Games like The Wych Elm: A True Crime Murder Mystery Party Game
Looking for games like The Wych Elm: A True Crime Murder Mystery Party Game? Here are top role playing recommendations with a mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Cabin #5: Halloween Murder Mystery Game, Cabin #5: An '80s Summer Camp Murder Mystery Party or Behind the Curtain: Hollywood Murder Mystery Game for 6-10 Guests.
1 Cabin #5 Game Time: 1.5-2 hours Number of players: 6 players, all gender-neutral ️ Play Online or In-Person with you and 5 friends! We include instructions and separate game files for easy online hosting. ⛺ Theme: Halloween '80s Summer Camp Inspired By: Stranger Things, Goosebumps, The Thing, and all things '80s! ✨ The Host can play without knowing whodunnit Your Story Starts Here! There’s a…
View GameView Game


2 Cabin #5 Game Time: 1.5-2 hours Number of players: 6 players, all gender-neutral ️ Play Online or In-Person with you and 5 friends! ⛺ Theme: '80s Summer Camp Inspired By: Stranger Things, Goosebumps, The Thing, and all things '80s! ✨ The Host can play without knowing whodunnit! Your Story Starts Here! There’s always one summer you never forget. Teens Bobby, Jo, Charlie, Riley, Alex, and…
View GameView Game


3 ✨Behind the Curtain: A Hollywood Murder Mystery Game✨ This is a print and play murder mystery party. Game Time: 2-3 hours Number of players: 6-10 players, 9 Gender-Neutral Characters, 1 Character using she/her pronouns ️ Play Online or In-Person with you and 9 friends! Theme: 1950s Vintage Hollywood ️ Inspired By: Tinseltown, Hollywood, and a love of movies! Perfect for theater and Broadway …
View GameView Game


4 Murder at Menlo Park Game Time: 2-3 hours Number of players: 7-15 players, all gender-neutral ️ Play Online or In-Person with you and 14 friends! ⚙️ Theme: Retrofuturism/Steampunk Inspired By: The Prestige, Steampunk, Thomas Edison, Age of Invention ✨ The Host can play without knowing whodunnit Your Story Starts Here! During the 1904 World’s Fair, Dr. Ari Jacobson and Dr. Julian Shaw debuted …
View GameView Game


5 WANDERSTAR Game Time: 2-3 Hours Number of players: 7-15 players, all gender-neutral ️ Play Online or In-Person with you and up to 14 friends! Download your digital game instantly! Theme: Space Western Inspired By: Star Wars, Star Trek, Old Western Movies, and Firefly! The host can play without knowing whodunnit! Your Story Starts Here! In The Outskirts of the Frontier Star System, the crews …
View GameView Game


6 The Blade of Fate Game Time: 1.5-2 hours Number of players: 6 players, all gender-neutral ️ Play Online or In-Person with you and 5 friends! Theme: High Fantasy ⚔️ Inspired By: World of Warcraft, D&D/Dungeon & Dragons, Lord of The Rings ✨ The Host can play without knowing whodunnit! CONTENT WARNING: Mild violence, mild references to alcohol. Recommended For Ages 16+ Your Story Starts Her…
View GameView Game


7 Game Time: 2-3 Hours Number of players: 15-24 players, mostly gender-neutral ️ Play Online or In-Person with you and up to 23 friends! Download your digital game instantly! Theme: Vintage Carnival or Circus Inspired By: The Greatest Showman, Moulin Rouge ✨ The host can play without knowing whodunnit! Your Story Starts Here! It’s 1919, one year since the Great War, and the centennial birthday…
View GameView Game


8 55%Game Brain Score55% User Score 6 reviewsIs Northwood House Haunted?? Salutations, citizens of Salchester! After the Wytecliff family’s annual harvest festival banquet at their manor, the Northwood House, Lord Remington Wytecliff was found dead in the foyer. Foul play is suspected, and so is everyone who spent the night… This story is the first of six mythical incidents from around Salchester that I am writing about in a series of myst…
View GameView Game


9 92%Game Brain Scorestory, replayabilitygrinding, stability92% User Score 1,742 reviewsA keenly dark twist on the traditional murder mystery setting, The Deed is an Adventure/RPG game about getting away with murder. Arran Bruce, the rightful heir to Dunshiel House, returns home to settle a score with his estranged family.
View GameView Game


10 89%Game Brain Scorestory, replayabilitygrinding, monetization91% User Score 760 reviewsCritic Score 87%13 reviewsJuly, 1935. A murder has been committed aboard the SS Hook, eight hours out from New York.Only one problem: you did it.Can you get away with murder?
View GameView Game












