Port Royale 4
- September 17, 2020
- Gaming Minds
- 13h median play time
A good management game with superb visuals, offering enough freedom to let you build your own merchant empire in the Caribbean to your heart’s content.
Port Royale 4 is a strategy game set in the 17th-century Caribbean. Players can choose to be a part of four colonial powers, engaging in trade, exploration, and naval warfare. The game features a realistic economic system, detailed city-building, and tactical combat in both single-player and multiplayer modes.
Reviews
- The game features beautiful graphics and a well-designed map, enhancing the overall visual experience.
- The turn-based naval battles add a strategic layer to the gameplay, allowing for thoughtful decision-making during combat.
- The trading mechanics are engaging, with the ability to set up automated trade routes and manage supply chains effectively.
- The combat system is overly simplistic and lacks depth, making battles feel repetitive and unengaging.
- The fame system is frustrating, as it can be difficult to gain fame while managing trade routes and town development.
- Many players feel that the game lacks the complexity and features of previous titles in the series, leading to a sense of disappointment.
- gameplay95 mentions
- 22 % positive mentions
- 67 % neutral mentions
- 11 % negative mentions
The gameplay of Port Royale 4 has received mixed reviews, with many players appreciating the improved graphics and trading mechanics but criticizing the combat system as simplistic and tedious. While some enjoy the depth of economic management and the new mechanics like trade winds, others find the overall gameplay repetitive and lacking in depth compared to previous titles in the series. The game offers a streamlined experience that may appeal to newcomers, but long-time fans of the franchise often feel it falls short of expectations.
“Overall, I'm having a blast playing this, and with the auto-management of buying and selling on my trade routes, I can focus on other parts of the gameplay.”
“Great graphics, animations, gameplay, and strategic/management thinking required.”
“The gameplay is entertaining, but repetitive.”
“The mechanics to break this feel clunky and complicated.”
“Pretty decent economic sim and management game ruined by the inclusion of mediocre battle mechanics that you cannot avoid unless you want your entire trade stock being thrown in the water every 5 seconds by endlessly spawning pirates that your nation's war fleets seemingly have no interest in defeating.”
“Unfortunately, while the game is gorgeous, as many other reviews have stated, Port Royale 4 drastically dumbs down gameplay mechanics to the point of borderline boredom.”
- graphics93 mentions
- 47 % positive mentions
- 49 % neutral mentions
- 3 % negative mentions
The graphics in the game have received mixed reviews, with many praising the improved visuals and beautiful design, while others criticize them for feeling outdated or simplistic compared to previous titles. Some players appreciate the seamless transitions and atmospheric effects, but others feel that the focus on graphics has come at the expense of gameplay depth and content. Overall, while the graphics are generally considered a highlight, they are not universally acclaimed, with some players expressing disappointment in their execution and performance issues.
“Amazing and improved graphics.”
“Beautiful graphics!”
“The graphics are great, the trading simulation engine seems pretty good, and it seems to have a lot of depth.”
“Graphics are terrible.”
“I know that not every game has such beautiful, almost lifelike images as medieval dynasty and kingdom come deliverance, but graphically this game doesn't even make it to the middle ages, at most the stone age.”
“And normally graphics don't matter, but seriously, the graphics look like they came straight from the early 2000s, right down to the low-res prerendered intro cutscene, the pixelated portraits for characters, and the incomprehensible mess that is the town hexes, where you can't even tell what they are without selecting each one (not even a hover-over!).”
- story31 mentions
- 10 % positive mentions
- 71 % neutral mentions
- 19 % negative mentions
The story aspect of the game is criticized for its lack of depth and variety, with missions often reduced to repetitive fetch quests and combat tasks that feel tedious and uninspired. Players express disappointment in the absence of engaging narratives or character development, noting that the quest system is overly simplistic and lacks meaningful interactions with town governors. While the game includes some elements of town management and side quests, these are often seen as shallow and unfulfilling, leading to a monotonous gameplay experience.
“I am really enjoying this game; it reminds me of East India Company in a way, but adds town management and side quests that will pop up during your voyages.”
“There are, admittedly imperfect, quests that can be done for either the viceroy of your nation or individual towns.”
“Dialogue with town governors and quests for popularity in town.”
“The tasks are monotonous and lack any story or progression.”
“There are missions and treasure maps, and again, they're shallow without much depth in either system.”
“They don't have a game story writer - this feels like it was written by devs.”
- music16 mentions
- 56 % positive mentions
- 25 % neutral mentions
- 19 % negative mentions
The music in the game is widely praised for its quality and ability to enhance the gameplay experience, with many players noting its relaxing and immersive qualities. The soundtrack is described as fitting well with the pirate theme, reminiscent of iconic scores like that of "Pirates of the Caribbean," though some players express a desire for more variety or additional pirate-themed tracks. Overall, the music contributes positively to the game's artistic interface and ambiance, making it a notable aspect of the experience.
“Best pirate music since Pirates of the Caribbean.”
“The game has a very beautiful, artistic interface, as well as a relaxing soundtrack.”
“I enjoy the music; it would be nice if we could have a Steam Workshop so we can mod, for instance, people that want more pirate music can add it to the game.”
“The ambiance of tropical birds, calming music, and the blue Caribbean sea is captivating.”
- grinding15 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
Players consistently find the grinding aspect of the game to be tedious and repetitive, often detracting from the overall enjoyment. Many reviews highlight the frustration of engaging in numerous manual battles and the slow progression due to arbitrary limitations, which can lead to a sense of burnout. While some appreciate the rewarding elements of building and trading, the overwhelming micromanagement and lengthy grinding sessions overshadow these positives.
“Every game I have ever played that has included grinding has been repetitive and highly tedious, and PR4 excels in this regard.”
“So you have to embark on this absolutely tedious exercise of trying to fight against a superior enemy which takes you right out of the flow of the main game and into this boring and frustrating mini-game where you are outmanned and outgunned from the start.”
“The naval battles are fun for a while but become repetitive quickly and more tedious than anything else.”
- optimization6 mentions
- 50 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 50 % negative mentions
The optimization of the game has received mixed reviews, with some players experiencing severe performance issues on lower-end hardware, particularly with a GTX 970, while others report smooth gameplay without any significant problems. Many users feel that the minimum system requirements are misleading, suggesting that a GTX 1060 or better is necessary for reasonable performance. Overall, the game's optimization appears inconsistent, leading to a divided player experience.
“In other words, the store page massively understates minimum playable requirements; I can't imagine you will have reasonable performance short of at least a 1060, if not a 1070.”
“I have also had very few computer performance issues, which isn't always the case for new titles.”
“For the time I have played, I never had any issues with this game; everything runs smoothly and pretty :)”
“The campaign was poorly made and poorly optimized; I regret buying this game.”
“Unplayable performance on GTX 970 4GB.”
“In other words, the store page massively understates minimum playable requirements. I can't imagine you will have reasonable performance short of at least a 1060, if not a 1070.”
- humor5 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The humor in the game is characterized by absurd and ironic situations, such as a comically inept adviser and a viceroy who criticizes players for not managing pirates while simultaneously hindering their ability to do so. Players also find humor in the exaggerated traits of characters, particularly the one-sided advantages and disadvantages that create a ridiculous imbalance. Additionally, the unrealistic combat mechanics add to the comedic tone, making the gameplay experience both entertaining and frustrating.
“The humorous adviser will then tell you about this, and you have to manually solve the problem.”
“The funny part is when the viceroy berates you for not dealing with the pirates while at the same time refusing to allow you 'licenses' for ship captains to help you do that, dude, wtf?”
“Okay, maybe I can understand that; it's easier to command 4-5 ships and the battles in PR3 were a bit funny and unrealistic.”
- replayability3 mentions
- 67 % positive mentions
- -33 % neutral mentions
- 67 % negative mentions
The game offers a mixed experience in terms of replayability; while some players find it has endless replay value, others feel it lacks incentive for multiple playthroughs. Suggestions for improvement include enhancing character options and streamlining gameplay mechanics to reduce downtime and improve responsiveness, particularly during naval battles.
“+ endless replayability”
“However, improvements can be made to increase the replay value of the game (character, etc) and to streamline further the long process of finishing a campaign or a free mode gameplay through providing more hotkeys and minimizing game reloading due to the game being not sensitive enough for clicks, especially during naval battles.”
“Ok for a single playthrough, but doesn't really have any replay value.”
“However, improvements can be made to increase the replay value of the game (character, etc.) and to streamline further the long process of finishing a campaign or a free mode gameplay by providing more hotkeys and minimizing game reloading due to the game being not sensitive enough for clicks, especially during naval battles.”
- stability3 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
The stability of the game has been widely criticized, with users reporting numerous bugs and a lack of thorough testing, particularly in the DLCs. Many feel that the game represents a significant downgrade from its predecessors, citing shallow gameplay and limited content as additional concerns. Overall, the development team's slow response to these issues has further exacerbated player dissatisfaction.
“To say it's buggy is a gross understatement.”
“Pretty shallow gameplay, fewer options and content than the predecessors, developers are working really slowly on everything, absolutely untested and buggy DLCs.”
“Port Royale 4 is just a total downgrade with their turn-based, trashy, buggy, super boring gameplay.”
- atmosphere2 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The game's atmosphere is widely regarded as its strongest feature, enhanced by impressive graphical presentation. However, the shift to a round-based battle system may not appeal to all players.
“The atmosphere is definitely the strongest quality of this game.”
“The graphical presentation is nice and atmospheric.”
Critic Reviews
Port Royale 4 Review – Below Deck
The complex systems at Port Royale 4’s core never flourish under the weight of its uninspired moment-to-moment gameplay and lack of structural balance.
50%Port Royale 4 Review
A good management game with superb visuals, offering enough freedom to let you build your own merchant empire in the Caribbean to your heart’s content.
80%Port Royale 4 Review – A Caribbean Corsair’s Calling
Port Royale 4 is a solid trading and building management sim. The improved visuals, as well as some improved mechanics, help set this apart, as does the tactical turn-based ship combat. It's very user-friendly and intuitive, particularly with the city building and trade-route creating aspects. However, it isn't without flaws. Side quests feel very repetitive and don't really give you enough to do and the campaign can be too rigid, not giving you the amount of time you'd need to do anything other than the bare minimum for the tasks set. If you like this sort of game, Port Royale 4 is likely just up your alley, but I can't see it converting anybody to the cause.
65%