Games like That's Not How it Happened
Looking for games like That's Not How it Happened? Here are top casual action adventure recommendations, selected from player-similarity data — start with One Night Stand, Storyteller or Dream Daddy: A Dad Dating Simulator.
1 84%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, optimization90% User Score 434 reviewsCritic Score 74%6 reviewsAfter a night of fun, passion, and one too many drinks, you awake to discover a complete stranger lying naked beside you in bed. With only hazy memories of what happened last night, explore a stranger's bedroom in search of clues and try and piece together the truth.
View GameView Game
2 
84%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplayreplayability, grinding86% User Score 4,119 reviewsCritic Score 76%1 reviewsStoryteller lets you build stories using a visual language. The goal on each level is to make a story that fits the given title by placing settings and characters that react to each other, creating a narrative through their relationships.Storyteller's comic-panel design and charming animations allow for experimentation within the framing of its many stories: just drag and drop characters to see ho…
View GameView Game
3 
83%Game Brain Scorestory, humorstability, grinding92% User Score 8,811 reviewsCritic Score 74%13 reviewsDream Daddy: A Dad Dating Simulator is a game where you play as a Dad and your goal is to meet and romance other hot Dads. Are you ready? Hi ready, I'm Dad.
View GameView Game
4 
93%Game Brain Scorehumor, graphicsgrinding, stability96% User Score 1,471 reviewsCritic Score 78%1 reviewsTramp, Granny, Bandit & Devil
View GameView Game
5 
88%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, stability90% User Score 1,490 reviewsCritic Score 83%2 reviewsPinstripe is an emotionally charged adventure about Hell created entirely by a one-man team over the course of five years. Play as Teddy, an estranged ex-minister forced to venture through the frozen afterlife in search of Bo, his three year old daughter, and her perverse kidnapper. Discover the dark secrets of Teddy's past, and confront his sleazy, demonic nemesis, Mr. Pinstripe.
View GameView Game
6 
84%Game Brain Scorehumor, storyreplayability, grinding84% User Score 1,508 reviewsCritic Score 85%7 reviewsA hilarious adventure game.
View GameView Game
7 
88%Game Brain Scorehumor, storymonetization, atmosphere97% User Score 409 reviewsCritic Score 57%2 reviewsAn absurd, strange, and hilarious underwater adventure featuring THE Clam Man, duck, nasty drinks, and the horrifying reality of mayonnaise crime.
View GameView Game
8 
85%Game Brain Scorestory, humorgrinding, monetization89% User Score 3,108 reviewsCritic Score 61%1 reviewsLed by her new friend, Misfortune ventures in a quest to find Eternal Happiness.
View GameView Game
9 
96%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, grinding96% User Score 2,590 reviewsSolve puzzles, collect clues, explore the swamp, interrogate suspects... and uncover the mystery! Detective Grimoire is a charming and mysterious adventure, featuring a variety of strange and unique interactions with the bizarre residents of the swamp, a compelling and challenging murder mystery to solve, and an original award nominated soundtrack.
View GameView Game
10 
82%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, character development82% User Score 413 reviewsMessage Quest is a tiny stained-glass point-n-click adventure about laziness and her herald. Imagine yourself as the main hero’s conscience, the one that must make him work when all he wants to do is sleep.
View GameView Game
