Games like Retrace
Looking for games like Retrace? Here are top puzzle recommendations with a horror and mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Project Kat: Paper Lily Prologue, Gone Home or The Room.
1 View Game99%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, monetization99% User Score 3,378 reviewsProject Kat is a short, unconventional RPG horror game in which there is always another way. Solve puzzles, make friends (or not), and guide Kat as she attempts to uncover the mystery behind a strange golden letter.
View Game2 View Game82%Game Brain Scorestory, emotionalreplayability, optimization77% User Score 20,826 reviewsCritic Score 82%14 reviews"Gone Home: Console Edition" is a story exploration game set in 1995 where you return home to an empty house and must discover what happened to your family. It's a critically acclaimed and award-winning game, known for its realistic portrayal of characters and emotional depth, with over 90 minutes of behind-the-scenes commentary available. The game has been praised for being a defining indie game of its generation and a unique love story.
View Game3 View Game79%Game Brain Scoregraphics, storyreplayability, grinding97% User Score 24,944 reviewsCritic Score 56%10 reviews"The Room" is a 3D puzzler game that takes you through a series of intricate boxes with hidden mechanics and secrets. You will need to solve puzzles and find clues to unlock and reveal the mysteries within each box. The game features a captivating storyline, immersive atmosphere, and challenging puzzles that require logical thinking and attention to detail.
View Game4 View Game94%Game Brain Scoregameplay, graphicsreplayability, grinding94% User Score 521 reviewsAn old shack deep in a dense forest, a strange computer and a game that's trying to kill you! Is this Game Trying to Kill Me? - it is a mix of horror and first-person puzzle. You are trapped inside a cabin deep in the forest, and its owner offers to play a computer game in exchange for freedom. But the cabin and the game are much more connected than you might think. Traps from the game begin to a…
View Game5 View Game92%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, monetization98% User Score 4,142 reviewsCritic Score 60%1 reviews"Mad Father" is a horror adventure game where you play as Aya Drevis, an 11-year-old girl, and uncover the secrets of her family's manor, which is the site of maniacal experiments. To explore the mansion, you'll use various weapons like chainsaws and knives. This remade version features updated graphics, new scenes, and a second playthrough mode called "Blood Mode" which alters the story.
View Game6 View Game98%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, stability98% User Score 1,593 reviews"Lily's Well" is a free point-and-click horror game where you play as a young girl, Lily, investigating a mysterious voice calling for help from a well. To do so, you must explore Lily's home and surroundings to find materials to create a rope, with the length affecting how far Lily can climb. The game features ten normal endings and three secret endings, providing multiple playthrough options. A behind-the-scenes pack is available for purchase for $10.00 USD.
View Game7 View Game95%Game Brain Scorestory, humorgrinding, optimization95% User Score 422 reviewsPEPPERED: an existential platformer challenges you to save the world in a single, high-stakes run where every choice and failure shapes the branching narrative. As an office intern labeled a terrorist, your decisions influence multiple endings and unique story routes. Intense platforming and one-shot boss battles demand precision, with no room for retries.
View Game8 View Game98%Game Brain Scorestory, musicgrinding, optimization98% User Score 2,345 reviews"Brutal End Tears" is a single-player game, featuring an interesting plot and outstanding mechanics, inspired by the visual novel "Bad End Theater" and the game "Brutal Orchestra." The mod introduces 8 teams of fools, each with unique abilities and playstyles, offering a variety of gameplay experiences. The game boasts masterful graphics, a stellar soundtrack, and a touch of humor, all contributing to a wholesome and engaging story.
View Game9 View Game95%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, grinding95% User Score 624 reviewsIn "Why Am I Dead At Sea," you play as a spirit stuck on a cruise ship, trying to solve your own murder mystery by possessing and communicating with the living passengers. With no memory of your past, you must uncover clues, expose secrets, and expose the killer. The game features a unique blend of adventure, puzzle-solving, and narrative-driven gameplay.
View Game10 View Game89%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, grinding91% User Score 2,498 reviewsCritic Score 85%6 reviews"This Bed We Made" is a narrative-driven RPG set in the low fantasy world of Orience. Players assume the role of a mercenary captain, navigating complex relationships and making difficult moral choices in a story that explores themes of power, loyalty, and consequence. With a focus on branching dialogue and multiple endings, each playthrough offers unique experiences and replayability.
View Game










