Games like Choices That Matter: And the Sun Went Out
Looking for games like Choices That Matter: And the Sun Went Out? Here are top casual puzzle recommendations with a mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Choices That Matter, Rue Valley or Omen Exitio: Plague.
1 89%Game Brain Scorestory, emotionalmonetization, atmosphere89% User Score 1,060 reviewsEpic text based adventure and interactive story game - choose your path!
View GameView Game
2 
65%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, replayability62% User Score 568 reviewsCritic Score 73%3 reviewsRue Valley is a narrative RPG about a man trapped in a time loop, surrounded by a colorful cast with complex emotional stories, each hiding unexpected secrets. Dealing with mental challenges, the main character must rise from the depths, delving into the anomaly to uncover its enigmatic origins.
View GameView Game
3 
84%Game Brain Scorestory, musicgameplay, grinding86% User Score 370 reviewsCritic Score 72%1 reviewsA narrative-based RPG game which draws from the old gamebook genre, set in the world of H.P. Lovecraft's Cthulhu mythology. Drawing from the dark realms of H.P. Lovecraft's imagination, Omen...
View GameView Game
4 
70%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregrinding, character development70% User Score 1,736 reviewsFollow us About the GameHome is a unique horror adventure set in a beautifully-realized pixel world. It’s a murder mystery with a twist—because you decide what ultimately happens. Awakened by an oncoming storm, you open your eyes to discover yourself in a strange, dark room—tucked away in a house that’s not yours. As you play the game, it changes—subtly, almost imperceptibly—to reflect your pe…
View GameView Game
5 
85%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaystability, grinding90% User Score 2,632 reviewsCritic Score 80%10 reviewsYou didn't ask to lead this expedition but here you are: stuck in the ice, Captain missing, miles from civilization and everyone looking for you to lead. Manage your meager resources, balance safety and morale, make the hard calls and head in the only direction you can - into The Pale Beyond.
View GameView Game
6 
96%Game Brain Scorestory, musicgameplay, character development96% User Score 469 reviewsA free horror Visual Novel about an ill-fated journey across Sinnlos, a lake where awful monsters lurk just beneath the surface. With times being so dire you'll need to decide what, and who, is going to be sacrificed. Anyone can be saved, but not everyone can be.
View GameView Game
7 
93%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, replayability93% User Score 948 reviewsPlay as a farmer who struggles to manage a failing farm. You come to a point where there is no more hope, and you must do something.
View GameView Game
8 
77%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, graphics83% User Score 359 reviewsCritic Score 72%10 reviewsThe Shapeshifting Detective is a supernatural-noir murder mystery FMV game where you play as a detective who can shapeshift into other characters, allowing you to unlock secret conversations and private encounters.
View GameView Game
9 
85%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplayreplayability, monetization85% User Score 1,220 reviewsThese are troubling times. A careful balance must be struck. Your throne awaits.
View GameView Game
10 
82%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, stability82% User Score 1,986 reviewsSoul Gambler puts YOU in the role of Faust, an ordinary young man living in the present day whose DESTINY is about to be change forever.
View GameView Game
