Games like Storyteller
Looking for games like Storyteller? Here are top role playing recommendations with a horror and mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Prologue (Second Edition), Tales of the Black Forest or English Eerie Second Edition.
1 53%Game Brain Score53% User Score 4 reviewsNobody knows how the Wizard came to power. For as long as anyone can remember, his dark tower has stood over the empire’s capital, and his armies have brutally enforced his will. His dark creatures lurk in the wilderness, preying on unprepared travellers. His dominion is total. Some time ago, a Hero rose from humble beginnings to challenge the Wizard. The Hero raised an army and took the fight to…
View GameView Game


2 97%Game Brain Scorestory, musicgrinding, stability97% User Score 1,077 reviewsA Japanese town disturbed by the surging of dark power, strange yet fascinating world of yokai. The tales in the Heisei Era, the tales among us... A Japanese Pixel Adventure game made by a group of 2 developers. In the name of love, romance and dreams.
View GameView Game


3 62%Game Brain Score62% User Score 13 reviewsEnglish Eerie Second Edition: A Rural Horror Storytelling Game for 1-4 Players is a GM-less tabletop game of terrifying proportions, allowing you to weave your own haunted tales set in the dark English countryside. There is blood in the roots of England. Forgotten, ancient things crawl beneath its surface, haunt its manor houses and creep within its woodland. Beyond the bucolic beauty of its rolli…
View GameView Game


4 92%Game Brain Scoregameplay, storyreplayability, grinding92% User Score 2,252 reviewsHome Safety Hotline is an analog horror inspired telephone operator simulator where you answer incoming callers' questions about what's inside their home. Read through a vast catalog of common pests and household hazards, and do your best to become an expert in home safety. You will be held responsible for what happens.
View GameView Game


5 86%Game Brain Scorestory, humorgrinding, music86% User Score 221 reviewsYou and your shattered werewolf pack must save the living Earth with Rage and spirit! In this interactive novel with hundreds of choices, can you defeat a Wyrm Spirit that manifests as a lie that you want to believe? Werewolf: The Apocalypse — The Book of Hungry Names is an interactive novel by Kyle Marquis set in the World of Darkness. It's entirely text-based—1.6 million words, without graphics…
View GameView Game
6 88%Game Brain Scorestory, musicreplayability, grinding88% User Score 165 reviewsArmy Gals is a visual novel set at a retreat for delinquents. The protagonist is forced to attend after a misunderstanding back at home. Expecting a fortnight of hell, he is pleasantly surprised to find he is sharing the retreat with three beautiful but very different young women.
View GameView Game


7 86%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospherereplayability, grinding93% User Score 1,785 reviewsCritic Score 74%7 reviewsIn the old days man tried to catch a glimpse of the future in the strangest of ways. Experience the ancient Swedish phenomena of year walking through a different kind of first person adventure that blurs the line between two and three dimensions, as well as reality and the supernatural.
View GameView Game


8 86%Game Brain Scorestory, musicgrinding, stability87% User Score 2,000 reviewsCritic Score 80%2 reviewsExperience a magical adventure. Journey with Jerry to the enchanted realm of Mousewood , master fascinating spells and solve tricky puzzles. Along with a intriguing story you will see breathtaking hand drawn backgrounds and elaborately animated characters. A Unique soundtrack complements Jerry's incredible adventure with fabulously composed music.
View GameView Game


9 92%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospherereplayability92% User Score 98 reviewsDon’t Go Looking For Evil, You May Find The Likho… One-Eyed Likho is a mystical first-person horror adventure in which you have to find Likho and escape your own evil fate. Features Folk horror – Explore a game world inspired by a Slavic fairy-tale recorded in the early 19th century Story-focused exploration – Progress through the game to uncover secrets and learn the whole truth Unique sty…
View GameView Game


10 84%Game Brain Scorestory, humoroptimization, stability84% User Score 146 reviewsBuzz is real! About the GameChicken Police: Into the HIVE! is a character-driven, story-rich, film-noir detective adventure in which you must uncover a complex, world-scale conspiracy by gathering clues, interrogating suspects, and solving puzzles. Sonny and Marty, the Wilderness's toughest detectives, are about to embark on the biggest case of their lives, which will take them through the in…
View GameView Game











