Games like The Plaything
Looking for games like The Plaything? Here are top puzzle recommendations with a horror focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Solais, Lydia or Masquerade.
1 Game will be released for free on December 1, 2025! Solais Step into the unforgiving landscape of WWII Scotland as a Scottish Lighthouse Keeper. Your duty is not just to maintain the light, but to guard your family against German attacks and the encroaching horrors of war. Solais is a narrative-driven game with multiple endings, taking its dramatic foundation from the tragic real-life events at…
View GameView Game


2 81%Game Brain Scorestory, emotionalreplayability92% User Score 434 reviewsCritic Score 69%8 reviewsA story-focused adventure game about a little girl in the world of adults. How can you find a monster you can’t see?
View GameView Game


3 81%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplay100% User Score 32 reviewsAbducted by the dangerous Theater, Juliet has been turned into a puppet. Guided by the mysterious Narrator, Romeo will embark on a twisted journey through faux décors, rotating sets, and deceptive backstages. What secrets lie beneath the Theater? Inspired by the original Romeo and Juliet of Shakespeare, rediscover key beats of their tragedy in this expansive 3D reimagination. Explore the T…
View GameView Game


4 75%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsoptimization, monetization80% User Score 150 reviewsCritic Score 60%8 reviewsThe Shattering is a first-person, story-driven, psychological thriller that takes place in the pristine white aesthetic of protagonist John Evans' own dream. Players must piece together the fragments of the past and present, following the voice of the 'Doctor' as he guides them deeper into John’s mind. Players will experience the key moments of John's life that have defined and shaped him - they w…
View GameView Game


5 99%Game Brain Scoregameplay, story99% User Score 91 reviewsA cozy, nostalgic puzzle game about projected dreams Delve into the room, drag toys from the shelves, and handle them on the table to create a shadow play. As the shadows you cast uncover past family relationships and the environment around you changes and evolves, the lines between reality and fantasy blur. Projected Dreams is a charming, cozy puzzle game emphasising a casual, stress-free g…
View GameView Game


6 74%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsatmosphere, gameplay100% User Score 25 reviewsStep into the shoes of Everlyn Sterling, a new grad undertaking a temp job in a small town in dead winter. Little does she know this seemingly ordinary task will soon unveil a mysterious tale of a disturbed spirit. Solve a series of brain teasers, booby traps, and ciphers set by the ghost. Can you unravel why a once beautiful mansion now harbors a dark, ugly secret? FEATURES Simple point-…
View GameView Game


7 43%Game Brain Scorestory, emotionalgameplay, optimization55% User Score 35 reviewsCritic Score 30%1 reviewsWhat are the most important moments in your life? Lost At Sea is a game about life. It's about the journey we all take and the monster we all face. Set on a beautiful island, you will fight death and fear to remember the moments that connect us all and make life worth living for everyone of us.
View GameView Game


8 Step into a lookout tower as Chief Park Ranger Adrian in a point-and-click simulation puzzle game about exploring environments and experiencing natural connections. Director of Forest Service Millie has tasked Adrian with finding new weather discoveries alongside the help of Park Rangers Jeremy and Mark. Complete with a full soundtrack, be immersed in the connection of nature and wildlife that li…
View GameView Game


9 51%Game Brain Score51% User Score 2 reviewsSchool Night Séance is a modern take on the point and click adventure genre. A pair of best friends; the impulsive Melony, and the practical Letty, find themselves separated in a haunted mansion after performing an ill-advised séance. The girls will need to work together to solve puzzles, uncover the mansion’s mysterious history, and finally, reunite and escape the house! ------------------------…
View GameView Game


10 Whispers of Eldoria is a narrative-driven fantasy adventure game set in a magical land teetering on the brink of chaos. As the adventurer of ancient gateways, you must make crucial decisions that shape the balance between realms while unraveling the mysteries of Eldoria’s forgotten past. Whispers of Eldoria Needs You! You’ve been chosen to take on a pivotal role as the adventurer of Eldoria’s …
View GameView Game












