Games like Toyeater

"Those Who Remain" is a single-player horror platformer game with an intriguing story and pretty visuals, set in the eerie, darkness-shrouded town of Dormont. Players navigate through two interconnected dimensions, solving puzzles and making morally challenging choices that impact the story. However, the game is reported to be very grinding, buggy, and has a dense atmosphere, which may not appeal to all players.

"Dreams in the Witch House" is a horror adventure game inspired by H.P. Lovecraft's story. As a student of mathematics and occult, you uncover supernatural events and face otherworldly creatures in your apartment complex. Solve puzzles, navigate eerie locations, and survive the nightmares of the witch house.

"Stay is a single-player drama RPG with an interesting plot and great soundtrack. As the player, you communicate with Quinn, a stranger trapped in a locked room, through a real-time chat interface. Your choices and timeliness shape his escape attempts, with seven different endings, numerous deaths, and various conversation paths available."

"Closer To Home" is a narrative-driven adventure game where you play as a young author returning to their hometown after a long absence. The game explores themes of memory, identity, and the complexities of small-town life as you reconnect with old friends and confront the ghosts of your past. As you navigate the town and its inhabitants, your choices will shape the outcome of your story, making for a unique and personalized experience.

"Disturbed" is a hand-drawn adventure/horror visual novel inspired by experiences of depression and addiction. Play as Von, a struggling farmer facing a hopeless situation, and decide how to confront your fate. With no clear solution in sight, how will you deal with the hand you've been dealt? This short, impactful game may leave you questioning your own choices.

Verfall: A Dark and Strategic RPGThe world of Verfall is in ruins. The "Servants of Corrosion" have been unleashed, and now it's a race against time to save what remains. Heroes marked by the "Mark" carry the burden of a curse and must unite, facing the challenge with the few resources available. Traditional power-ups are not an option — every battle must be fought with what yo…

In "Ghost on the Shore," you play as a ghostly figure named Charlie, who has the power to possess and control other characters. The game is a narrative-driven, supernatural adventure that explores themes of memory, identity, and loss. With a unique blend of puzzle-solving and exploration, players will uncover the mysteries of a remote fishing town while navigating Charlie's own complex past.

"One Night Stand" is a visual novel that explores the aftermath of a one-night stand. The game puts you in the shoes of a character who wakes up next to a stranger, with no memory of the previous night. Through conversation and exploration, you must navigate the awkward situation and make choices that will determine the outcome of your one-night stand. With multiple endings and a focus on character development, "One Night Stand" is a thought-provoking and engaging game.

"Wolf Tails" is a visual novel game where you, a solitary cabin dweller, take in a lost wolf-girl and find yourself involved in the affairs of her pack, leading to romance and multiple endings. Play as either a male or female protagonist with unique dialog options and CGs. Enjoy beautifully illustrated scenes with animated intros and two romantic options featuring wolf-girls.

"Heaven's Vault" is an archaeological adventure game that follows Ali, a robot archaeologist, as she explores a mysterious network of ancient ruins, deciphering a lost language and uncovering secrets of the past. Players will solve puzzles, make choices that affect the story, and delve deeper into the rich history and lore of this ancient civilization. With a unique narrative-driven experience, "Heaven's Vault" offers a compelling and immersive journey through space and time.