Games like New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia
Looking for games like New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia? Here are top casual puzzle recommendations, selected from player-similarity data — start with Abyss: The Wraiths of Eden, Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek or The Secret Order 2: Masked Intent.
1 View Game91%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, monetization91% User Score 676 reviewsDive into the mysterious underwater city of Eden, a forgotten utopia rich with Art-Deco beauty and dark secrets. Uncover supernatural forces and confront an ancient evil lurking in its deepest chambers. Explore this haunting world and unravel the spine-chilling mysteries hidden beneath the waves.
View Game2 View Game82%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, stability85% User Score 1,022 reviewsCritic Score 75%3 reviews"Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek" is a thrilling hidden object puzzle adventure game that takes you on a quest to solve the mystery of a missing teenager and uncover an ancient evil lurking in the peaceful town of Maple Creek, Vermont. The game features an evidence board to collect and analyze clues, AAA-quality cinematics, and stunning autumnal scenery. With its immersive storyline and challenging puzzles, you'll be drawn into this chilling adventure.
View Game3 View Game80%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, stability80% User Score 242 reviewsIn "The Secret Order 2: Masked Intent," the daughter of the Order of the Griffins' Master must save the organization from destruction by a rogue council member. Travel through time to recover powerful artifacts, uncover secrets, and thwart the Clan of the Dragon in this suspenseful adventure game. Restore order to the world and make amends for past wrongs.
View Game4 View Game91%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, stability91% User Score 195 reviewsIn "Mythic Wonders: The Philosopher's Stone," Emma, the protagonist, embarks on a journey to find her missing uncle who has vanished while working on a mythical portal. She steps into the unknown, entering a world of five elements, solving 48 puzzles and 21 hidden object scenes to uncover the mystery. With hand-painted locations and an immersive storyline, the game offers an engaging hidden object adventure experience.
View Game5 View Game98%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, stability98% User Score 109 reviews"House of 1,000 Doors - Family Secrets" is a single-player adventure game with an interesting plot, ingenious graphics, and a marvelous soundtrack. Players guide Kate Reed, a writer, through the House of 1000 Doors to save lost souls by exploring mind-bending worlds and uncovering their family secrets. This immersive game offers a unique and fascinating experience for fans of the adventure genre.
View Game6 View Game91%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, stability91% User Score 690 reviewsIn "Darkarta: A Broken Heart's Quest Standard Edition," play as a mother named Mary who is determined to save her kidnapped daughter, Sophia, from a dark and dangerous force. This game features an engaging story set in the enchanted valleys of the forgotten Indus civilization, and has received numerous international awards. With a focus on motherhood and true love, this is an emotional and thrilling quest to save Sophia and uncover Mary's own mysterious past.
View Game7 View Game96%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, monetization96% User Score 912 reviews"Enigmatis 2: The Mists of Ravenwood" is a horror-filled detective adventure game, serving as the sequel to "Enigmatis: The Ghost of Maple Creek." After a year of chasing the demonic preacher she encountered, the detective's trail goes cold in the redwood forests of Northern California. Upon finding an abandoned camper with deadly claw marks, the detective becomes entangled in a new mystery filled with shadowy intrigue. This immersive hidden object puzzle adventure is sure to captivate players with its thrilling plot twists.
View Game8 View Game73%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsstability, replayability73% User Score 486 reviews"Cursed" is a single-player horror point and click game with a good story, excellent graphics, and delightful music. The game offers a unique atmosphere and innovative puzzles, promising a thrilling experience as you save the world from evil. Join other adventures at the Steam store and join the JetDogs Steam group for updates and events.
View Game9 View Game89%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, grinding89% User Score 673 reviews"9 Clues: The Secret of Serpent Creek" is a horror-noir hidden-object puzzle-adventure game set in the 1950s. As a private investigator, you're searching for your missing reporter friend in the peculiar town of Serpent Creek, where citizens are sleepwalking and the streets are overrun by snakes. By collecting and combining clues in the Detective Mode, you'll unravel the dark secrets behind the town's supernatural events.
View Game10 View Game80%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, grinding80% User Score 354 reviews"Left in the Dark: No One on Board" is a hidden object puzzle adventure game set on a mysterious and abandoned cruise ship. As the player, you'll uncover the ship's ominous past and face supernatural forces while searching for hidden objects and solving intricate puzzles. With its eerie atmosphere and challenging gameplay, this game will keep you on the edge of your seat.
View Game












