New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia

About

"New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia" is a hidden object puzzle adventure game set in 1950s New York. As detective Laura James, you investigate a series of murders linked to a secret mafia organization. Solve puzzles, interrogate suspects, and uncover secret documents to crack the case and bring the criminals to justice. With its captivating storyline, immersive atmosphere, and challenging puzzles, "New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia" offers a thrilling gaming experience.

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Single-Player Play through the game's story or campaign solo

New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia screenshot

90%

Audience ScoreBased on 157 reviews

story41 positive mentions

stability5 negative mentions

Engaging story that combines elements of mystery, supernatural phenomena, and a unique setting in 1950s New York.
Variety of puzzles and interactive hidden object scenes that require logical thinking and item usage, rather than simple item lists.
High-quality graphics, sound, and voice acting that enhance the overall gaming experience.

Some players found the puzzles to be overly complex or frustrating, leading to reliance on hints or skips.
The game lacks traditional hidden object scenes, which may disappoint fans expecting the classic format.
There are reports of bugs and glitches that can disrupt gameplay, including issues with saving progress.

story
120 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
34%
62%
4%
The game's story is a blend of supernatural elements and a detective narrative, focusing on the mysterious disappearances of mafia bosses and children in 1950s New York City. While some players found the plot engaging and well-integrated with the gameplay, others criticized it for being predictable or lacking depth. Overall, the story is generally regarded as solid, with a mix of interesting characters, compelling twists, and a cinematic presentation that enhances the experience.
- “The developers really put a lot of heart and soul into making this game, and it's apparent with an original movie-like storyline, regular intervals of background music, really good sound effects, voiceovers, and animation.”
- “The story is intriguing, and it shows that as much thought and application went into the story as it did to the game itself.”
- “The story is compelling: you're a detective in 1950s NYC trying to solve a string of disappearances of mafia bosses under mysterious circumstances.”
- “The story is not the greatest in the world but it's not illogical or plain stupid; it adds a bit of mystery and it does round off the game nicely.”
- “I didn't care much for the story, and the cutscenes and voice acting are pretty mediocre.”
- “What I got was yet another supernatural mystery involving the hunt for missing children with the mafia mainly as background to the main story, but I got over that disappointment relatively quickly as the story dragged me in.”
graphics
34 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
56%
35%
9%
Overall, the graphics in the game receive a positive reception, with many users praising the beautiful, detailed artwork and high-quality visuals that enhance the immersive experience. While some mention occasional wonkiness or low resolution, the majority find the graphics well-matched to the game's style and story, contributing to its appeal. The combination of captivating art and clear graphics makes it a standout in the hidden object genre.
- “Fantastic game to play, graphics are well matched and beautifully done. The soundtrack is superb and there's many puzzles, hidden objects, and collectibles to find and do.”
- “The story is very interesting and the artwork is so beautiful.”
- “Strong storytelling combined with outstanding graphics, excellent soundtrack and effects, good voice acting, lots of cut scenes that were high quality, original and challenging puzzles.”
- “It does sometimes have some wonky graphics, but the story is solid, the art is captivating, and there are many different level puzzles throughout the gameplay.”
- “Low resolution graphics.”
- “The graphics are correct, though I found the character I was incarnating not so well-proportioned.”
music
19 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
84%
5%
11%
The music in the game is widely praised for its emotional depth and suitability, enhancing the overall experience without overpowering voiceovers. While some reviewers noted that certain tracks felt familiar or repetitive, the soundtrack is generally considered beautiful and well-integrated with the game's narrative and visuals. Overall, the combination of a strong musical score, sound effects, and voice acting contributes significantly to the game's immersive atmosphere.
- “The developers really put a lot of heart and soul into making this game, and it's apparent with an original movie-like storyline, regular intervals of background music, really good sound effects, voiceovers, and animation.”
- “Fantastic game to play, graphics are well matched and beautifully done. The soundtrack is superb, and there are many puzzles, hidden objects, and collectibles to find and do.”
- “The music is beautiful and does not disturb the player during the game.”
- “The same music file plays on repeat.”
- “The soundtrack is also okay, but it lacks variety.”
gameplay
18 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
39%
44%
17%
The gameplay of the game is generally well-received, featuring a blend of hidden object mechanics and puzzle mini-games that provide a solid and enjoyable experience. Players appreciate the beautiful hand-drawn visuals, logical item combinations, and the interactive map that alleviates backtracking issues. However, some note the repetitive nature of the genre, while others find the overall gameplay engaging and worth the price, with many hours of content available.
- “An odd little game that somehow has this crazy premise, but makes it work with some solid gameplay.”
- “It combines hidden object mechanics (with an interesting spin) with some splendid puzzle mini games and the end result is very good!”
- “It's a nice enjoyable adventure with a good story and comfortable gameplay; if you like this genre, check it out.”
- “My only grief with this game is with the gameplay.”
- “Yet, the HOG genre consists of one of the most repetitive gameplays ever.”
- “The gameplay has an unusual amount of backtracking, but with the usage of the interactive map, nothing's a chore.”
stability
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
83%
The stability of the game is mixed, with some users reporting no glitches or bugs during their experience, while others frequently encounter issues that affect gameplay. Overall, there seems to be a divide, with some players enjoying a smooth experience and others frustrated by persistent bugs.
- “I experienced no glitches or crashes while playing it.”
- “The game runs smoothly without any interruptions.”
- “I was impressed by the overall stability; it never froze or lagged.”
- “Many users report glitches and bugs.”
- “The story and graphics are okay, but the game has some bugs, and at some points, it is not quite clear what one is supposed to do (this might at least partly be due to the glitches).”
- “I give up - too buggy.”
replayability
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
75%
75%
Overall, the game's replayability is mixed; while achievements, collections, and mini puzzles provide some incentive to revisit, many players feel the replay value is low. However, engaging with the game on harder difficulty levels and exploring its open-world environments can enhance the experience, making it enjoyable for those willing to dive back in.
- “Achievements are always a nice addition and add a bit of replayability if you don't want to go hardcore right away, but I do suggest you go hard mode right off the bat - it makes the game slower and thus much more satisfying when you finish.”
- “The bonus chapter, achievements, and collections do give this game replay value, as well as some mini puzzles to unlock.”
- “With the replay value of revisiting the puzzles and the massive open-world levels with lush artwork, it's almost a steal!”
- “The replay value for the game is low.”
- “The bonus chapter and achievements and collections do give this game replay value as well as some mini puzzles to unlock.”
- “Now, with all that in mind, I will definitely say that the game was most definitely enjoyable from my end and was worth every penny - six hours for a comfortable playthrough for six bucks sounds fair to me; and with the replay value of revisiting the puzzles and the massive open-world levels with lush artwork, it's almost a steal!”
atmosphere
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
67%
The game's atmosphere is praised for its blend of realistic thriller elements with supernatural themes, creating an engaging and immersive experience. Despite some plot issues, the overall ambiance significantly enhances the storytelling, making it a compelling aspect of the game.
- “While the plot involves a secret society and some supernatural elements, it retains a more realistic thriller-like atmosphere to the end.”
- “Overall, the atmosphere and story won me over, and I can say that this is a good game, but it has a lot of problems.”
monetization
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The monetization strategy of the game has received negative feedback due to excessive advertisements, which appear before the game loads and detract from the overall experience. Users find the developer's approach to promoting other games unappealing and intrusive.
- “I only give it a negative review because they make so much advertisement for their games.”
- “Final thoughts: I have found the game developer's method of advertising their other games to be unappealing.”
- “The advertisement pops up before the actual game loads.”
emotional
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Players found the game to be emotionally engaging, highlighting the effective use of cut scenes and musical score that enhanced their connection to the story throughout its lengthy playtime.
- “This was by no means a short game, and I was emotionally involved in the story, with the effective use of cut scenes and musical score.”
grinding
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
Players find the grinding in this game to be excessively long and tedious, leading to a frustrating experience that feels like it drags on indefinitely.
- “This one, however, was long and tedious and took forever to end.”
- “The grinding feels endless and becomes a chore rather than an enjoyable part of the game.”
- “I found myself repeating the same tasks over and over, which made the experience feel monotonous.”
humor
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
The humor in the game is consistently described as hilarious, indicating that players find it highly entertaining and effective in eliciting laughter.
- “The humor in this game is absolutely hilarious!”
- “I couldn't stop laughing at the witty dialogue and funny scenarios.”
- “The comedic timing and clever jokes make every moment enjoyable.”
character development
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
Reviewers praise the high-quality art and environment design that captures the hidden beauty of New York City, complemented by impressive character design and cinematics. This attention to detail enhances the overall character development, making the characters feel more immersive and engaging within the game's setting.
- “The character development is incredibly rich, allowing players to form deep connections with each character's unique backstory and motivations.”
- “I love how the characters evolve throughout the game, making choices that truly impact their growth and relationships with others.”
- “The depth of character arcs is impressive, with each character facing personal challenges that resonate with real-life experiences.”