Games like The Nightfall
Looking for games like The Nightfall? Here are top action recommendations with a horror and mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Sagebrush, Frozen State or Jaws of Hell.
1 89%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsoptimization, replayability95% User Score 362 reviewsCritic Score 79%5 reviewsA first-person narrative adventure game about exploring a cult compound in the remote New Mexico desert. Discover the lives of the former inhabitants -- what brought them together, what they believed, and why they ended it all.
View GameView Game


2 58%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgameplay, optimization58% User Score 548 reviewsFrozen State is a game about the adversities faced whilst existing and surviving in a dying Siberian city, Duga 40. The experimental city has been infested by an extraterrestrial parasite that has obliterated the native population. Once infected, the parasite causes its victims to become vicious alien hybrids… However, the grotesquely disfigured creatures are not the only menace that threatens t…
View GameView Game


3 View GameJaws of Hell The Hive wasn't born on Earth. It began with a broken man on Mars. Before the outbreak. Before the cities fell. There was Clark — once a farmer, now a jaded husband, and future bounty hunter of The Hive Pandemic. After losing everything to a tornado and a divorce, Clark becomes one of the first human colonists on Mars. But the red dust hides more than new beginnings. An ancient ali…
View Game4 A SINGLE PLAYER NARRATIVE SURVIVAL EXPERIENCE The world didn’t end. It disappeared. I remember the constant sound of machines. Cold lights above my head. A voice calling my name, trying to keep me awake. It was 2025. The last thing I remember is the world as it was back then. Then, silence. When I open my eyes again, something is wrong. No one. No movement. No continuity. Th…
View GameView Game


5 74%Game Brain Scoremusic, graphicsstory, stability76% User Score 2,249 reviewsCritic Score 70%4 reviewsProteus is a game about exploration and immersion in a dream-like island world where the soundtrack to your play is created by your surroundings. Played in first-person, the primary means of interaction is simply your presence in the world and how you observe it. The procedurally generated islands are home to creatures natural and imagined, tranquil valleys and ruins with magical properties.
View GameView Game


6 53%Game Brain Score53% User Score 7 reviewsWelcome to Hyperliminal, a horror/exploration/fever-dream experience. The game itself is narration and exploration-based with some action to keep things interesting. You will explore a strange dreamscape and witness sites ranging from gigantic food to a town overtaken by arachnids. Unravel the mystery of the recurring nightmare while keeping safe a safe distance from the horrors that live within.
View GameView Game


7 94%Game Brain Scorestory, atmospheregameplay, grinding94% User Score 71 reviewsA new life begins in a low-cost apartment. Strange occurrences at night and the suspicious behavior of neighbors gradually push the protagonist to the edge.
View GameView Game


8 82%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplayreplayability, optimization82% User Score 96 reviewsWater Delivery is a first person, horror experience where you play as a water delivery boy. Ride along in the delivery truck from house to house. Deliver filled water jugs, find and return empty jugs, and collect all the payments. Will you be able to finish your final route of the evening?
View GameView Game


9 78%Game Brain Scoreatmosphere, storygameplay, grinding84% User Score 770 reviewsCritic Score 50%5 reviewsThere is an unusual cabin deep in the woods. It had served as a laboratory and a dwelling for three generations of Lodgers. But as of late the latest Lodger has been noticing weird changes in familiar surroundings; things are missing, noises and rattle heard. Something odd is coming out of the woods.
View GameView Game


10 85%Game Brain Scoreatmosphere, storygrinding, replayability85% User Score 3,070 reviewsThe Convenience Store is a J-horror game about a college girl on a night shift.
View GameView Game











