Games like New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia
Looking for games like New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia? Here are top casual puzzle recommendations, selected from player-similarity data — start with Abyss: The Wraiths of Eden, Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek or House of 1,000 Doors - Family Secrets.
1 91%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, monetization91% User Score 676 reviewsFind your missing fiancé in the deepest parts of the ocean in a forgotten underwater city that hides many spine-chilling secrets and an ancient evil that is hiding in the deepest chambers of the once idyllic city of Eden.
View GameView Game
2 
82%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, stability85% User Score 1,022 reviewsCritic Score 75%3 reviewsImagine waking up after a powerful storm as the sun goes down. You find yourself just outside a small town on the side of the road. A shiver runs down your spine as your body remembers the recent dramatic events that your mind cannot or will not recall… Will you dare to solve the ages-old mystery of Maple Creek? What ancient evil lurks in the seemingly peaceful, pastoral lands of Vermont? Find a m…
View GameView Game
3 
98%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, stability98% User Score 109 reviewsWhat secrets do these souls share with Kate Reed, a struggling writer hoping to recapture her past success? These lost souls cannot move on. To save them, you must guide Kate between these mind-bending worlds as you explore the House of 1000 Doors.
View GameView Game
4 
80%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, stability80% User Score 242 reviewsBecome the wayfarer through the past to force back the evil power!
View GameView Game
5 
91%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, stability91% User Score 690 reviewsHaunted by strange curses from her orphanage days, Mary never knew the story of her dark past until that day. Enter the enchanted 'Netherworld' where your destiny was written in blood and which whispers of true love. A multi-award winner epic adventure game! Rated by many as their all time favorite!
View GameView Game
6 
96%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, monetization96% User Score 912 reviewsEnigmatis: The Mists of Ravenwood is a critically-acclaimed, beautifully crafted casual adventure game rich with horror, plot twists and shadowy intrigue. Follow the trail of a demonic preacher and unravel the secrets shrouded in the mists of Ravenwood Park! What happened to the abandoned camper covered by enormous claw marks? What lurks in the park’s shadows? Will you be able to solve the mystery…
View GameView Game
7 
91%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, stability91% User Score 195 reviewsFind the Philosopher's Stone!
View GameView Game
8 
80%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, replayability86% User Score 358 reviewsCritic Score 50%1 reviewsFind the missing woman lost in a mysterious Carnival of Horrors. Investigate two worlds: the one you know and an alternate plane existing behind the Hall of Mirrors. Discover the secret of an ancient being known as the Evil One. Reveal the story of star-crossed lovers and stop the Evil One from breaking its magical chains and invading our world.While traveling through dimensions, you will solve cl…
View GameView Game
9 
89%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsreplayability, grinding89% User Score 673 reviewsA casual adventure with hidden objects and logical puzzles. The action of the title takes place in the 1950s.
View GameView Game
10 
86%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgrinding, stability86% User Score 209 reviewsUse your cunning to defeat the demons of the Seven Deadly Sins and rescue humanity from destruction!
View GameView Game
