We Were Here Forever

85%
Game Brain Score Based on 4,795 reviews
  • story
  • graphics
  • gameplay
We Were Here Forever Game Cover
When the issues of a game are rolled and stomped by its greatness, then it’s something to invest in if you have some spare.
Starting at €17.99Buy now
Get on Steam Get on Epic Games Store

"We Were Here Forever" is a cooperative first-person puzzle adventure game set in the mysterious Castle Rock. Players work together to explore the sinister castle, solve puzzles, and plot their escape. With a focus on communication and teamwork, players must navigate the castle's secrets and hidden riddles to ultimately escape the castle's grasp. Trust and collaboration are key in this chilling Antarctic adventure.

  • PC
  • Play​station 4
  • Play​station 5
  • Steam Deck
  • Windows
  • Xbox One
  • Xbox Series X|S
  • Play​Station
  • Xbox
Genres & TagsPlay Modes

Reviews

85%
Audience ScoreBased on 4,795 reviews
story349 positive mentions
optimization20 negative mentions
  • Incredible puzzles that require teamwork and communication, making for a fun and engaging experience.
  • Beautiful graphics and immersive environments that enhance the overall gameplay.
  • A satisfying conclusion to the series with a compelling story that ties together previous installments.
  • Some puzzles can feel tedious and one-sided, leaving one player with little to do.
  • The game has bugs and glitches that can lead to frustrating soft locks and progress loss.
  • The ending is disappointing and feels anticlimactic compared to the buildup throughout the game.
  • story725 mentions

    The story in "We Were Here Forever" has received mixed reviews, with many players praising its depth and connection to previous entries in the series, while others found it convoluted or lacking in clarity. The narrative is described as engaging and well-integrated with the puzzles, enhancing the cooperative gameplay experience, though some players noted that it can be overshadowed by the puzzle-solving aspect. Overall, the game is seen as a significant improvement in storytelling compared to earlier titles, providing a satisfying conclusion to the overarching plot.

    • “The story is really interesting and some decisions you have to take require hard thinking... definitely something I would replay.”
    • “The story was so well written... with one of the best soundtracks to any game accompanying it.”
    • “The story is a direct continuation of 'We Were Here Together'.”
    • “The story is mediocre and is definitely a letdown with that horrid ending.”
    • “The story was decent, but convoluted.”
    • “The story isn't the strongest, so if you want to play for story you might not find it as fun.”
  • graphics244 mentions

    The graphics in the game have received widespread acclaim for their stunning visuals, improved art style, and immersive atmosphere, marking a significant upgrade from previous titles in the series. Players have praised the beautiful environments, detailed animations, and cohesive design that enhance the overall gameplay experience. However, some users noted performance issues and frame drops in certain areas, which slightly detracted from the otherwise impressive graphical presentation.

    • “The atmosphere is dark and luminous, the graphics and cut scenes are beautifully done, and I'm always excited to get to the next area of events.”
    • “The graphics are stellar and the story is engaging.”
    • “The visuals, sound, and direction of this game were absolutely an evolution from the previous games; I can only hope that the devs do something even more brilliant in the future.”
    • “The performance overall wasn't great however, even after reducing the game's graphical fidelity.”
    • “The reason for my negative review is how piss poor the optimization for such a simple game is.... no matter what graphical settings I chose I consistently had extreme frame drops/stutters.”
    • “Graphics optimization is really bad; it really needs to be improved.”
  • gameplay179 mentions

    The gameplay is praised for its cooperative mechanics, engaging puzzles, and smooth interactions, making it a standout experience for players who enjoy teamwork and problem-solving. While many find the puzzles to be creatively designed and challenging, some players note that certain mechanics can be convoluted or frustrating, and the game may require patience and communication to fully enjoy. Overall, it offers a satisfying blend of immersive storytelling and innovative gameplay, though technical issues and difficulty spikes have been mentioned as drawbacks.

    • “Lovely co-op gameplay with friends.”
    • “The cooperative gameplay encourages teamwork and communication, making it a perfect choice for friends and family to play together.”
    • “The gameplay makes you think and work with your partner, the story is engaging, and the game generally looks beautiful.”
    • “Gameplay and story are king; increasing your game’s run time through backtracking and painfully slow ski lifts is lazy and very unwelcome.”
    • “Unfortunately, some of the internal mechanics and co-op puzzles are just so convoluted that it stops being fun.”
    • “The mechanics of the game are often clunky and hinder playing, many puzzles are entirely one-sided or just break for no visible reason, and most are so incredibly simple that I'm glad I didn't pay full price for this.”
  • music138 mentions

    The music in the game has received widespread acclaim for its quality and ability to enhance the overall atmosphere, with many players praising the soundtrack as one of the best aspects of the experience. While some noted a few recycled elements, the majority found the compositions to be engaging and well-suited to the game's themes, contributing to a memorable and immersive gameplay experience. Overall, the music is described as beautiful, relaxing, and integral to the game's emotional impact, making it a standout feature.

    • “The game has the perfect balance of puzzles, an incredible story, and beautiful music, and overall made it probably one of the most unforgettable gaming experiences for me.”
    • “The atmosphere is very well crafted with fantastic sound design and music.”
    • “The music is gorgeous, and the voice acting of the characters has no right being as good as it is for a puzzle game.”
    • “The music puzzle can suck me off.”
    • “The worst instance was a 3 minutes wait where there was no music, no dialogue, or anything interactable.”
    • “The environment is nice to look at but mostly static and the only thing you can interact with is the puzzles; the game can sometimes feel a bit slow as the music is slow and some of the puzzles leave you in the same spot for maybe a bit too long.”
  • atmosphere70 mentions

    The atmosphere of the game is consistently praised for its immersive and engaging qualities, featuring beautiful graphics, haunting sound design, and a compelling storyline that enhances the overall experience. Players appreciate the unique and creative puzzles that complement the atmospheric settings, which range from dark and spooky to beautifully artistic. Overall, the game's atmosphere is described as a standout element that significantly contributes to its enjoyment and emotional impact.

    • “The atmosphere is dark and luminous, the graphics and cut scenes are beautifully done, and I'm always excited to get to the next area of events.”
    • “The game's graphics and sound design are top-notch, creating a haunting and immersive atmosphere that will keep you on edge throughout the entire game.”
    • “The atmosphere is very well crafted with fantastic sound design and music.”
    • “The game is flooded with atmosphere throughout with some genuinely creepy moments (especially if you don't like deep water!).”
    • “Overall the atmosphere the game creates is dense and fits well to the castle/trap/escape setting.”
    • “I personally didn't care much for the story, but the whole atmosphere of the game is what matters most.”
  • optimization54 mentions

    The optimization of "We Were Here Forever" has received significant criticism, with many players reporting severe performance issues, including frame drops and stuttering, even on high-end systems. While some users noted improvements over previous entries in the series, the overall consensus is that the game requires substantial optimization and bug fixes to enhance the gameplay experience. Many reviewers recommend waiting for updates before purchasing due to these persistent performance problems.

    • “Technically, the game is also better optimized than previous ones in the series.”
    • “Performance is rock solid beyond these load moments, and I had no issues playing the game whatsoever.”
    • “Despite being released quite a while ago, there are plenty of issues, and it's not very well optimized even for mid-tier rigs that would have no problem running any of the previous games.”
    • “Horrible performance on top hardware in open areas.”
    • “The performance overall wasn't great; however, even after reducing the game's graphical fidelity.”
    • “The reason for my negative review is how poor the optimization for such a simple game is. No matter what graphical settings I chose, I consistently had extreme frame drops and stutters.”
  • stability51 mentions

    The game's stability has been widely criticized, with numerous players reporting significant bugs, glitches, and connection issues that disrupt gameplay and puzzle-solving. While some users noted improvements in voice chat and minor glitches, many experienced game-breaking bugs that rendered the game unplayable at times. Overall, the consensus suggests that while the game has potential, it currently suffers from stability issues that detract from the overall experience.

    • “Other than that one thing, it was bug-free.”
    • “Buggy, broken, can't get past chapter 5 due to a game-breaking bug.”
    • “The game is full of glitches and constantly made me and my mate have to reset.”
    • “While the game is great and has many puzzles that are easy to miss but fun to play, the constant glitches, the places not loading properly, and multiple other game-breaking glitches made me quit in the middle of play because I was tired of restarting my game because it wasn't bug tested.”
  • emotional46 mentions

    The emotional aspect of the game has resonated deeply with players, often leading to tears and heartfelt connections during gameplay. Many reviews highlight the game's ability to evoke strong feelings, particularly through its impactful endings and the bonds formed while solving puzzles with friends or loved ones. Despite some critiques regarding the narrative depth, the overall sentiment is that the game delivers a powerful emotional experience that enhances the cooperative gameplay.

    • “This game brought it all together and without any spoilers, playing with my brother, the ending made me cry a bit.”
    • “Finished the entire game series with my boyfriend, all I can say is it's been a long time since a game made me cry. The ending was absolutely brutal and had me crying like a baby, but overall the games are beautifully done and it's not just something basic that you can finish in 10 minutes; you actually have to turn on your brain. I really hope the series continues because these were a lot of fun.”
    • “The fact that the jester had escaped scot-free, while my friend and I struggled so desperately to help each other onto the piece of wood... it was heart-wrenching.”
    • “The emotional depth is overshadowed by a boring story that fails to engage.”
    • “Most puzzles feel like rehashes of ones already completed, detracting from the emotional experience.”
    • “Repetitive puzzles artificially extend the story, making it hard to connect emotionally.”
  • humor46 mentions

    The humor in the game is widely praised, with players highlighting its ability to create hilarious moments through miscommunication and the challenges of solving puzzles with friends. Many reviews mention the comedic value of the puzzles themselves, as well as the amusing interactions between players, often leading to laughter and frustration in equal measure. While some characters, like the jester, may not resonate as well, the overall experience is described as entertaining and filled with funny scenarios that enhance the cooperative gameplay.

    • “The ending had me in tears laughing my ass off.”
    • “It perfectly captures the experience of trying to solve a puzzle with your friend, endless confusion and hilarious miscommunication.”
    • “You and your partner will likely make plenty of mistakes along the way, leading to some hilarious and unforgettable moments.”
    • “The humor in this game falls flat and often feels forced, making it more cringeworthy than entertaining.”
    • “I expected some clever jokes, but instead, the humor is stale and lacks any real wit or charm.”
    • “The attempts at humor are so over-the-top that they detract from the overall experience, leaving me more confused than amused.”
  • grinding32 mentions

    Overall, players find the grinding aspect of the game to be excessively tedious, particularly due to the repetitive and labyrinthine puzzles that often require significant time investment without much reward. Many reviews highlight the slow travel mechanics and the trial-and-error nature of certain puzzles as frustrating elements that detract from the overall experience. While some acknowledge that the effort put into the game's design is commendable, the consensus leans towards the grinding being a major drawback.

    • “You'll need a second life for grinding.”
    • “The most tedious annoying 'game' I've ever had the misfortune of trying to play.”
    • “Some puzzles have become extremely tedious to do (they are still simple to figure out but take too much time to complete).”
  • replayability23 mentions

    Overall, the game's replayability is a mixed bag, with some players noting a lack of replay value due to predictable puzzles and scripted solutions, while others appreciate the asymmetric design that allows for different experiences when playing with a partner. Some reviews highlight that playing both sides of the puzzles can enhance replayability, but many agree that the game is best enjoyed in a single playthrough. Overall, while there are elements that can encourage replay, many players feel that the game ultimately offers limited incentive to return after the first completion.

    • “I definitely recommend this game, since it is highly replayable if you want to experience what the other player experienced during the first run.”
    • “The asymmetric design lends itself not only to replayability but also to one-of-a-kind puzzles.”
    • “It changed it up, making it more difficult as well as different, which added additional replayability.”
    • “My only complaint is that there's not much replayability.”
    • “Sadly, it may not be replayable even with a new partner, as you'll already understand the puzzles after.”
    • “The game is also significantly longer than the others but has less replay value due to more content being shared between players.”
  • character development1 mentions

    The game is praised for its engaging story and strong character development, contributing to an overall enjoyable experience, despite some frustrating puzzles.

    • “Actually a great game with a compelling story and impressive character development, making it super fun despite some frustrating puzzles.”
    • “The character development in this game is truly remarkable, adding depth to the story and making the gameplay experience more engaging.”
    • “I love how the characters evolve throughout the game; their growth and interactions keep me invested in the story.”
Positive mentions (%)Positive
Neutral mentions (%)Neutral
Negative mentions (%)Negative

Critic Reviews

77% average critic score

Buy We Were Here Forever

Play time

9hMedian play time
11hAverage play time
6-12hSpent by most gamers
*Based on 21 analyzed playthroughs

Videos

Similar Games

Game News