Skip to main content
Games like Don't Be Afraid: The First Toy

Games like Don't Be Afraid: The First Toy

Games like Don't Be Afraid: The First Toy

Looking for games like Don't Be Afraid: The First Toy? Here are top action recommendations with a horror focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Don't Be Afraid: The First Toy, Don't Be Afraid or 月圆之堡 Castle of Full Moon.

Change display type

Skip Platform filter

Skip Play Mode filter

Skip Price filter
  1. 90%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, gameplay
    Most mentioned negative aspects:monetization, music
    90% User Score Based on 420 reviews

    Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy, is an introduction to the dramatic story of a boy kidnapped by a psychopath. Exploring the giant house of your torturer you will soon discover things worse than your childish nightmares. Take on the role of Jamie and see what phrase “The First Toy” actually means. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Don't Be Afraid: The First Toy.

    View Game
  2. 82%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, atmosphere
    Most mentioned negative aspects:replayability, grinding
    82% User Score Based on 425 reviews

    Your name is David, you are 11 years old... and this is the end of your innocent childhood. You have woken up in a dark, cold room. Despite the darkness, you are trying to recognize the surroundings, but in vain. You don't know, where you are. Frightening sounds can be heard all around you, the feeling of helplessness fills in your soul. You are too afraid to walk alone in this terrifying space..… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Don't Be Afraid.

    View Game
  3. Introduction A beautiful elf girl will become the bride of the castle. But the master is a monster. The castle is full of mysteries, There are switches and puzzles, The castle not only has scary clowns chasing you, There are also various ghosts and monsters. You can choose to escape the castle alone, Or choose a companion, Or escape with all your companions, Or live to be the bride of the castle, … If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to 月圆之堡 Castle of Full Moon.

    View Game
  4. *Before introducing the game, I want to tell everyone why I made it. I once saw a documentary online about a warrior named Nike from the international animal protection organization, the Anti-Poaching Alliance, and his fight against poachers in Africa. The documentary moved me, especially the moment when Nike was unfortunately shot and killed. I felt I needed to do something, and that's how the id… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Last Subway.

    View Game
  5. 62%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, music
    Most mentioned negative aspects:character development, optimization
    62% User Score Based on 90 reviews

    Beyond The Gates is a 1-4 player online co-op horror which mainly focuses on the storyline. Discover the truth behind a dark mystery that has been hidden until now. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Beyond The Gates.

    View Game
  6. View Game
    69%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, graphics
    Most mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, music
    69% User Score Based on 115 reviews

    The Fan is an interactive photo fiction with real locations and actors. The game is a first person thriller with a unique twist. Driven by a creepy and unsettling atmosphere, it will take you deep within the darkest places of Paris underground. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Fan.

    View Game
  7. Join the Viking heroes in a race against time to save the world from eternal darkness. As the sun and moon falter and Fenrir threatens to consume them, the Vikings must travel across realms to forge a magical chain that can capture him. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Viking Heroes 4.

    View Game
  8. game Introduction"Endless Nightmare" is a 3D horror-based puzzle and stand-alone game. Test your logical reasoning skills by piecing together various clues found throughout the game. The connected story and horror setting will hopefully deliver an unusual game experience for players.gameplayThis game is in first-person. You play as a police inspector James, your wife and daughter were mu… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Endless Nightmare.

    View Game
  9. 67%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:atmosphere, graphics
    Most mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, optimization
    84% User Score Based on 31 reviews

    Birthday Boy: A First-Person Psychological Horror Experience In Birthday Boy, players delve into the haunting psychological landscape of "Brian," a successful Manhattan investor who is forced to confront the traumatic memories of his past. The game explores the dark corners of his childhood, dominated by his father, Jo, a disturbed engineer with a penchant for dressing as a clown. Jo's eccentrici… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Birthday Boy.

    View Game
  10. A third-person sci-fi horror game about exploring your grandfather’s abandoned mansion and its interdimensional portals. Solve puzzles, evade monsters, and uncover why Dr. Voss vanished. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Mortimer Paradox.

    View Game
  11. 61%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, atmosphere
    Most mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, stability
    86% User Score Based on 22 reviews

    An episodic psychological horror experience based on fragmented memories and twisted perception. You’re looking at the first chapter of the Living Nightmares series — standalone stories that follow people grappling with distorted realities, fractured identities, and unsettling truths they were never meant to uncover. False FamiliarAfter a strange event leaves you disoriented, you begin to qu… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Living Nightmares - False Familiar.

    View Game
  12. 66%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:gameplay, atmosphere
    Most mentioned negative aspects:graphics, stability
    86% User Score Based on 28 reviews

    IMPORTANT: THIS IS ONLY THE PROLOGUE (CHAPTER 1) - IF YOU WISH FOR THE FULL GAME, PLEASE CHECK THE LINK FOR BABY BLUES NIGHTMARES. Baby Blues Nightmare - Prologue is only a small taste of the horrors that awaits in the full game. This is only the Prologue for the survival horror game where you play as a toddler and have to do what it takes in order to survive your horror-ish nightmares of what's… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Baby Blues Nightmares - Toddler Horror Game Prologue.

    View Game
  13. 57%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:music, graphics
    Most mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, replayability
    81% User Score Based on 21 reviews

    Pooh is no longer the cute little bear he used to be... something has corrupted him, and now he thirsts for blood. Gather your courage and investigate. Play as Friend, Pooh's favorite human in the world. Not just anyone can taste Pooh's honey. Read the invitation he sent and then head to his house in the forest. When you enter his house, you'll discover that Pooh has changed a bit. But that's oka… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Honey Time! with Pooh!.

    View Game
  14. View Game
    86%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, graphics
    Most mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, replayability
    86% User Score Based on 59 reviews

    Christmas Night is a story-themed horror game about Christmas and its beliefs. Will we be rewarded for being a good girl this Christmas or will we be punished for being a spoiled person? If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Christmas Night.

    View Game
  15. 90%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:emotional, humor
    Most mentioned negative aspects:graphics, gameplay
    90% User Score Based on 69 reviews

    A collection of short minigames about surviving trauma, depression, and a society that values commodification of grief. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to EVERYTHING IS GOING TO BE OK.

    View Game
  16. 78%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, graphics
    Most mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, grinding
    83% User Score Based on 46 reviews

    These days the Chestnut Lodge Asylum is abandoned and forgotten, but many years ago a terrible tragedy unfolded behind those rusty gates. Every year, patients disappeared from the asylum without a trace. Neither the nurses nor the police could find any clues. But one day, everything changed. My dreams draw me to the asylum and I yearn to return to my normal life - a life without nightmares, premon… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Abandoned: Chestnut Lodge Asylum.

    View Game
  17. 71%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:atmosphere, graphics
    Most mentioned negative aspects:story, gameplay
    71% User Score Based on 104 reviews

    She waits. Explore an abandoned house in black and white as you solve cryptic puzzles and try to make discoveries. If you like to work with others to discover things, then you may like this game. I hope you love it, I really hope you do. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Please Love My Computer Game.

    View Game
  18. View Game
    55%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:humor, atmosphere
    Most mentioned negative aspects:story, gameplay
    71% User Score Based on 28 reviews

    A psychological horror suspense horror game about a girl who unknowingly enters a shocking trap related to her grandfather, whom she has never met. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to INHUMAN.

    View Game
  19. View Game
    28%Game Brain Score
    44% User Score Based on 16 reviews

    The Secrets of The Forest is a horror exploration/adventure type game where you're investigating a mysterious forest to find out what creepy things is going on there after hearing countless reports of the forest being haunted. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to TSOTF.

    View Game
  20. 69%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, music
    Most mentioned negative aspects:gameplay
    92% User Score Based on 26 reviews

    Physical Exorcism SeriesThis game is part of the Physical Exorcism Series. You will see some of the same characters across the series, but the stories are independent of each other and can be enjoyed separately. About the GameA horror mystery adventure game with ghost story elements. Anxiety plagues college student Lily, whose crush Sally has gone missing. As Lily explores the truth, Sally's boy… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Case 03: True Cannibal Boy.

    View Game
  21. 85%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, gameplay
    Most mentioned negative aspects:grinding, stability
    85% User Score Based on 1,361 reviews

    The game of your dreams just dropped, DUCK SEASON, a hunter with ridiculous graphics. Luckily, it's summer vacation and Mom just surprised you with a one day rental of it! Unfortunately, as you binge play it becomes apparent that all is not right with Duck Season... If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Duck Season.

    View Game
  22. 64%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, atmosphere
    Most mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, grinding
    72% User Score Based on 498 reviews
    Critic Score 37%Based on 2 reviews

    Explore disturbing corners of the human psyche. Delve into a dimension of nightmares, the occult and a tense psychological world created in classic Lovecraftian style. As police detective Howard E. Loreid, you are tasked to solve the murder of Clark Field, a wealthy man involved in the occult. Your number one suspect is Loath Nolder; a highly respected private investigator. After mysteriously aba… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Darkness Within: In Pursuit of Loath Nolder.

    View Game
  23. 52%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:story, emotional
    Most mentioned negative aspects:music, graphics
    52% User Score Based on 97 reviews

    Embark with Heileen in a unforgettable voyage to the New World! Met with old friends, and make new ones. Find romance, avoid dangers and life your life to the fullest! If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Heileen 1: Sail Away.

    View Game
  24. View Game
    View Game
  25. The voices command you to commit a burglary! Unfortunately for them, you are blind and finding what they seek is a challenge! Chased after you try your best to not get caught and end up in the asylum. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Blind Rage.

    View Game
  26. "Little Slime and the Crown" is an exploration and puzzle platform game. Take on the role of a soft and squishy little slime creature, harness the power of the mysterious crown, search for five scattered calendars, unlock hidden passageways, journey to the temple, and return the crown! If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Little Slime and the Crown.

    View Game
  27. A mother is gone. A forbidden ritual still exists. ️ And deep inside the cursed woods, one boy refuses to accept death. Dark Tale - Lone Survivor is a story-driven top-down survival horror game where grief, fear, and love collide in a terrifying journey. You play as a lonely boy who discovers a mysterious ancient magical rod — an artifact said to hold the power to bring the dead back to life. … If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Dark Tale - Lone Survivor.

    View Game
  28. 51%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:atmosphere
    Most mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, story
    83% User Score Based on 12 reviews

    A routine night turns into a true nightmare. You are a psychologist trapped in a building filled with unsettling secrets and rooms that seem to watch you, while an unknown presence follows you without rest. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Exit: Echoes of insanity.

    View Game
  29. You are the V.I.P Client of a brand new casino on it's big opening night. However instead of just fun and games, you will need to run for your life. Key features:Randomness: In V.I.P Client you will engage in different games of chance, all with some factor of radomness and the only thing to gamble is your life. Every playthrough will be different, depending on how lucky you are on the odds Atm… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to V.I.P Client.

    View Game
  30. Terror on the Bayou is a 3rd person (1st-person in VR), exploration horror game where the player must navigate their canoe through a tangled swamp full of hazards and traps, stalked by a mysterious apex predator. Alone and afraid, the players will question if they are merely prey, or if the thing after them enjoys the torture of its victims. Whether they wish to rise to the challenge or row away… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Terror On The Bayou.

    View Game
  31. View Game
    61%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:music, story
    100% User Score Based on 12 reviews

    Blanky is a 2D platformer that combines fluid movement with fast thinking to avoid environmental hazards. Using multiple abilities discovered along the way, Jacob travels through nightmarish areas each with their own distinct dangers. Featuring epic boss battles, heart pounding chases and a compelling story, Blanky is a challenging platforming adventure that explores fear from a child's p… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Blanky.

    View Game
  32. You arrive home and notice that something very bad has happened to your wife. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Story 210.

    View Game
  33. 52%Game Brain Score
    52% User Score Based on 26 reviews

    And now he is forced to spend three nights at her coffin, fighting not only for his life, but also for the remnants of sanity. This visual novel in the best traditions of black humor and mystical horror If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Ведьмы зов.

    View Game
  34. 51%Game Brain Score
    51% User Score Based on 2 reviews

    This is the FULL version of the game.Follow me on twitter: https://x.com/steelkrillJoin our Discord Community: https://discord.com/invite/d8WUuuRCJK STEAM:  https://store.steampowered.com/app/2836820/Baby_Blues_Nightmares__Toddler_Horror...Baby Blues Nightmares is a survival horror game where you play as a toddler and have to do what it takes in order to survive your horror-ish nightmares of what… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Baby Blues Nightmares (Full Game).

    View Game
  35. Step into the enigmatic world of "Gummy Nightmares" as Player One, a young boy who awakens in a mysterious amusement park with no memory of his past or identity. Guided by a mysterious girl named Jenny, you must use your slingshot, whistle, and backpack to battle evil robots, solve puzzles, and find clues to recover your lost memories.Welcome to Gummy Park!Gummy Park was once a lively am… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Gummy Nightmares.

    View Game
  36. "The Demon's Exorcism" is a first-person psychological horror game that reveals the story of a family trapped in a haunting curse. Immerse yourself in the chilling narrative as you exorcise the demon and break the curse. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to The Demon's Exorcism.

    View Game
  37. Embark on a one-of-a-kind journey of exploration in "Elevator Experience". Step into the elevator and prepare to be transported to a world of mysteries, where every floor holds a new adventure waiting to be unlocked. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Elevator Experience.

    View Game
  38. 55%Game Brain Score
    55% User Score Based on 6 reviews

    ISSUE #51 Cover - Haven aka Caramellcast Hello and welcome to Indiepocalypse! Indiepocalypse is a curated monthly collection looking to highlight the very best of the alternative indie game scene.  Each month features games by 10 different developers, including a newly commissioned game exclusive to the bundle-zine. The games cover a wide variety of styles, genres, and themes as they figh… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Indiepocalypse #51.

    View Game
  39. 38%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:music, atmosphere
    Most mentioned negative aspects:story, gameplay
    62% User Score Based on 13 reviews

    Stories to Tell is a saga of psychological horror video games where each episode is based on dreams/nightmares that I, the developer, have had. (the episodes are short). -This is the second video game in the saga. In "Stories to tell - Downhill Cemetery" you are a young Japanese man named Hiroshi who decided to move to a new house, he did not know what awaited him... key features of &… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Stories to Tell [Alpha 2] - Downhill Cemetery.

    View Game
  40. Embark on a mysterious journey with Alexandra, who moves to a charming Swiss countryside house. As Alex begins to settle down, she begins to notice strange happenings around her, like what she believes to be vivid dreams about the house's past. Alex will soon find herself forced to uncover the truth, living a bizarre adventure to find out more. Through the memories, Alex will realize that the dist… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Droste Effect.

    View Game
  41. View Game
    61%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:music, atmosphere
    Most mentioned negative aspects:story, gameplay
    100% User Score Based on 12 reviews

    StorySix Meat Under takes place in an alternate universe in North Dakota during the summer of 1986. You are a front gate security officer on their first day of the job at the Kurzmann Laboratory, a research center focusing on medical innovations and pharmaceuticals through their discoveries in the meat pit. Oh yeah there's a giant meat pit, in case you didn't notice. Your first day turns into a ni… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Six Meat Under.

    View Game
  42. 25%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned positive aspects:atmosphere
    Most mentioned negative aspects:graphics, stability
    42% User Score Based on 12 reviews

    Rec: Beyond The Lens is a first-person horror game that tells the story of an unresolved past, with realistic graphics. Explore an unknown location, investigating dark secrets while using a body camera to document every step If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to REC: Beyond The Lens.

    View Game
  43. Play a crazy survival horror game and enjoy the terrifying slasher atmosphere!A hide-and-seek horror game with chilling plot twists awaits you!️ Scary Mansion is an exciting thriller with complex riddles and a maniac's sinister house. Remember all horror films about best serial killer Jason and Friday the 13th and feel like the main character of a scary story game. The evil genius Dr. Jason Crow f… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Unlucky Postman (Scary Mansion).

    View Game
  44.  Welcome to the North Pole Cast away your pathetic, childish fantasies; this is no winter wonderland. There are no toys here, no candy, no songs about tinsel and joy.  This is a harsh, bleak wasteland of chemical spills, centuries-long elvish serfdom and utterly absent hope. This is a land where the bells don’t jingle. They toll. Operation S.A.N.T.A. Operation S.A.N.T.A. is a "Festive" Rol… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Operation S.A.N.T.A..

    View Game
  45. In a grim world where reality intertwines with nightmare, you are the last surviving guardian, armed with a legendary bat—an ancient artifact of unimaginable power. Every step is a fight for survival in a distorted realm filled with mutations, ghosts, and monsters eager to destroy you. Bat of Dead is a brutal adventure where: Every enemy is a deadly threat The landscape constantly shifts and … If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Bat of dead.

    View Game
  46. 0%Game Brain Score
    0% User Score Based on 1 reviews

    This 8bit game is a port from a mystery source...This casual, linier, interactive story game centers around a campfire with old friends telling... tales. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Campfire Tales.

    View Game
  47. Includes: Koji (Character for Occult Raise) DLC. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Occult Raise.

    View Game
  48. Update: I will be redoing and adding stuff for this game. The glitches will be fixed in that release. check for updates on my Facebook. Play as a Dream Decay-er. Search houses to find active dreams to feast on. While feasting on dreams, enter the victim's dreams and discover their story. Then play as them in their dreams!  (very early access)  Known glitches:  I didn't have time to fix it (the … If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Leechs of Sleep.

    View Game
  49. 26%Game Brain Score
    Most mentioned negative aspects:gameplay, story
    26% User Score Based on 2 reviews

    Deadly Curse: Insane Nightmare Edition is placing you in the midst of an action-packed adventure game where you are in control. You enter a mental hospital where doctors are experimenting on patients unlike never before. A priest is here to help the doctors without knowing the stuff they do to those patients. If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Deadly Curse: Insane Nightmare.

    View Game
  50. Particules Studio presents Barrett Foster, a realistic and immersive puzzle game in which you play as the famous inspector to solve a dramatic personal investigation: The disappearance of his close friends, Emma and Gabriel, in murky circumstances. The starting point of this adventure is a phone call received from Emma and informing Barrett Foster that they must leave their home urgently for a ma… If you enjoyed this game, see our list of games similar to Barrett Foster : Chapter One.

    View Game