South of Midnight is Compulsion's best game by a country mile, emerging as an assured and beautifully crafted Southern Gothic folktale that feels like a bracing breath of earthy, swampy air.
Immerse yourself into the macabre and fantastical world of South of Midnight with the Premium Edition, which includes the full game, up to 5 days early access, and digital access (in English) to:
• South of Midnight Artbook
• Original Soundtrack composed by Olivier Deriviere
• The Boo-Hag Comic book by Rob Guillory
• Music Video: Songs & Tales of South of Midnight
• Documentary: Weaving Hazel’s Jo…
Stunning art style and visuals that create a captivating atmosphere.
Engaging and emotional story that explores themes of trauma and healing.
Incredible soundtrack that enhances the overall experience and fits the narrative.
Combat can feel repetitive and lacks depth, making it less engaging over time.
Some characters and story arcs feel underdeveloped or rushed, leaving loose ends.
Gameplay can be linear and lacks exploration, which may disappoint players seeking more freedom.
story
2,032 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
47%
51%
2%
The story of "South of Midnight" is widely praised for its emotional depth, engaging characters, and rich incorporation of southern folklore, creating a unique narrative experience that resonates with players. Many reviewers highlight the game's ability to evoke strong emotions, with themes of loss, healing, and community woven throughout the plot. While some critiques mention repetitive gameplay and a desire for deeper character exploration, the overall consensus is that the story is the game's standout feature, making it a compelling choice for fans of narrative-driven experiences.
“Between the wonderfully written story and the emotional depth of the characters.”
“The best part of this game is the story.”
“An amazing story, a morally grey/good ending, and great characters.”
“This game is really, really boring, it really is leaning 95% on the story which I'll admit is fine.. nothing amazing but fine.”
“As I pushed through the story, I found myself increasingly disengaged.”
“The story feels a bit shallow, some parts are intriguing however for the most part it did not do the folklore justice.”
music
1,187 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
49%
1%
The music in "South of Midnight" has received widespread acclaim, with many reviewers praising its hauntingly beautiful soundtrack that blends elements of blues, folk, and jazz, perfectly complementing the game's southern gothic atmosphere. Players noted that the music not only enhances the storytelling but also evolves with the gameplay, creating an immersive experience that resonates emotionally. Overall, the soundtrack is considered one of the game's standout features, elevating it above others in the genre and leaving a lasting impression on players.
“Id play this game simply for the music, but the scenery alone also makes this game put on a pedestal above so many others.”
“The soundtrack is a standout, won't spoil much here, but it adds a lot to the game.”
“The music is incredible, visuals are stunning, combat feels frantic and claustrophobic yet incredible when mastered, and the movement is slick.”
“3 hours in but after that everything is cheaply made including the soundtracks that feels like amateur students and on top of that they mention abuse children stories only to forget about them after molly die.”
“The music, too, stood out as a highlight, adding atmosphere to the opening sections although even this was a bit of a let down during certain parts of the game as i feel this was underutilised.”
“The game had potential the concept was strong, the visual style was inspired, and the setting was ideal for something special had the creative team not overly relied on the stop motion style and soundtrack to carry their game.”
graphics
673 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
60%
39%
1%
The graphics of "South of Midnight" have received widespread acclaim for their stunning and unique art style, often described as reminiscent of stop-motion animation or claymation, which beautifully complements the game's southern gothic narrative. Players are particularly impressed by the vibrant environments, character designs, and the overall aesthetic that enhances the storytelling experience. While some users noted occasional performance issues, the visuals are generally regarded as a standout feature, making the game visually captivating and immersive.
“South of Midnight has beautiful stylized graphics and music, also an artistic take on southern folklore.”
“The graphics are gorgeous, and the setting is perfect for this kind of narrative.”
“The art style is beautiful, the music is haunting and enchanting, the aesthetic and scenery are breathtaking.”
“But unfortunately the high quality art style is all it has going for it.”
“Graphic looks like from 2017, but it's suddenly drop fps on 9800x3d and rtx 5080 from 144 to 70 and it's terrible experience.”
“I genuinely love this game so far and recommend it as a visual experience, but while I love the visuals, I love almost everything about it, this monotonous gameplay between beautiful setpieces and story completely detracts from how great it could be.”
gameplay
625 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
25%
63%
12%
The gameplay in "South of Midnight" is characterized by its straightforward mechanics, primarily focusing on platforming and combat, which many players found to be repetitive and lacking innovation. While the game features enjoyable traversal and a captivating story, the combat often feels basic and button-mashy, leading to a predictable gameplay loop that may bore those seeking more depth. Overall, the game excels in its artistic presentation and narrative, but its gameplay mechanics leave much to be desired, making it more suitable for players who prioritize story over gameplay.
“The gameplay is fun, the soundtrack is amazing, and the story is genuine and emotional.”
“The gameplay is smooth, and the controls are easy to follow.”
“Gameplay in South of Midnight is a masterful blend of action and exploration, with a touch of strategy.”
“Game mechanics are extraordinarily repetitive.”
“The gameplay is boring and monotonous.”
“The main problem is the gameplay, it's so boring.”
emotional
170 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The emotional aspect of *South of Midnight* is widely praised for its beautifully crafted narrative and deep character development, often evoking strong feelings such as sadness, nostalgia, and joy among players. Many reviewers noted that the game effectively intertwines themes of trauma, grief, and personal growth with rich southern folklore, resulting in a heartfelt experience that resonates on a personal level. The combination of stunning visuals, a powerful soundtrack, and relatable characters contributes to an emotional journey that leaves a lasting impression, making it a standout title in storytelling within gaming.
“This game had such a hold on me that I cried during certain parts of the story.”
“The stories are raw, emotional, and do not shy away from the tragedies that have befallen these poor souls.”
“The connection of deep south folklore to the showcasing of heart-wrenching stories and moments when collecting and piecing together fragmented memories really had an emotional depth and labor of love put into it that you rarely find in other games nowadays.”
atmosphere
148 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
58%
40%
2%
The atmosphere in "South of Midnight" is widely praised for its captivating and immersive qualities, blending a unique visual style with a moody, well-composed soundtrack that enhances the storytelling. Reviewers highlight the game's rich, eerie environments and emotional depth, creating a compelling southern gothic experience that feels both inviting and mysterious. While some gameplay mechanics may be lacking, the overall atmosphere, art direction, and voice acting contribute significantly to its charm and appeal.
“From the very first moment, the game pulls you into its eerie, dreamlike atmosphere—and it never lets go.”
“The atmosphere is carried beautifully by a moody, well-composed soundtrack and a truly unique visual style.”
“The music, too, stood out as a highlight, adding atmosphere to the opening sections, although even this was a bit of a letdown during certain parts of the game as I feel this was underutilized.”
“While the gameplay is merely serviceable, the art, atmosphere, music, and story all come together to make this something special.”
“The game’s atmosphere is one of its biggest strengths, with a rich, eerie world that feels both mysterious and inviting.”
optimization
75 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
47%
42%
11%
Overall, the game's optimization is praised for delivering smooth performance across various hardware setups, with many players reporting minimal bugs and impressive graphics. However, some users experienced performance issues during cutscenes and significant stuttering on specific high-end configurations after progressing through the game. Despite these inconsistencies, the general consensus highlights a well-optimized experience that enhances the game's visual and narrative elements.
“The game also runs really well; I barely encountered any performance issues, so kudos for actually optimizing it.”
“A really enjoyable, well-paced story backed with one of the prettiest and most unique visual presentations I've seen in a 3D game in ages, and performance was silky smooth throughout. My mid-tier PC ran the game on max settings with a solid framerate throughout, and it looked great.”
“The game is also well-optimized, making the journey smooth and enjoyable.”
“However, technically it is a disaster. On a 7800x3d and 5080, it is barely playable after chapter 4 (there are 14 chapters in the game) due to atrocious stuttering, even with high and steady FPS.”
“If I had to offer any criticisms, it would be weird performance issues during cutscenes (the game itself runs fine on ultra, but cutscenes often slowed way down and had audio issues).”
“During early chapter cutscenes, you can really see the glitches and stuttering even at just 60 frames.”
character development
68 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
41%
55%
4%
Character development in the game is praised for its depth and emotional resonance, particularly through the character Hazel, whose journey is described as beautiful and engaging. However, some reviewers feel that the overall character development could have been more fleshed out, despite the strong character designs and unique storytelling elements. The art style and animation contribute significantly to the characters' appeal, enhancing the overall experience.
“Hazel's character development throughout the game is a beautiful thing to experience, and the gameplay was super fun and engaging.”
“This message didn't come across in a corny way - it was beautifully illustrated through in-depth character development arcs and interpersonal relationship arcs.”
“However, character development could have been fleshed out more.”
“I'm hitting recommend because the game has so much going for it in terms of art direction, sound design and music, character design, voice acting, setting... but the gameplay part isn't really doing it for me.”
“The music, character development, and story are the highlights of this game.”
humor
36 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The humor in the game is largely driven by the relatable and witty protagonist, Hazel, whose self-reflective remarks and reactions to her surroundings elicit genuine laughter. Players appreciate the blend of emotional storytelling with comedic elements, often finding themselves amused by the absurdity of situations and the quirky characters, such as the humorous catfish. Overall, the game successfully captures the essence of southern humor, making it both entertaining and memorable.
“The story is great, the voice lines are hilarious, the gameplay is fun, and the music is excellent.”
“One thing I particularly like, which reminds me a lot of Uncharted, is how Hazel tends to talk to herself and have those funny, witty remarks, much like the writing in Uncharted.”
“Hazel was quite funny and entertaining as she reacted to the situations she fell into.”
grinding
32 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
3%
3%
94%
Players consistently find the grinding aspect of the game tedious, particularly due to repetitive combat and enemy encounters that become monotonous over time. While boss battles offer a brief respite, the overall combat mechanics are criticized for being basic and frustrating, leading many to utilize the option to skip fights entirely. Despite the engaging story and beautiful visuals, the grinding detracts significantly from the overall enjoyment of the game.
“You'll need a second life for grinding.”
“Combat and platforming got very tedious halfway through the game, and at that point, I was playing to see more of the story and just tolerating the combat to keep the narrative going.”
“But after about the 2-hour mark, this game becomes tedious, annoying, and honestly, you just wish for it to end.”
“Visuals are nice and the story is interesting, but the gameplay and combat get very boring and tedious. You fight the same enemies over and over; the gameplay loop is just boring. I say wait for a sale.”
stability
24 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
42%
58%
Overall, the game's stability is generally positive, with many players reporting minor glitches and occasional bugs that do not significantly hinder gameplay. While some users experienced game-breaking issues, developers have been responsive in addressing these problems. The game runs well on various platforms, including the Steam Deck, and most players found the experience enjoyable despite the few stability concerns.
“The game ran flawlessly with no glitches or bugs.”
“So far great game, runs great, love the writing, and all the characters are well written and likable, best soundtrack of the year for sure.”
“But overall the gameplay is not buggy, it's lagging sometimes (cinematics for me, or cut voices out) but it's bearable and doesn't rip off any of the feel of the gameplay.”
“There have been a few game-breaking glitches; however, the devs have responded quickly to try and fix them.”
“During early chapter cut scenes, you can really see the glitches and stuttering even at just 60 frames.”
“While there were some glitches here and there, overall I rate it an 8 out of 10.”
replayability
13 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
15%
62%
23%
Overall, the game's replayability is considered very low, with many reviewers noting a lack of branching paths, alternative endings, and repetitive boss fights. While some players may find value in replaying chapters to collect hidden items, the general consensus is that the game offers little incentive to revisit once completed, especially given its price point.
“Parts of the game are broken into easily replayable chapters that show how much you have collected, with mini ‘gates’ separating you inside the chapter (though you can’t hop directly to them).”
“$40 might be a little pricey for a digital game with essentially 0 replay value, but if you like the visuals and the setting, I suggest checking it out.”
“It's worth the price of admission in my opinion, but the replay value is less than zero.”
“Replay value seems limited unless you're a completionist who enjoys going back to collect every hidden item, similar to how you’d replay Mario levels to grab missed stars.”
“[Little to no replayability – no branching paths, no alternative endings. Boss fights are repetitive and uninspired. Game is shorter than expected – feels like it ends just as it’s getting started. Gameplay loop lacks variety – great mechanics, not enough expansion. Chapter select overwrites saves – so plan your exploration carefully.]”
monetization
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Reviewers appreciate the game's monetization approach, noting that it avoids cash grabs and live service models, which enhances the overall experience. The focus on quality storytelling and art style, rather than aggressive monetization tactics, has positively influenced players' purchasing decisions.
“Just goes to show that Xbox can still fund really cool games just like back then if they don't focus on cash grabs and live service nonsense!”
“The monetization strategy feels overly aggressive and detracts from the overall experience.”
“It's frustrating to see a game that could be great bogged down by constant prompts to spend more money.”