New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia

About

"New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia" is a hidden object puzzle adventure game set in 1950s New York. As detective Laura James, you investigate a series of murders linked to a secret mafia organization. Solve puzzles, interrogate suspects, and uncover secret documents to crack the case and bring the criminals to justice. With its captivating storyline, immersive atmosphere, and challenging puzzles, "New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia" offers a thrilling gaming experience.

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Single-Player Play through the game's story or campaign solo

New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia screenshot

90%

Audience ScoreBased on 314 reviews

story82 positive mentions

stability10 negative mentions

Engaging story with a unique blend of mystery and supernatural elements set in 1950s New York.
Variety of puzzles and interactive hidden object scenes that require logical thinking and item usage.
High-quality graphics and sound design, along with a fast travel map that enhances gameplay experience.

Some puzzles can be frustratingly difficult, leading to reliance on hints or skips.
The game can feel overly long and drawn out, especially with excessive backtracking.
Occasional bugs and glitches that can disrupt gameplay and progress.

story
240 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
34%
62%
4%
The game's story revolves around a journalist investigating the mysterious disappearances of mafia bosses and children in 1950s New York City, blending elements of supernatural phenomena with a noir atmosphere. While some players found the narrative engaging and well-integrated with the gameplay, others criticized it for being predictable or lacking depth. Overall, the story is seen as a strong aspect of the game, enhanced by quality graphics, sound, and a compelling mix of puzzles that tie into the plot.
- “The story is intriguing, and it shows that as much thought and application went to the story as it did to the game itself.”
- “The story involves mafia guys being liquified and at the same time kids go missing and you have to find how the two things are related, and it takes you all over New York City through an abandoned subway network.”
- “The main story features a journalist named Laura, who takes it upon herself to try and solve the mystery behind the kidnapped children and some mafia bosses who have been disappearing from all over New York City.”
- “I didn't care much for the story, and the cut scenes and voice acting are pretty meh.”
- “I am new to HOG games and I found Enigmatis to be a great game, but this just bored me to death. Unlike Enigmatis, I found the story very lacking and I had no compunction to finish this game; it was a real struggle to carry it through to the end.”
- “The background story is poorly integrated into the game, but it's ok.”
graphics
68 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
56%
40%
4%
The graphics in the game receive a generally positive reception, with many users praising the beautiful, detailed artwork and high-quality visuals that enhance the immersive experience. While some mention occasional wonky graphics and low resolution in certain areas, the overall art style is well-matched to the game's theme and contributes significantly to its appeal. Players appreciate the clarity and aesthetic quality of the graphics, which, combined with a solid story and engaging gameplay, make for an enjoyable experience.
- “Fantastic game to play, graphics are well matched and beautifully done. The soundtrack is superb and there's many puzzles, hidden objects, and collectibles to find.”
- “This game has great quality in every aspect, from high-quality graphics to a well-done story.”
- “Strong storytelling combined with outstanding graphics, excellent soundtrack and effects, good voice acting, and lots of high-quality cut scenes.”
- “It does sometimes have some wonky graphics, but the story is solid, the art is captivating, and there are many different level puzzles throughout the gameplay.”
- “Low resolution graphics.”
- “The story and graphics are okay, but the game has some bugs, and at some points, it is not quite clear what one is supposed to do (this might at least partly be due to the glitches).”
music
38 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
84%
11%
5%
The music in the game is widely praised for its emotional depth and suitability, enhancing the overall experience without overpowering voiceovers. While many players appreciate the beautiful soundtrack and sound effects, some note that certain music tracks feel familiar, suggesting a reuse from previous titles. Overall, the combination of music, graphics, and storytelling creates an engaging atmosphere that keeps players invested.
- “The music is beautiful and doesn't disturb the player during the game.”
- “Fantastic game to play, graphics are well matched and beautifully done. The soundtrack is superb and there are many puzzles, hidden objects, and collectibles to find and do.”
- “The musical score fits the game perfectly.”
- “The soundtrack is also okay.”
- “The same music file is repeated throughout the game.”
gameplay
36 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
39%
53%
8%
The gameplay is generally well-received, featuring a blend of hidden object mechanics and puzzle mini-games that provide a solid and enjoyable experience. While some players note the repetitive nature of the genre and the presence of backtracking, the interactive map helps mitigate these issues. Overall, the game offers good value with its engaging puzzles, beautiful visuals, and a comfortable adventure experience for fans of the genre.
- “It combines hidden object mechanics (with an interesting spin) with some splendid puzzle mini games, and the end result is very good!”
- “It's a nice enjoyable adventure with a good story and comfortable gameplay; if you like this genre, check it out.”
- “[i]New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia[/i] is one great HOG, with hours of gameplay, imaginative puzzles that I haven't seen before, which come with comparatively logical item combinations.”
- “My only grief with this game is with the gameplay.”
- “Yet, the hog genre consists of one of the most repetitive gameplays ever.”
- “The gameplay has an unusual amount of backtracking, but with the usage of the interactive map, nothing's a chore.”
stability
12 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
17%
83%
The stability of the game appears to be inconsistent among users; while some report no glitches or bugs, others frequently encounter issues that hinder gameplay. This divide suggests that while some players may have a smooth experience, many others find the game plagued by bugs that affect clarity and enjoyment. Overall, stability seems to vary significantly, with a notable number of users expressing frustration over persistent glitches.
- “I experienced no glitches or crashes while playing it.”
- “I experienced no glitches or crashes while playing it.”
- “Many users report glitches and bugs.”
- “The story and graphics are okay, but the game has some bugs, and at some points, it is not quite clear what one is supposed to do (this might at least partly be due to the glitches).”
- “I give up - too buggy.”
replayability
8 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
38%
24%
38%
The game's replayability is mixed; while achievements, bonus chapters, and mini puzzles offer some incentive to revisit, many players feel the overall replay value is low. However, engaging with the game on hard mode can enhance the experience, making it more satisfying and enjoyable. Overall, the combination of content and affordable pricing makes it a worthwhile experience for those willing to explore its features.
- “The bonus chapter, achievements, and collections do give this game replay value, as well as some mini puzzles to unlock.”
- “Now, with all that in mind, I will definitely say that the game was most definitely enjoyable from my end and was worth every penny - six hours for a comfortable playthrough for six bucks sounds fair to me; and with the replay value of revisiting the puzzles and the massive open-world levels with lush artwork, it's almost a steal!”
- “Achievements are always a nice addition and add a bit of replayability if you don't want to go hardcore right away, but I do suggest you go hard mode right off the bat - it makes the game slower and thus much more satisfying when you finish.”
- “The replay value for the game is low.”
- “The replay value for the game is low.”
- “The bonus chapter and achievements and collections do give this game replay value as well as some mini puzzles to unlock.”
atmosphere
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
50%
17%
The game's atmosphere is praised for its blend of realistic thriller elements with supernatural themes, creating an engaging and immersive experience. Despite some narrative flaws, the overall ambiance and storyline effectively captivate players.
- “While the plot involves a secret society and some supernatural elements, it retains a more realistic thriller-like atmosphere to the end.”
- “Overall, the atmosphere and story won me over, and I can say that this is a good game, but it has a lot of problems.”
monetization
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The monetization strategy of the game has received negative feedback due to excessive advertisements that appear before the game loads, which many users find unappealing and intrusive.
- “Final thoughts: I have found the game developer's method of advertising their other games is unappealing.”
- “The advertisement pops up before the actual game loads.”
- “I only give it a negative review because they make so much advertisement for their games.”
emotional
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Players report a strong emotional engagement with the game's story, enhanced by effective cut scenes and a compelling musical score. The length of the game allows for deeper investment in the narrative.
- “This was by no means a short game, and I was emotionally involved in the story, with the effective use of cut scenes and musical score.”
grinding
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Players find the grinding aspect of the game to be excessively long and tedious, leading to a frustrating experience that feels like it drags on indefinitely.
- “This one, however, was long and tedious and took forever to end.”
humor
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The humor in the game is consistently praised as hilarious, indicating that players find it exceptionally funny and entertaining.
- “Hilarious.”
- “Hilarious.”
character development
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The character development is enhanced by high-quality art and environment design, showcasing the hidden beauty of New York City during its darker periods, complemented by stunning character design and impressive cinematics.

Buy New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia

8h Median play time

8h Average play time

8-8h Spent by most gamers

*Based on 2 analyzed playthroughs

Videos

91%676reviews

Abyss: The Wraiths of Eden

2014

Casual Action Adventure

+15

87%686reviews

Nightmares from the Deep: The Cursed Heart

2014

Casual Puzzle

88%652reviews

9 Clues: The Secret of Serpent Creek

2014

Casual Puzzle

+15

79%676reviews

Left in the Dark: No One on Board

2014

Casual Puzzle

85%1kreviews

Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek

2014

Casual Puzzle

+15

90%328reviews

Nightmares from the Deep 3: Davy Jones

2015

Casual Puzzle

77%192reviews

Questerium: Sinister Trinity HD Collector's Edition

2015

Action

74%1.2kreviews

Frankenstein Master of Death

2015

Casual Puzzle

91%235reviews

Portal of Evil: Stolen Runes Collector's Edition

2015

Casual Action Adventure

92%402reviews

Enigmatis 3: The Shadow of Karkhala

2018

Casual Action Adventure

New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia

Platforms

About

Buy New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia