Games like Lost Island
Looking for games like Lost Island? Here are top puzzle recommendations with a fantasy focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Zefyr: A Thief's Melody, Eastshade or Reflections.
1 View Game99%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, stability99% User Score 85 reviews"Zefyr: A Thief's Melody" is a 3D cartoon adventure/stealth game with a peaceful atmosphere, reminiscent of classics like "Beyond Good & Evil" and "Zelda Windwaker." As a thief-in-training, explore a colorful archipelago world, solve puzzles, engage in combat, and uncover the truth behind mysterious kidnings. The game features a charming open world, complete with sailing on a turtle, climbing islands, and interacting with various NPCs. Currently in development for Windows, Linux, and MacOS.
View Game2 View Game88%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsstability, optimization90% User Score 3,634 reviewsCritic Score 85%7 reviewsEastshade is a single-player, open-world exploration-adventure game where you play as a traveling painter on the island of Eastshade. Capture the stunning world on canvas, engage in dynamic conversations with inhabitants, and solve quests to uncover the land's secrets. With its peaceful gameplay, outstanding music, and emotional depth, Eastshade offers a memorable and immersive experience, despite some bugs and optimization issues.
View Game3 View Game51%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsoptimization, atmosphere44% User Score 55 reviewsCritic Score 85%1 reviewsReflections is a real-world adventure game where every action you take has meaningful consequences that radically shape the experience. Each action you take is punctuated by flushing the black and white environment with color, illustrating your progress and providing clues to what your future might hold.
View Game4 View Game93%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, optimization93% User Score 967 reviews"Swords 'n Magic and Stuff" is a sandbox RPG set in a vibrant, procedurally generated world. Customize your character, gather resources, and craft weapons to defeat enemies. With a focus on player freedom, explore the vast world and create your own unique adventure.
View Game5 View Game72%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, stability80% User Score 342 reviewsCritic Score 64%12 reviews"Aka" is a single-player, open-world fantasy game with a deep, emotional story and engaging gameplay. The farming system is inspired by permaculture, and players can craft various items for quest-solving or decorative purposes. Relax in hot springs, watch clouds, or take a nap on a giant Capybara while meeting various characters and completing narrative quests. The game also features mini-games and stunning visuals with a delightful soundtrack. However, be prepared for some grinding.
View Game6 View Game82%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsoptimization, stability83% User Score 510 reviewsCritic Score 77%2 reviews"Aporia: Beyond The Valley" is a first-person adventure game set in a mystical, ancient world. Players explore this beautiful but ruined land, solving puzzles to uncover the story of its lost civilization. With no combat or dialogue, the game emphasizes exploration and discovery in a serene, atmospheric setting.
View Game7 View Game97%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygrinding, stability97% User Score 120 reviewsThe Girl from Arkanya is a pixel art action RPG inspired by classic 2D Zelda games, featuring Marisa, a treasure hunter, and her magical capybara ally, Kapi. Together, they explore seven diverse jungle zones and face six unique dungeons while uncovering mysteries and seeking treasure. Embark on an epic adventure filled with danger, discovery, and legacy.
View Game8 View Game99%Game Brain Scorestory, humorgrinding, atmosphere99% User Score 130 reviewsWYRMHALL: Brush and Banter is a charming game where you play as a goblin cleaning mysterious artifacts while uncovering secrets and meeting quirky creatures called chumpos. Your choice to clean carefully or slack off influences multiple endings, all set to an original soundtrack. Dive into gob-speak and enjoy a unique, cozy experience meant to be completed in one sitting.
View Game9 View Game90%Game Brain Scoregraphics, storygameplay, grinding90% User Score 449 reviewsNecrophosis is a single-player action game set in a haunting, Lovecraftian world where decay reigns supreme. Featuring stunning visuals, a dense atmosphere, and an interesting plot conveyed through narrative poems, players navigate a surreal, nightmarish landscape filled with unsettling shapes. The experience combines gripping puzzle elements with immersive music and challenging grind gameplay.
View Game10 View Game98%Game Brain Scorestory, humorgameplay, music98% User Score 63 reviewsFlibbius McDoogle and the Mysterious Flying Machine is a charming puzzle adventure where you help the inventive Flibbius fulfill his dream of flight. Explore, meet quirky characters, craft items, and solve creative puzzles in a relaxed, story-driven journey. With hints available, the game offers a delightful experience lasting 2-3 hours.
View Game










