Games like The Past Within
Looking for games like The Past Within? Here are top casual puzzle recommendations with a horror, mystery and thriller focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Tick Tock: A Tale for Two, Unboxing The Cryptic Killer or Cube Escape: Paradox.
1 View Game91%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, grinding91% User Score 6,242 reviews"Tick Tock: A Tale for Two" is a co-op puzzle adventure game where players must work together to uncover the secrets of a mysterious clockwork world. Each player has a unique perspective on the game world, and must communicate and coordinate to solve puzzles and progress. With no correct way to solve each puzzle, players are encouraged to think creatively and work together to unravel the story.
View Game2 View Game91%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, stability91% User Score 1,510 reviews"Unboxing the Cryptic Killer" is a challenging 2-player cooperative puzzle game where both players must own a copy and communicate via voice chat to solve the cryptic box. Players step into the shoes of seasoned detectives Ally and Old Dog, working together to unravel intricate puzzles designed by the mysterious Cryptic Killer to save innocent lives. Teamwork is crucial in this thrilling race against time, as every puzzle solved brings you closer to unmasking the killer.
View Game3 View Game94%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsstability, grinding94% User Score 10,000 reviewsIn "Cube Escape: Paradox," players assume the role of detective Dale Vandermeer, who finds himself in a mysterious room with no memory of his past. He must solve increasingly difficult puzzles to regain his memories and escape the room, all while uncovering connections to the Rusty Lake universe. The game features unique gameplay and a film crossover experience, with two chapters available, including a free one, and supports 14 languages. Chapter 2 continues the story with new challenges and mysteries to uncover.
View Game4 View Game96%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, grinding96% User Score 1,457 reviews"Rusty Lake: Roots" is a atmospheric point-and-click adventure game that follows James Vanderboom's life as it changes dramatically after planting a special seed in his inherited garden. The game features a unique storyline where you expand your family tree by unlocking portraits in the tree of life across more than 33 levels. With a immersive soundtrack, suspenseful moments and achievements to unravel, this game will keep you engaged and intrigued.
View Game5 View Game93%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, stability93% User Score 978 reviewsIn Rusty Lake Paradise, Jakob, the son of the deceased island paradise owner, must perform a series of ascension rituals to lift a curse that’s causing deadly fruits and plagues. Each ritual requires solving puzzles that involve the island’s mysterious inhabitants, with unique challenges as you progress. As Jakob, you'll confront dark family secrets while uncovering the paradise island's past, making for a captivating and suspenseful adventure.
View Game6 View Game85%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, grinding87% User Score 1,437 reviewsCritic Score 77%1 reviews"The White Door" is a psychological adventure game where you follow the story of Robert Hill, a patient in a peculiar psychiatric facility. The game combines point-and-click and rhythm-based gameplay elements, with players interacting with various objects and following a strict daily routine while trying to uncover Robert's memories and past. The game features a unique monochrome aesthetic, with a focus on story and atmosphere.
View Game7 View Game94%Game Brain Scoregraphics, storystability, replayability97% User Score 9,996 reviewsCritic Score 83%2 reviewsA time-spanning journey
View Game8 View Game90%Game Brain Scoregameplay, storystability, replayability90% User Score 15,393 reviews"We Were Here" is a challenging cooperative first-person puzzle game. Players are trapped in a sinister castle and must communicate and solve puzzles to escape. Each player sees different parts of the castle, requiring effective teamwork and strategic thinking. With a focus on atmospheric exploration and immersive storytelling, "We Were Here" offers a unique experience for pairs of adventurous gamers.
View Game9 View Game95%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsmonetization, stability95% User Score 8,234 reviewsSamsara Room is a first-person puzzle game set in a mysterious, ever-changing room. Players must explore the room, solve puzzles, and unlock new areas to progress. With its unique gameplay mechanics and atmospheric setting, Samsara Room offers a challenging and immersive experience.
View Game10 View Game92%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsmonetization, stability92% User Score 3,218 reviewsThe Cube Escape Collection is a series of atmospheric puzzle-adventure games. Players must escape various cube-shaped rooms and uncover the mysteries of a surreal universe by solving intricate puzzles and gathering clues. With a distinctive art style and immersive soundtrack, this compilation offers a compelling and mysterious experience.
View Game










