Games like By Moonlight

Dream Daddy: A Dad Dating Simulator is a visual novel game where you play as a single dad who has moved to a new neighborhood with your daughter. The game features multiple dads as potential love interests, with various personality types and storylines to explore. Gameplay involves choosing dialogue options and performing activities to improve your relationship with the dads. The game is known for its inclusivity and diversity in character design, and for its humor and heartfelt storytelling.

"Hiveswap Friendsim" is a visual novel game where players interact with characters from the Homestuck universe. It features a series of episodic storylines with multiple endings based on player choices. The game is a spin-off of the popular webcomic Homestuck, and allows players to explore and develop relationships with its diverse cast of characters.

Witches x Warlocks is a cute and light-hearted Halloween Raising Sim Visual Novel; featuring a customizable protagonist and 4 love interests of different genders!

"Trick and Treat - Visual Novel" is a thrilling mystery visual novel that takes place in a forest with a legendary monster. After an attack, the protagonist encounters two girls, Ashley and Lilian, whose intentions and hidden secrets are unclear. The game is in English and offers about 3 hours of gameplay with a little romance.

In "Seduce Me the Otome," you're a high school senior who inherits her grandfather's estate, only to find five injured incubi seeking shelter. As you care for them, you navigate complex relationships while learning about their supernatural lives and the dangers they face. This visual novel offers romance and drama with a paranormal twist.

Afterparty is a single-player mystery action game with an intriguing story, good mechanics, marvelous graphics, and phenomenal music. As Milo and Lola, recently deceased best friends, you'll explore an interconnected underworld, outdrink demons, and uncover the mystery of your damnation. With an intelligent conversation system, varied libations, and a spectacular atmosphere, Afterparty delivers a memorable and highly emotional experience, despite some grinding and bugs.

"Wolf Tails" is a visual novel game where you, a solitary cabin dweller, take in a lost wolf-girl and find yourself involved in the affairs of her pack, leading to romance and multiple endings. Play as either a male or female protagonist with unique dialog options and CGs. Enjoy beautifully illustrated scenes with animated intros and two romantic options featuring wolf-girls.

"Kill or Love" is a visual novel centering on Jack, a hospital patient with no childhood memories, whose girlfriend is held captive by his nurse Anna. Anna, who put Jack in the hospital, is obsessed with him and holds the key to his forgotten past. With two choices and four endings, players uncover the truth behind Anna's fixation as they navigate Jack's desperate attempts to save his girlfriend. The game features 28,000 words, high-resolution graphics, and a trailer by KotoriWorks.

In ACE Academy, play as a student at a prestigious academy for advanced technology. Develop friendships, romances, and rivalries with your classmates while navigating the ups and downs of student life. Use your skills to customize mecha models and engage in exciting battles, with the fate of the academy and the world at stake.

Upon answering a mysterious phone call, you awaken in an unfamiliar place filled with new faces… Through intricate relationships and thoughtful introspection, will you be able to unravel the reason you are here?