Games like TALLY
Looking for games like TALLY? Here are top casual simulation recommendations with a horror, mystery and historical focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Toll: The Ferryman's Ledger, Play with Me: Escape room or Where Time Ends.
- 53%Game Brain Score53% User Score 16 reviews
You take the coins off the eyes of the dead, and one of them must someday be your own. An idle game about Charon that actually ends: five rivers, a tribute owed to Hades, 147 dead people with unfinished business, and a last crossing about three hours in. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Toll: The Ferryman's Ledger.
View Game


- 56%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:music, stability56% User Score 224 reviews
See how a game created by the very Jigsaw would look like! Use the available objects, outwit tricky illusions and optical puzzles and above all, answer the question – will you dare to Play with Me? If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Play with Me: Escape room.
View Game


- 48%Game Brain Score48% User Score 5 reviews
3rd PLACE GIGANTIC JAM 2025 Download the game for better performance About: Because of the loss of your mother and your desire of seeing her one last time you decide to build your own time machine in your garage. But beware, time does not forgive. Duration: 10min How to play: MOVEMENTWASDINTERACTLEFT CLICKPAUSETAB or ESC Gameplay: Use tools Solve puzles Drag & GET THE FIVE… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Where Time Ends.
View Game


- 85%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, atmosphereMost mentioned negative aspects:monetization91% User Score 44 reviews
Deliver food to a weird house and learn about the residents' lives. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The House on Holland Hill.
View Game


- 66%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, optimizationMost mentioned negative aspects:graphics, atmosphere83% User Score 30 reviews
"Who am I ?" is a first-person psychological horror game with a linear narrative and an average playtime of 50-60 minutes to complete. StoryYou step into the shoes of Mark, a man trapped in a life he never dreamed of living. After receiving a letter announcing the death of his aunt, he decides to travel to his childhood home in search of answers and, perhaps, a chance to change his fate… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Who am I?.
View Game


- 84%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:gameplay, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:grinding, optimization92% User Score 1,726 reviewsCritic Score 45%1 reviews
KILL YOUR GOD. BECOME WORTHY. Horripilant is a chilling idle incremental dungeon crawl through the horrors of a forgotten underworld. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Horripilant.
View Game


- 84%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:atmosphere, storyMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, grinding84% User Score 770 reviews
There is an unusual cabin deep in the woods. It had served as a laboratory and a dwelling for three generations of Lodgers. But as of late the latest Lodger has been noticing weird changes in familiar surroundings; things are missing, noises and rattle heard. Something odd is coming out of the woods. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Knock-Knock.
View Game


- View Game80%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, atmosphereMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, music90% User Score 40 reviews
A woman killed herself. Uncover her motive in 3 surreal, hexagon rooms. Set in the aftermath of a tragic incident, Trance, Trauma is a point-and-click puzzle game where you play as the soul of the victim. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Trance, Trauma.
- 81%Game Brain Score81% User Score 86 reviews
You inherited a mountain bed-and-breakfast where guests keep checking in and the register says nobody has ever checked out. Four adults. One book. A cozy-horror mystery visual novel where the person you fall for decides what the town's curse really is — and what you do about it. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Lantern Hollow.
View Game


- 54%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:atmosphere, musicMost mentioned negative aspects:graphics, story86% User Score 14 reviews
In a remote, secluded location where no human foot has set foot, there is a laboratory conducting secret research. What purpose and what kind of research is being conducted in this laboratory is unknown, but it is clear that strange things are happening. Help with the research being conducted in this laboratory and complete the research, unraveling the mysterious events happening within. [The Par… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Paradixion: Laboratory.
View Game


Finish your last training run, if you can. Luis, a procrastination prone runner, has been training for his first marathon. Today is the day of his last training run. He knows he has 20 miles ahead of him, but unfortunately he's having a hard time starting. When he does though, strange things start to happen, pushing him ahead and forcing his hand. The world, shifting and bending to some unseen for… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Start Running.
View Game


- 53%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned negative aspects:story, graphics90% User Score 10 reviews
The Paraxition: Son's Room is the first series of The Paraxition, a point-and-click adventure game with a mysterious atmosphere developed by a solo developer in Korea. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Paradixion: Son's Room.
View Game


- View Game82%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:gameplay, atmosphereMost mentioned negative aspects:stability97% User Score 35 reviews
Hearing Voices is a unique indie short horror experience where you will need to put your listening and deduction skills to the test to solve puzzles. Mistakes have consequences. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Hearing Voices.
- 90%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:atmosphere, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, story90% User Score 58 reviews
Examine and test patients for common and novel infections using sophisticated medical instrumentation. Isolate and treat infected patients. Discover the wonders, mysteries, and horrors of medical science. Rumors of mysterious diseases and human experimentation are unconfirmed. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Symptoms of Infection.
View Game


- 79%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:gameplay, musicMost mentioned negative aspects:story, grinding100% User Score 30 reviews
Play a flute to solve puzzles and unlock secrets, looking for an exit of a dark place before the darkness consumes everything. In this dark immersive horror puzzle game, knowledge is key to put the pieces together. No music experience required. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Fugaz.
View Game


- 93%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:grinding93% User Score 136 reviews
Wake up in the nightmare world you created. This hand-drawn point-and-click adventure blends dark fantasy with psychological horror. Explore strange islands, solve puzzles, and shape the fates of those you meet. Your choices lead to multiple endings. You don't need to have played the first game. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Tormentum II.
View Game


- 66%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphics100% User Score 17 reviews
A romance reality show full of love, gossip, and delicious drama. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Heartbeat House: Hong Kong.
View Game


- 61%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, stability89% User Score 19 reviews
Saccharine Echo is a story that walks the line between psychological drama and dark paranormal romance. Your choices will shape the fate of a young woman haunted by an obsessive entity from another world. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Saccharine Echo.
View Game


- 38%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:gameplay, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:atmosphere, optimization62% User Score 13 reviews
NOTE: The game focuses on exploration and builds tension slowly to create a deeper and more meaningful experience. Its story is unveiled through surreal cinematic imaging. Estimated completion time: 1.5hours. Please do leave a review if you liked the game as it helps a lot! - How far will you go to reunite with your lost daughter? ItLivesInTheWoods is a first-person psychological horror game… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to ItLivesInTheWoods.
View Game


- View Game91%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, gameplay91% User Score 140 reviews
A claustrophobic anomaly-horror game where you can only turn, blink, and decide: is it real or not? Survive five endings and uncover Mike’s story. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Floor Above.
- 72%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, character development90% User Score 31 reviews
What Happened Here is a short adventure horror game: around 30-45 minutes, exploring the classic horror trope of being locked inside a house and exploring it in order to go out. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to What Happened Here?.
View Game


- 88%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, grinding88% User Score 51 reviews
A short, interactive visual novel set in the mid-19th Century, in which a poet fights against time as she's writing the most important work of her life. Poetry is the answer, but what is the question? If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Inversed.
View Game


- 52%Game Brain Score100% User Score 3 reviews
MDNE - My Dream Never End! You find yourself in your nightmare once again, but this time you will discover once and for all what causes it. In this nightmare, all your frightening dreams, childhood memories, fears, ancient Greek mythology, and your own unique and strongest fear are intertwined. To help make sense of it all, your inner voice will guide you, vividly remembering all your past nightm… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to MDNE.
View Game


- 75%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:humor, storyMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, music75% User Score 149 reviews
Fork Road is a first-person immersive atmospheric game with new gameplay , Be prepared to face fears you've never faced before If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Fork Road.
View Game


- 85%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:character development92% User Score 111 reviewsCritic Score 70%4 reviews
Tales from Candleforth is a folk horror 2D point and click adventure with puzzles and escape room mechanics. Using dark and evocative aesthetic it creates a nostalgic atmosphere where beautiful music compositions meet with 2D traditional and digital art and frame by frame hand drawn animations. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Tales from Candleforth.
View Game


- 92%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:gameplay, storyMost mentioned negative aspects:replayability, grinding92% User Score 2,715 reviews
Home Safety Hotline is an analog horror inspired telephone operator simulator where you answer incoming callers' questions about what's inside their home. Read through a vast catalog of common pests and household hazards, and do your best to become an expert in home safety. You will be held responsible for what happens. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Home Safety Hotline.
View Game


- 90%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:graphics, atmosphereMost mentioned negative aspects:story, gameplay96% User Score 45 reviews
NOW AVAILABLE ON STEAM FOR FREE! Ordinary Day On Steam In this short psychological horror you awaken to your regular routine, however, something is scratching to get out, something buried deep...Something that has always been with you waiting to get out, waiting for the opprtunity granted by the loss of your closest friend. Ordinary Day was #3 best rated graphics for the Brackeys 2022.2… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Ordinary Day.
View Game


- 78%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:humor, atmosphereMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, graphics92% User Score 36 reviews
A surreal supermarket shopping simulation. Explore a strange and thrilling supermarket like no other. Chat with the local "hoi polloi", complete legendary supermarket tasks and buy the products of your wildest dreams! If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Supermarket Times.
View Game


- 45%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, musicMost mentioned negative aspects:graphics, atmosphere59% User Score 27 reviews
A linear visual novel about five short stories, unrelated at first glance. Be prepared for mysticism, gloomy atmosphere and light psychological horror. Not recommended to play if you are experiencing depression or severe psychological state. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Experimentation.
View Game


- 56%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, musicMost mentioned negative aspects:stability68% User Score 34 reviews
In the beginning there was nothing, only the chaos of dreams, from it appeared Ksari. He tried to figure out how people work and help them. But he is still too young. And now you are here. You need to figure it all out ... If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to My Hidden Things.
View Game - 93%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:graphics, storyMost mentioned negative aspects:character development, grinding93% User Score 2,614 reviews
TORMENTUM is a dark Point & Click adventure game. The dreamlike, nightmarish atmosphere of the game was inspired by works of painters H.R. Giger and Zdzislaw Beksinski. The game's final look and feel was also strongly influenced by the universes of games such as Demon's Souls or Dark Seed. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Tormentum: Dark Sorrow.
View Game


- 72%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:monetization84% User Score 37 reviews
The Remainder is a dark fantasy mystery where you will try to save The High Magus Vyn from certain death. Will you find your way alone or will you reignite a lost love? Is it worth the sacrifice? Do you deserve to be saved? If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Remainder: Act 1.
View Game


- 95%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:monetization, stability95% User Score 8,234 reviews
Samsara Room is a new atmospheric escape room game by Rusty Lake! If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Samsara Room.
View Game


- 91%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:replayability, grinding95% User Score 2,003 reviewsCritic Score 75%2 reviews
Start your own family tree in the point and click adventure Rusty Lake: Roots If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Rusty Lake: Roots.
View Game


- 85%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:music, grinding85% User Score 220 reviews
My Beautiful Paper Smile is a story about a child trapped in a facility that raises children to be perfect. Their upmost joy is required at all times. They must smile always, never frowning; always happy, never saddened. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to My Beautiful Paper Smile.
View Game


- 87%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, gameplayMost mentioned negative aspects:replayability, grinding92% User Score 5,026 reviewsCritic Score 65%1 reviews
Unheard is a narrative-centric detective game.Put on your headphones and step back into the past. Use the voices you hear to return to crime scenes, tracking down each individual involved and solving the cases!The game puts players in the role of a time-traveling detective who is only able to use one sense, sound. Also, the game’s story is a non-linear experience. Players must build their own time… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Unheard.
View Game


- 94%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:stability, grinding94% User Score 10,000 reviews
Detective Dale Vandermeer needs to escape the Cube Escape room in Rusty Lake If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Cube Escape: Paradox.
View Game


- 91%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:grinding, stability93% User Score 1,358 reviewsCritic Score 80%1 reviews
Solve all plagues in the exciting point-and-click adventure Rusty Lake Paradise If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Rusty Lake Paradise.
View Game


- 92%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:monetization, stability92% User Score 3,218 reviews
Unlock the Cube Escape Collection and the mysteries of the Rusty Lake universe! If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Cube Escape Collection.
View Game


- 100%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, musicMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay100% User Score 71 reviews
A mystery horror visual novel game where you must survive seven days with a cursed painting. The protagonist, trapped in a gloomy studio for seven days, must contend with a cursed painting of a girl to survive. Rely on notes from past victims and manage to successfully paint her portrait. Be careful not to upset her, or you'll quickly find yourself facing an unfortunate fate! Will you be the one… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Matsuro Palette.
View Game


- 49%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, gameplayMost mentioned negative aspects:graphics, grinding82% User Score 11 reviews
The Island: Into The Mist is a mystery adventure visual novel where every decision counts. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Island: Into The Mist.
View Game


- 72%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, replayability72% User Score 138 reviews
Embark on a touching and creepy jorney about sacrifice and how sometimes a person pays for the sins of another If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The 111th Soul.
View Game


- 91%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:grinding, stability94% User Score 2,832 reviewsCritic Score 80%1 reviews
Solve all the puzzles in the eerie point-and-click adventure Rusty Lake Hotel! If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Rusty Lake Hotel.
View Game


- 94%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:grinding, stability94% User Score 1,252 reviews
A casual healing rpg that takes players on a journey around the house from the perspective of a young girl, what does she do when she's home alone? What strange things will you come across in the process, and while exploring, perhaps... What other strange secrets might you discover? If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to At Home Alone Final.
View Game


nib lives on your taskbar and plays a digging game while you work. step away and he keeps playing, then hands you a report card when you're back. over about two weeks he starts to notice what he is and who keeps leaving. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to While You Were Away.
View Game


- 47%Game Brain Score47% User Score 10 reviews
Navigate through a changed map everytime and all you can see is what your flashlilght reveals. Explore the space while avoiding a being hunting you down, to find out the answer to the mystery of why are you there or even where are you. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Moksha.
View Game


- 67%Game Brain ScoreMost mentioned positive aspects:story, graphicsMost mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, atmosphere92% User Score 24 reviews
You have been marked by a monster to be its next prey. Defend your cabin against the beast across the four seasons, listening out for its attacks to stop it before it gets inside. Complete tasks throughout the night in an effort to free yourself from its curse and return to a normal life. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Whispers of the Seasons.
View Game


A new apartment. A polite neighbor who knows every package you get. He wants his share. Every day, a little more. Keep him fed or become the meal. A first-person psychological horror. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Apartment.
View Game


Why am I in a place like this...? Strange exhibits are placed on every floor. And rooms that don’t belong here—spaces with no clear purpose. No matter how I think about it, I don’t remember ever coming here before. And yet… somehow, it feels oddly familiar. What’s more, all of this feels like it was prepared for me. Investigate the mysterious exhibition hall, gather scattered clues, an… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Paradixion: Exhibition.
View Game


- View Game
Step into an eerie silence, a place where childhood dreams have turned into eternal nightmares. You are a paranormal investigator, drawn by dark rumors of an abandoned school built on the ruins of an old orphanage where, decades ago, children died of a mysterious illness and abuse. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Firefly Shelter.




















































