Games like We Were Here First
Looking for games like We Were Here First? Here are top puzzle recommendations with a mystery focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with RETURN, Mystic Fishing: A Fantasy Fishing RPG or Yokumo: Night Parade.
️ RETURN RETURN is an action-adventure puzzle game set on a mysterious floating island in the sky. You play as Noah, a young boy whose peaceful life is shattered when a sudden calamity strikes and his sister Kyra is taken away by the ancient bird, the Harpy. The island is now plagued with darkness, perilous ruins, and relentless enemies. To rescue his sister and uncover the truth behind the disa… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to RETURN.
View Game


- View Game
Set off on your journey to become a Master Angler by experiencing the unique genre blend of fishing sim and turn-based JRPG combat all wrapped up with fantasy elements! Traverse over 10 unique and varied biomes, catching rare and exotic fish– both real and fantastical! Play a Timing-based fishing minigame to reel in the fish, before taking it on in a traditional party based RPG battle to weakened… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Mystic Fishing: A Fantasy Fishing RPG.
Find your truth. Tame your spirits. Discover your place. Yokumo: Night Parade is a turn-based monster-catching RPG set in the beautiful region of Aomori, Japan. Play as an aspiring Shaman and protect the land from a dangerous rogue group set out on terrorizing everything in their path. Why they've suddenly appeared with such fearsome force is unknown, although rumours have been throwing around &q… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Yokumo: Night Parade.
View Game


THE ASTERISK Season1: “BREAK” A young man named Leon, met an enchantress that is looking for help to save her world. That Enchantress has a unique ability to create a portal to another world which she inherits from her grandmother. But because of Leon's stupidity, he was accidentally brought to her world with abnormality because of unenchanted teleportation potion. In this first… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Asterisk Season 1.
View Game


- 65%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplayoptimization, atmosphere81% User Score 31 reviewsCritic Score 66%6 reviews
Adventure platformer about Potata's travel in fairy forest. Reveal all secrets and hidden treasures and don't forget to save the world. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Potata: fairy flower.
View Game


- 90%Game Brain Scoregameplay, music90% User Score 206 reviews
Embark on a journey with a group of villagers in search of a new part of the island to populate. Land on the hidden shores of the northern side of Isola and explore what was once a secret city. Find new sources of food to nourish your villagers and help them rebuild the remains of this mysterious city. Who lived here before? Where have they gone? What is the secret of Isola? If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Virtual Villagers - The Secret City.
View Game


- 57%Game Brain Scoregameplay, graphicsstory, grinding62% User Score 37 reviewsCritic Score 62%4 reviews
Alchemic Cutie is a relaxing adventure RPG set on colorful Wimba Island. While taming wild jellies, you’ll meet villagers, enter jelly competitions and uncover the secrets of the island. "Go on an adventure on the colorful Wimba Island to catch jellies, meet villagers, and discover secrets. With each jelly having uniquely generated stats, traits, and over 4000 visual styles, you can raise and ca… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Alchemic Cutie.
View Game


Breathe new life into forgotten islands. Pick up trash, recycle it, craft items, and build your own base. As you heal the land, it flourishes into a wild paradise. Explore by walking, riding a boat, or using a submarine, and change a world that reacts to everything you do! A World on the EdgeYou are not a hero. You are a maintenance bot: solar-powered, tethered to distant signals, and alone. The … If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Island Keeper.
View Game


Jaime was just playing in the forest when, drawn in by a beautiful red bird, he accidentally fell into a deep and mysterious cave. Now, he must find a way to escape while uncovering the forgotten secrets of this ancient place. In an underground world full of dangers and lost stories, you embark on an exciting adventure, solving puzzles, exploring hidden passages, and helping spirits that long for … If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Perimbó.
View Game


- 51%Game Brain Score51% User Score 2 reviews
"Lay thy head to rest, souls quickly spent The world has fallen, left no means to its end A harrowed sea bathed in neon light Steel yourself. Metal tends to bite." Vekari: Remote Bypass is a text-based psychological horror ARG built entirely in-browser. Explore the city of Faktoria, Haloran in the vast world of Vekari, where your decisions shape the world around you. An entire city controlled… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Vekari: Remote Bypass.
View Game












