Games like Aye Aye Captain

Aye Aye Captain is a game about crewing a ship on the high seas of the 1500 and 1600s. You'll have to manage a crew, provide them with consistent booty, rum, and fight off mutinies all while pillaging vessels of royal navies, other pirates, and trading companies.

Privateers is a crowdfunded pirate themed adventure game.

Terror of the Seven Seas lets you live the pirate life you’ve always dreamed of, blending ship combat, sailing, and exploration in a vast open world. Choose your path as a ruthless pirate, loyal naval officer, wealthy trader, or daring explorer, each with unique quests and challenges. Engage in intense boarding battles, hunt legendary creatures, and uncover hidden treasures across the seas.

Patrician III - sequel to the award winning game Patrician II - features advanced in-game AI, which adjusts its difficulty based on experience and ability. In this economic sandbox game you can gain wealth and power in multiple ways - what you will do with it is up to you. Invite up to 8 of your friends for a multiplayer session via LAN or over the Internet. Become a fellow of the famous medieval…

"Corsairs Legacy - Pirate Action RPG & Sea Battles" is a story-driven adventure game where you play as Rufus Monroe, an adventurous smuggler in the Caribbean. After a raid goes wrong, you'll face dangerous voyages, perilous piracy, and fatal fights against powerful enemies. The game is designed according to historical prototypes and challenges you to survive the dangers of the Caribbean and become a legendary pirate.

Patrician III is a medieval trading simulation game that allows players to rise through the ranks of Hanseatic League cities. Build and upgrade your own production facilities, ships, and trade routes to amass wealth and influence. Engage in political intrigue, complete missions, and navigate complex economic systems to become the leading merchant in the Baltic Sea region.

"Buccaneers!" is a single-player historical role-playing game with an intriguing story and good graphics. As a fearless captain, pledge your allegiance to one of four factions, each with unique abilities and starting locations. Engage in intense naval battles, upgrade your warship, and conquer an ever-changing Caribbean sea to leave your mark on the world. With hours of replayability, find legendary treasures, battle powerful ships and make your mark on history.

In "Sea Dogs: City of Abandoned Ships," become a feared pirate or loyal navy captain, sailing the high seas to explore, raid, and plunder. Solve ancient mysteries, cross swords with notorious pirates, and choose from 3 characters and classes in this swashbuckling adventure. Myth and reality intertwine in the dark jungles of South America.

"Pirate's Life" is a single-player 2D strategy/city builder game where you manage a crew of shipwrecked pirates on a deserted island, meeting their needs to prevent mutiny.“Unlock new buildings, resources, and recruit crew members through raids on other settlements or trade routes, increasing your wanted level and attracting the Royal Navy.”With a playtime of around 4 hours, the game offers a self-contained pirate management experience.

"The Caribbean Sail" is a nautical exploration and adventure game set in the Victorian era. Sail through the Caribbean, completing quests, trading goods, and battling pirates while managing your ship and crew. Engage in ship-to-ship combat, negotiate with merchants and factions, and uncover the mysteries of the sea in this immersive experience.