Skip to main content

Games like The Devil In New Jersey

Looking for games like The Devil In New Jersey? Here are top action recommendations, selected from player-similarity data — start with The Devil In New Jersey, Evil Twin or Afterlight Catacombs.

Change display type

Skip Platform filter

Skip Play Mode filter

Skip Price filter
  • In the eerie depths of the Pine Barrens, the disappearance of four teenagers sends shockwaves through their idyllic town. Rumors spread like wildfire, but no one seems closer to solving the mystery of what happened to Leigh Anne Turino and her friends. That is, until you stumble across a lost VHS tape, revealing chilling secrets that threaten to tear your quaint community apart. Content Warning…

    View Game
    View Game
  • 40%Game Brain Score
    40% User Score Based on 1 reviews

    Evil Twin is a first-person psychological horror game that plunges players into a surreal purgatory shaped by guilt, science, and madness. You’ll explore a haunting world filled with cryptic puzzles, eerie environments, and symbolic storytelling — all from the perspective of a brilliant scientist trapped in her own mind. A Tragic Experiment Gone WrongLan Anh, a gifted researcher at Py King Corpo…

    View Game
    View Game
  • Afterlight Catacombs is a horror exploration game in which you attempt to escape a procedurally-generated labyrinth while a mysterious stalker chases you in the dark. Explore the winding tunnels, learn the secret about this dungeon and, above all, do not let your torch run out!

    View Game
    View Game
  • Life of Tabayama is a psychological thriller visual novel set in a quiet Japanese mountain town in the early 1990s. What begins as a lighthearted high school romance quickly descends into a dark and disturbing mystery. With a deeply emotional storyline, richly developed characters, and a creeping sense of dread, this is a game that explores what happens when jealousy, desire, and hidden traumas co…

    View Game
    View Game
  • 51%Game Brain Score
    51% User Score Based on 2 reviews

    DEMO EDITION IS HERE! WISHLIST ON STEAM NOW TO SUPPORT US SteamWISHLIST ON STEAM NOW TO SUPPORT US Hello horror community, colleagues, video game lovers, and indie development enthusiasts! Thank you for the support you've been giving us for these 2 years. These times have been very tough, but we keep working to deliver a quality experience, or at least we try to. We are two solo deve…

    View Game
    View Game
  • 50%Game Brain Score
    50% User Score Based on 1 reviews

    Gather around the wegi board with a group of friends on a stormy Halloween night in the late 1980s. What begins as a harmless game soon spirals into a dark, twisted tale of grief, betrayal, and deception. Wegi invites you to experience a short story-driven adventure to uncover secrets with the group and find out what happened to Sarah the night she died.

    View Game
    View Game
  • 90%Game Brain Score
    90% User Score Based on 47 reviews

    "Birthright" is a text-based game where you return to your childhood town after receiving a letter about a loss, uncovering a complicated web of mystery, magic, and gaps in your memory. Play as a male, female, or non-binary character, with 12,000+ words in the prologue and 10,000+ for Part 1. The game allows you to choose your pronouns for a personalized experience.

    View Game
    View Game
  • Story & Atmosphere Welcome to X Burger! This is the liveliest, happiest spot in town. Especially today! Because today is May 28th, World Burger Day. Customers are starving, balloons are inflated, and the celebration goes on as if it will never end. As a kitchen staff member in this cheerful chaos, your job is to prepare delicious burgers and serve them with crispy fried sides, dipping sauce…

    View Game
    View Game
  • Step into the unnerving depths of psychological horror with The Oldest View: Rolling Giant, a singleplayer/co-op found footage horror game. Unravel the mysteries buried beneath an abandoned shopping center as you and your friends navigate a labyrinth of terror, where every corner hides a new nightmare. In The Oldest View: Rolling Giant, you are part of a team of urban explorers, drawn to the omin…

    View Game
    View Game
  • 50%Game Brain Score
    50% User Score Based on 1 reviews

    About the Game: Beyond The Illusions Beyond The Illusions is a psychological horror game developed as a prototype in just 50 hours, delivering an eerie blend of puzzle-solving, atmospheric terror, and psychological twists. This first-person experience drags you into the depths of a cursed and near-deserted forest, where reality blurs and nothing is as it seems. You play as Dan, a heartbroken teen…

    View Game
    View Game