Games like Lost To Darkness
Looking for games like Lost To Darkness? Here are top shooter recommendations with a horror focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with DREDGE, The Shore or In Sound Mind.
1 View Game89%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, replayability96% User Score 42,766 reviewsCritic Score 82%48 reviewsDredge is a fishing horror exploration game where you captain a trawler to discover the secrets of remote islands and their depths. Sell your catch to unlock upgrades, complete quests to uncover each area's past, and avoid the horrors that lurk in the darkness. The Pale Reach DLC adds an additional frozen biome with new challenges and story to explore.
View Game2 View Game66%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgameplay, stability71% User Score 1,798 reviewsCritic Score 53%3 reviews"The Shore" is a narrative-driven adventure game where players uncover the mysteries of a strange island. Through exploration, puzzle-solving, and interaction with non-playable characters, players delve into the memories and emotions of the inhabitants to understand the island's enigmatic past. With its beautiful art style and immersive atmosphere, "The Shore" invites players to reflect on themes of loss, love, and the passage of time.
View Game3 View Game91%Game Brain Scorestory, musicoptimization, grinding95% User Score 3,854 reviewsCritic Score 83%4 reviews"In Sound Mind" is a first-person psychological horror game where players uncover a series of tape recordings left behind by a mysterious researcher. As they delve deeper into the tapes' contents, they must navigate surreal landscapes and confront distorted memories to unravel a nefarious plot. The game features immersive puzzles, a haunting soundtrack, and a unique blend of psychological and supernatural horror elements.
View Game4 View Game82%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsoptimization, stability83% User Score 510 reviewsCritic Score 77%2 reviews"Aporia: Beyond The Valley" is a first-person adventure game set in a mystical, ancient world. Players explore this beautiful but ruined land, solving puzzles to uncover the story of its lost civilization. With no combat or dialogue, the game emphasizes exploration and discovery in a serene, atmospheric setting.
View Game5 View Game61%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgameplay, music61% User Score 110 reviews"Enola" is a single-player Horror Simulation game with a gripping story and perfect atmosphere, immersing players in the tortured memories of Angelica. The game features frighteningly calculated death-traps and multiple endings, decided by the player's actions, all without relying on paranormal elements. The suspenseful experience offers a chilling in-depth look into Angelica's broken mind and traumatic past.
View Game6 View Game91%Game Brain Scoregameplay, storyoptimization, stability91% User Score 564 reviewsThe next chapter in the haunting Dread X Collection series. Co-produced by the legendary David Szymanski (DUSK, The Music Machine, Squirrel Stapler), Dread X Collection: The Hunt showcases 7 all-new short horror shooters from a handpicked selection of creative and unique indie developers. Continuing the Dread X Collection story, you play as series newcomer Artemis. Driven by a cryptic message rec…
View Game7 View Game74%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregameplay, music74% User Score 78 reviewsLazaretto is a first-person survival horror game, where you play as an urban explorer investigating an abandoned quarantine island. With a focus on atmospheric horror and combat-free gameplay, players must rely on their wits to avoid dangerous creatures and solve unique puzzles. The game features immersive audio, eerie sound design, and horrifying creatures modeled and animated by industry professionals.
View Game8 View Game89%Game Brain Scoregraphics, gameplaystory, optimization93% User Score 46 reviewsIn this Indie Horror Game you are playing as a stranded Sailor who tries to find a way to escape the Island. But there are some strange things going on! Created with Unreal Engine 5, this game offers a thrilling horror experience with good graphics and combat action! Let's see how brave you are.
View Game9 View Game64%Game Brain Scoregameplay, graphicsstability, grinding66% User Score 718 reviewsCritic Score 57%2 reviews"Yume Nikki: Dream Diary" is a modern indie title that reimagines the surreal world and characters of the cult classic RPG Maker game in 3D. With six expansive dreams to explore, players will experience gameplay evocative of recent indie classics as they delve into the dream world using items and abilities to uncover its mysteries. The game also features an updated version of the beloved minigame, NASU. 'ALL-NEW OLD' original character included.
View Game10 View Game90%Game Brain Scorestory, musicstability, grinding90% User Score 666 reviews"The Mallet Island Curse" comes to life in "The Music Machine." As David, a mute rockstar, explore the haunted island, solve puzzles, and uncover the dark truth behind your silence. Use your enchanted music sheets and trusty sledgehammer to battle grotesque monsters in this rhythm-based horror adventure. Only by embracing the beat can you break the curse and find your voice again.
View Game










