"Corsairs Legacy - Pirate Action RPG & Sea Battles" is a story-driven adventure game where you play as Rufus Monroe, an adventurous smuggler in the Caribbean. After a raid goes wrong, you'll face dangerous voyages, perilous piracy, and fatal fights against powerful enemies. The game is designed according to historical prototypes and challenges you to survive the dangers of the Caribbean and become a legendary pirate.

"Cursed Crew" is an Early Access game that allows players to choose from various curses and experiment with their effects. The game plans to add more bosses, creatures, an expanded world map, crew member traits, more playable ships, Steam Workshop support, and additional language support. Players can also look forward to new features yet to be announced.

"Sail Forth" is a high seas adventure game where you sail and battle across a procedurally generated ocean. Customize your ship, complete quests, and discover mysterious islands. Engage in ship-to-ship combat and upgrade your vessel for ultimate domination on the water.

Tempest: Pirate RPG Premium is a swashbuckling adventure that lets you navigate an open world, complete over a hundred quests, and assemble a formidable crew. Engage in naval warfare, trade, and plunder, while also battling sea monsters and harnessing mystic crystals for powerful attacks. Play solo or join forces with friends to conquer the seas together.

Forgotten Seas is a survival game set in the Bermuda Void, an endless ocean filled with islands that appear and disappear in time. To survive, you'll need to craft a ship and navigate treacherous waters filled with bounty, treasure, and danger. Ships are magical and can be stored in bottles, allowing you to build a fleet for various purposes. The goal is to conquer the forgotten seas and rule the waters.