New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia

90%
Game Brain Score Based on 222 reviews
  • story
  • graphics
  • music
New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia Game Cover
Starting at $7.38Buy now
Get on Steam

"New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia" is a hidden object puzzle adventure game set in 1950s New York. As detective Laura James, you investigate a series of murders linked to a secret mafia organization. Solve puzzles, interrogate suspects, and uncover secret documents to crack the case and bring the criminals to justice. With its captivating storyline, immersive atmosphere, and challenging puzzles, "New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia" offers a thrilling gaming experience.

  • Mac OS
  • Nintendo Switch
  • PC
  • Windows
Genres & TagsPlay Modes

Reviews

90%
Audience ScoreBased on 222 reviews
story44 positive mentions
stability6 negative mentions
  • Engaging story with a mix of mystery and supernatural elements, keeping players intrigued throughout the game.
  • Variety of puzzles that range from easy to challenging, providing a satisfying gameplay experience.
  • High-quality graphics and sound design, enhancing the overall atmosphere of the game.
  • Some puzzles can be frustratingly difficult, leading to reliance on hints or skips, which may detract from the enjoyment.
  • The game can feel overly long and drawn-out, especially with the bonus chapter that may not add significant value.
  • Issues with saving progress, as some players experienced glitches that caused them to lose their place in the game.
  • story118 mentions

    The game's story is generally well-received, featuring a creative and engaging narrative that intertwines with the gameplay, including interesting puzzles and captivating visuals. While some players found the story to be a bit choppy or lacking depth, many appreciated the emotional involvement and the cinematic quality of the storytelling, enhanced by effective cut scenes and music. Overall, the narrative is seen as a strong aspect of the game, with a mix of detective elements and unique character interactions that keep players invested.

    • “The developers really put a lot of heart and soul into making this game, and it's apparent with an original movie-like storyline, regular intervals of background music, really good sound effects, voiceovers, and animation.”
    • “The story is intriguing, and it shows that as much thought and application went into the story as it did to the game itself.”
    • “The puzzles are challenging but doable, the story is compelling, and the conclusion ties everything together nicely.”
    • “I didn't care much for the story, and the cut scenes and voice acting are pretty meh.”
    • “I am new to HOG games and I found Enigmatis to be a great game, but this just bored me to death. Unlike Enigmatis, I found the story very lacking and I had no compunction to finish this game; it was a real struggle to carry it through to the end.”
    • “Instead of an even amount of story, characters, and puzzles, it was one right after another until you were almost numb.”
  • graphics40 mentions

    The graphics in the game are generally praised for their high quality, captivating art style, and attention to detail, contributing positively to the overall experience. While some users noted occasional glitches and inconsistencies, the visuals are often described as beautifully painted and well-matched to the game's theme. Overall, the graphics enhance the gameplay, making it visually appealing despite minor issues.

    • “Fantastic game to play, graphics are well matched and beautifully done. The soundtrack is superb and there's many puzzles, hidden objects, and collectibles to find and do.”
    • “This game has great quality in every aspect, from high-quality graphics to a well-done story.”
    • “Excellent game, superb graphics, easy to use controls, and a great story make this one of the very best hidden object games I've played.”
    • “It does sometimes have some wonky graphics, but the story is solid, the art is captivating, and there are many different level puzzles throughout the gameplay.”
    • “The story and graphics are okay, but the game has some bugs, and at some points, it is not quite clear what one is supposed to do (this might at least partly be due to the glitches).”
    • “In addition, the graphics and voice acting are decent for a hidden object game.”
  • music22 mentions

    The music in the game is widely praised for its beautiful composition and unobtrusive nature, enhancing the overall experience without overshadowing voiceovers. Players appreciate the regular background music and sound effects, which complement the engaging storyline and visually stunning graphics. While some noted the repetition of music tracks, the overall sentiment is that the soundtrack significantly contributes to the emotional depth and immersion of the game.

    • “The developers really put a lot of heart and soul into making this game, and it's apparent with an original movie-like storyline, regular intervals of background music, really good sound effects, voiceovers, and animation.”
    • “Fantastic game to play, graphics are well matched and beautifully done. The soundtrack is superb, and there are many puzzles, hidden objects, and collectibles to find and do.”
    • “The music is beautiful and does not disturb the player during the game.”
    • “The same music file plays on repeat.”
    • “The soundtrack lacks variety and quickly becomes monotonous.”
    • “The music feels repetitive and fails to enhance the gaming experience.”
  • gameplay16 mentions

    The gameplay is well-received, featuring a blend of hidden object mechanics and classic point-and-click elements, complemented by engaging puzzles and a decent mystery story. Players appreciate the beautiful hand-drawn art and the substantial playtime of around 8 hours for a low price, making it a worthwhile experience for fans of the genre. Overall, it offers a comfortable and enjoyable adventure.

    • “It has good puzzles, an okay mystery story, beautiful hand-drawn art, and a hefty amount of gameplay for the price.”
    • “It combines hidden object mechanics (with an interesting spin) with some splendid puzzle mini-games, and the end result is very good!”
    • “It's a nice enjoyable adventure with a good story and comfortable gameplay; if you like this genre, check it out.”
    • “As for gameplay, it's a mixture of HOG features as well as some from classic point & click adventure games.”
    • “I liked the previous game in this HOG series, finishing it in just two long spells of gameplay.”
    • “It has good puzzles, an okay mystery story, and beautiful hand-drawn art, but the gameplay feels lacking.”
  • stability6 mentions

    Overall, users report a generally stable experience with few glitches or bugs, suggesting that many issues may have been resolved over time. However, some players still encounter occasional bugs that can lead to confusion regarding gameplay objectives.

    • “The story and graphics are okay, but the game has some bugs, and at some points, it is not quite clear what one is supposed to do (this might at least partly be due to the glitches).”
    • “The story and graphics are okay, but the game has some bugs, and at some points, it is not quite clear what one is supposed to do (this might at least partly be due to the glitches).”
  • monetization6 mentions

    The monetization aspect of the game has received negative feedback due to excessive advertisements that appear before the game loads, which many users find unappealing and intrusive. This aggressive advertising strategy detracts from the overall gaming experience.

    • “Final thoughts: I have found the game developer's method of advertising their other games is unappealing.”
    • “The advertisement pops up before the actual game loads.”
    • “I only give it a negative review because they make so much advertisement for their games.”
  • replayability6 mentions

    The game's replayability is considered low overall, though achievements and the option to play on hard mode can enhance the experience for some players. While the initial playthrough is enjoyable and reasonably priced, revisiting puzzles and exploring the beautifully crafted open-world levels may provide some additional value for those seeking more.

    • “Achievements are always a nice addition and add a bit of replayability if you don't want to go hardcore right away, but I do suggest you go hard mode right off the bat - it makes the game slower and thus much more satisfying when you finish.”
    • “Now, with all that in mind, I will definitely say that the game was most definitely enjoyable from my end and was worth every penny - six hours for a comfortable playthrough for six bucks sounds fair to me; and with the replay value of revisiting the puzzles and the massive open-world levels with lush artwork, it's almost a steal!”
    • “The replay value for the game is low.”
    • “The replay value for the game is low.”
  • atmosphere2 mentions

    The atmosphere of the game is generally well-received, with many users noting it as a strong point alongside an acceptable storyline.

    • “The atmosphere is incredibly immersive, drawing you into the game's world.”
    • “The game's ambiance perfectly complements the storyline, creating a captivating experience.”
    • “Every detail contributes to a hauntingly beautiful atmosphere that keeps you engaged.”
  • emotional2 mentions

    Players report a strong emotional engagement with the game's story, enhanced by effective cut scenes and a compelling musical score. The game's length allows for deeper immersion in the narrative, contributing to a memorable emotional experience.

    • “This was by no means a short game, and I was emotionally involved in the story, with the effective use of cut scenes and musical score.”
  • grinding2 mentions

    Players find the grinding in this game to be excessively long and tedious, leading to a frustrating experience that feels never-ending.

    • “This one, however, was long and tedious and took forever to end.”
  • humor2 mentions

    The humor in the game is consistently described as hilarious, indicating that players find it exceptionally funny and entertaining.

    • “Hilarious.”
    • “Hilarious.”
    • “Hilarious.”
Positive mentions (%)Positive
Neutral mentions (%)Neutral
Negative mentions (%)Negative

Buy New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia

Play time

8hMedian play time
8hAverage play time
8-8hSpent by most gamers
*Based on 2 analyzed playthroughs

Videos

Similar Games