Games like When eyes close
Looking for games like When eyes close? Here are top puzzle recommendations with a horror and thriller focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with The House Below, Home or The Last Case of John Morley.
1 View GameThe House Below is a short, first-person psychological horror game where atmosphere, tension, and subtle storytelling drive the experience. You awaken in a place that doesn’t feel real — a maze of dark rooms and crumbling hallways beneath the surface of something familiar. There’s no clear direction, no weapons, and no escape in sight. All you know is that you need to keep going… and that somethin…
View Game2 View Game70%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregrinding, character development70% User Score 1,736 reviews"Home" is a single-player adventure horror game with an interesting plot and good game mechanics. It takes place in a beautifully designed pixel world, where the game's environment subtly changes to reflect your perspective. As a murder mystery, the game allows you to decide its outcome, creating a unique and masterfully crafted atmosphere.
View Game3 View Game73%Game Brain Scorestory, atmosphereoptimization, music82% User Score 100 reviewsCritic Score 56%5 reviewsStep into the shoes of detective John Morley as he revisits a cold murder case from 20 years ago, guided by Lady Margaret Fordside, a countess seeking the truth behind her daughter's death. Explore atmospheric 1940s settings, uncover hidden clues, and unravel a haunting mystery that challenges the official story. Immerse yourself in a gripping noir investigation filled with dark secrets and forgotten places.
View Game4 View Game58%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregameplay, stability51% User Score 714 reviewsCritic Score 68%12 reviewsUncanny Valley is a true survival horror indie game, available on Steam, that differentiates itself from action-oriented titles. Players control a security guard in a remote facility, where they must balance exploration, evasion, and engagement with various threats while uncovering a chilling mystery. The game is known for its unsettling atmosphere, multiple endings, and tough choices that impact the story.
View Game5 View Game61%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregameplay, music70% User Score 229 reviewsCritic Score 52%25 reviews"Those Who Remain" is a single-player horror platformer game with an intriguing story and pretty visuals, set in the eerie, darkness-shrouded town of Dormont. Players navigate through two interconnected dimensions, solving puzzles and making morally challenging choices that impact the story. However, the game is reported to be very grinding, buggy, and has a dense atmosphere, which may not appeal to all players.
View Game6 View Game93%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplayreplayability, grinding93% User Score 296 reviewsIn "The Sandman," players navigate surreal, ever-changing dreamscapes to regain lost memories. As Evelunn, a young woman trapped in an enigmatic realm, she must solve puzzles, avoid nightmarish creatures, and unlock secrets to escape. With its distinctive art style and atmospheric soundtrack, this first-person puzzle adventure delivers a hauntingly beautiful experience.
View Game7 View Game99%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospherereplayability, grinding99% User Score 684 reviews"Deep Sleep Trilogy" is a series of horror adventure games that simulate interactive dreams. The player explores surreal and disturbing environments, solves puzzles, and uncovers the story of their own subconscious mind. With a focus on atmosphere and symbolism, the trilogy offers a unique and psychological take on the horror genre.
View Game8 View Game82%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregameplay, stability82% User Score 523 reviewsNight Delivery is a first-person puzzle game set in a surreal, constantly shifting city. As a delivery driver, you must navigate narrow alleyways, dark rooftops, and twisting corridors to deliver packages on time. With each successful delivery, the city becomes more complex, challenging you to find new routes and strategies to complete your rounds. Use your wits and quick reflexes to overcome obstacles, avoid hazards, and become the best nighttime courier in town.
View Game9 View Game96%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgameplay96% User Score 389 reviewsWithout a Dawn is a dark, psychological visual horror novel featuring haunting pseudo-ASCII art that immerses players in introspection. Set in a remote cabin, the story explores themes of silence, isolation, and the blurred line between reality and fiction. Its philosophical narrative and carefully crafted art create a deeply atmospheric experience.
View Game10 View Game71%Game Brain Scorestory, musicgameplay, replayability73% User Score 146 reviewsCritic Score 60%1 reviewsIn "The Isle Tide Hotel," become a detective and explore a mysterious hotel to infiltrate a cult and save your missing daughter. With an award-winning cast, every decision counts as you gather clues and question guests. The hotel is only open three nights every three years, adding urgency to your quest, as you uncover hidden lore, side quests, and navigate a branching narrative with multiple endings.
View Game










