Games like Unnatural: Benighted
Looking for games like Unnatural: Benighted? Here are top casual shooter recommendations with a horror focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with POSTAL 4: No Regerts, A Day Out or Daymare: 1998.
1 54%Game Brain Scorehumor, graphicsstory, optimization69% User Score 7,918 reviewsCritic Score 35%6 reviewsThe Postal Dude is back! Postal 4: No Regerts is a satirical and outrageous comedic open world first person shooter and the long-awaited true sequel to what’s been fondly dubbed as "The Worst Game Ever", Postal 2! (No third game is known to exist).
View GameView Game
2 
78%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgameplay, stability78% User Score 664 reviewsTackle cases that will each take place in a different part of the world. Find clues to aid you on your mission to solve these cases. Once the case has been solved, you’ll be tasked with having to deal with whatever creature is responsible. Use the knowledge gained from your cases to capture these ferocious cryptids. Traps and other weapons can be used to subdue the creature, once secured, they…
View GameView Game
3 
60%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, grinding66% User Score 1,560 reviewsCritic Score 55%24 reviewsDaymare: 1998 is a third-person survival horror game that recreates the mood of iconic titles from the '90s, with a fresh storyline. An incident that turns a small town into a deadly zone, three characters to play with and little time to find the truth, before its mutated citizens abruptly end your mission.
View GameView Game
4 
89%Game Brain Scoregraphics, atmospherestory, stability89% User Score 244 reviewsGlowcoma: Chapter 1 is a Sci-Fi FPS survivor horror game.
View GameView Game
5 
78%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, grinding78% User Score 308 reviewsRed Alliance is an atmospheric, dark action thriller single player game with elements of horror. The game takes place in Eastern Europe where the society is under oppressive regime enforced by a mysterious scientist whom the player must stop to restore justice.
View GameView Game
6 
64%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplayoptimization, stability64% User Score 418 reviewsThe Moon. Our closest celestial neighbor. A place full of mystery and strange things. That's right, there's more than just rocks and impossible challenges out there. A lone astronaut is about to learn that first hand, when he loses contact with Earth and begins an interstellar odyssey across the universe Moon Mystery is a first-person shooter adventure full of puzzles, action, set on strange new …
View GameView Game
7 
67%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheremusic, stability63% User Score 156 reviewsCritic Score 85%1 reviewsSTAIRS is a first-person atmospheric psychological horror game, inspired by real-life events, that takes players through the stories of three missing people as seen through the eyes of journalist Christopher Adams.
View GameView Game
8 
64%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, optimization64% User Score 331 reviewsFerocious is a survival shooter in which you will discover a lost prehistoric world full of deadly creatures under the control of hostile forces. Fight, Explore, Survive
View GameView Game
9 
85%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsstability, grinding85% User Score 861 reviewsExperience what the island has in store as you uncover the secretive Arque Corporation, burrowing ever deeper into their dangerous and haphazard operations.
View GameView Game
10 
46%Game Brain Scoremusic, atmospheregraphics, story46% User Score 636 reviewsHappy Horrordays from Bright Dawn!Need a last minute gift or looking for that special present for yourself? Look no further!Dementium II HD Trading Cards - Available Now!About the GameThe visage of doctors and patients alike fade in and out of these nightmarish visions of tortured memories. This eggshell reality is fractured by experiments conducted in the ward. Blood, flesh and screams surround…
View GameView Game
