We Were Here Together is a fun escape the room type of puzzle game with an interesting story and beautiful aesthetic and soundtrack. It’s let down by some unnecessary difficulty and teething console issues with regards to controls.
We Were Here Together is a cooperative first-person puzzle game where players work together to escape a haunted castle in Antarctica. Players communicate through walkie-talkies to solve puzzles and uncover secrets, using only their wits and the items they find along the way. The game is a challenging and immersive experience that requires strong teamwork and communication skills.
The story aspect of the game has received mixed reviews, with some players finding it engaging and immersive, while others describe it as bland, confusing, or poorly executed. Many appreciate the attempt to weave a narrative into the puzzle-solving experience, noting that it adds depth, but some feel it detracts from the gameplay, with plot holes and a lack of coherence. Overall, while the story has its moments and connects to previous entries in the series, it often leaves players wanting more clarity and satisfaction.
“While the game is mainly about solving puzzles, the mystery and storyline that unfolds with it is very captivating, and we're excited to see in which direction this story continues in the next games.”
“The added depth to the story and the immersive environments made our journey truly memorable.”
“Great game, understandable puzzles, fun storyline.”
“The story is incredibly bland and at this point played out terribly for a climax. Do not buy!”
“The story just kinda seems to happen in front of you, with little explanation as to why.”
“The story was pretty meh and the focus is mainly on the puzzles anyway.”
gameplay
294 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
34%
62%
4%
The gameplay in "We Were Here Together" is characterized by its engaging co-op mechanics, requiring players to communicate effectively to solve a variety of puzzles that range from intuitive to challenging. While the game introduces new mechanics and environments that enhance the experience, some players found certain aspects, like the walkie-talkie communication and timed puzzles, to be frustrating or clunky. Overall, the game offers a satisfying blend of teamwork and problem-solving, though it may occasionally suffer from vague mechanics and technical issues.
“The game builds on the formula that worked so well in earlier installments but offers a fresh experience with new mechanics and environments that keep things exciting.”
“The puzzles in this game were the most fun and challenging yet, which kept the gameplay enjoyable even after playing the first two games in the series.”
“Amazing gameplay with puzzles that prove to be pretty challenging and intuitive once you start putting the clues and hints together, allowing for people to come together and learn how to communicate in fun ways.”
“The game has grown in beauty but gameplay fell through.”
“Things are aggravatingly vague and mechanics are not explained.”
“From what little I did play before losing my patience, it's a puzzle game but it's here to artificially extend gameplay time with stiff controls, slow walking, watching levers and cranks turn, pointlessly bad voice comms, and other such nonsense.”
graphics
280 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
45%
53%
2%
The graphics in this game have received significant praise for their stunning visuals and atmospheric environments, marking a notable improvement over previous entries in the series. Players appreciate the vibrant art style and detailed settings, which enhance the overall experience, although some have noted minor graphical glitches and performance issues. Overall, the visuals contribute positively to the game's immersive quality, making it visually appealing and enjoyable to explore.
“The visuals and atmosphere were also a step up from the previous entries, with some well-crafted environments that added to the sense of adventure and isolation.”
“The art style is visually stunning, with each location rich in detail and atmosphere.”
“The graphics are vastly improved over the previous two games.”
“Graphically, the game fails to impress.”
“The visuals are mediocre at best, with uninspired environments that do little to immerse players in the supposed atmosphere of suspense and mystery.”
“The lackluster graphics only serve to highlight the game's shortcomings, making it even more apparent that this is a half-hearted attempt at creating a gripping cooperative experience.”
music
187 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
63%
34%
3%
The music in the game has received widespread acclaim for its ability to enhance the atmosphere and overall experience, with many players praising the soundtrack as one of the best aspects of the game. While some found the music to be soothing and immersive, others noted occasional issues with repetitiveness or volume levels that could detract from gameplay. Overall, the soundtrack is considered a significant strength, contributing to the game's emotional depth and engagement.
“The music is amazing and creates a fantastic atmosphere.”
“A wonderful soundtrack and well-designed environment round off the whole experience.”
“The ingenious puzzles and stunning visuals, coupled with a haunting soundtrack, create an immersive experience that kept me hooked.”
“The soundtrack, if you can even call it that, is an assault on the ears.”
“Repetitive and grating, the music adds an extra layer of annoyance to an already infuriating experience.”
“Finally, as far as both art and music are concerned, well there's nothing special here.”
atmosphere
121 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
66%
32%
2%
The game's atmosphere is widely praised for its immersive and visually stunning environments, complemented by an exceptional soundtrack that enhances the overall experience. While the initial chapters create a captivating sense of mystery and adventure, some players note that the atmosphere can become less engaging as the game progresses, with certain areas feeling bland and puzzles becoming more abstract. Overall, the atmosphere is considered a strong point, contributing significantly to the enjoyment of the cooperative puzzle-solving gameplay.
“The atmosphere and art direction are well done, and immerse players in the mysterious world of the series.”
“The visuals and atmosphere were also a step up from the previous entries, with some well-crafted environments that added to the sense of adventure and isolation.”
“The atmosphere is amazing and the setting really feels like a journey.”
“But the further you go, the more abstract the puzzles get and the atmosphere becomes blander and blander.”
“The visuals are mediocre at best, with uninspired environments that do little to immerse players in the supposed atmosphere of suspense and mystery.”
“It's good for people who have hours and hours of chill and figuring things out but the atmosphere is sad, pulls on my anxiety strings and gives me no reward whatsoever if you have managed to do something right.”
stability
110 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
4%
96%
The game's stability has been widely criticized, with numerous players reporting significant bugs and glitches that hinder gameplay, including issues with server connections, unresponsive puzzles, and game-breaking errors. While some users noted improvements in stability compared to previous entries in the series, the overall consensus is that the game remains frustratingly buggy, often requiring restarts and workarounds to progress. Despite these issues, a few players still found enjoyment in the game, suggesting that it may improve with future patches.
“Nevertheless, really enjoyable game, for the most part bug free, and with good company, really really fun.”
“Game play is smooth, no glitches at all and nice visuals with an interesting story depending on who you played as.”
“Graphically, it's the best, it's smooth, it's clean, and it runs great.”
“The game is extremely buggy; a few times we couldn't join the same server, and the weird choice of proximity voice chat not being here would be doable if the walkie-talkies didn't bug out and we couldn't hear each other.”
“Firstly, this game is horridly buggy to the point that entire sections are nigh unplayable, which is extremely frustrating.”
“The game is very buggy; I spent hours in a room arguing with my partner about what to do, all because the game was bugged and didn't show what they needed to show.”
grinding
79 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
4%
11%
85%
The reviews indicate that the grinding aspect of the game is largely viewed as tedious and frustrating, with many puzzles lacking the satisfying challenge found in previous titles. Players frequently express that the puzzles feel overly long, confusing, and often require excessive trial and error, detracting from the overall enjoyment and sense of accomplishment. Overall, the game is criticized for its shift towards tedious gameplay rather than engaging teamwork and problem-solving.
“And not tedious at all.”
“A bit grindy sometimes.”
“A bit grindy sometimes.”
“The game quickly devolved into a tedious cycle of trial and error, leaving me feeling unsatisfied.”
“This starts strong, but the puzzles lose their shine and become tedious.”
“The puzzles are tedious and nonsensical without any sort of fun from figuring them out on your own, if you even do.”
replayability
56 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
29%
50%
21%
The game's replayability is a mixed bag, with some players enjoying the option to swap roles and experience different storylines, while others find the lack of randomized puzzles and predictable solutions limits replay value significantly. Many reviews suggest that while the initial playthrough is engaging, subsequent attempts may feel less rewarding, making it more suitable for cooperative play rather than solo experiences. Overall, the game offers some replay potential, particularly for those interested in exploring alternate perspectives, but it may not sustain long-term interest.
“The decision to give each player one different piece of the whole story is a really good idea; it's amazing to reunite at the end and find out that both of you have seen and done different things. It's good for replayability too; replaying the other side is a lot more fun than previous games.”
“I also really like the fact that the game has some replay value in that you can swap roles with your friend and play the game again through a completely different lens.”
“Replayability: the game offers multiple paths and endings, giving players a reason to replay the game to experience different outcomes and explore new paths.”
“The replayability of this game falls flat; a lot of puzzles are not randomized at all.”
“Sadly, these kinds of games lack much replayability once you know the puzzles. Most of the fun is seeing the puzzle fresh for the first time.”
“The solution to the puzzle your first time through will be the solution every time through the game, and as such, there’s almost no replayability here, which is a shame.”
humor
44 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The humor in the game is a standout feature, with players frequently highlighting the hilarious miscommunications and absurd descriptions that arise during cooperative gameplay. Many reviews mention the joy of sharing funny moments with friends, whether through quirky puzzle-solving or amusing in-game antics, making it a great choice for those who enjoy laughter and lighthearted chaos. However, some players noted that the humor can feel inconsistent, particularly in later stages of the game.
“There's something incredibly funny about desperately trying to describe an abstract symbol while your friend is screaming, 'What do you mean it looks like a dancing moose?!' 🦌📡.”
“Teamwork is essential, but expect some hilarious miscommunications along the way.”
“You can actually get drunk in this game, which I find hilarious.”
optimization
28 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
29%
42%
29%
The game's optimization has received mixed reviews, with many players reporting significant performance issues, including lag, stuttering, and frequent bugs that hinder gameplay. While some users noted that the graphics are appealing and the game runs well on certain systems, others experienced severe frame rate drops and connectivity problems, indicating that overall optimization is lacking. Despite improvements in graphics compared to previous entries, the game's performance remains a major concern for many players.
“The graphics have been significantly improved as well as the performance compared to the previous entry.”
“Good graphics, cute animations, well optimized.”
“One of the best puzzle games I have ever played; it runs smoothly, it looks beautiful and it's designed very well.”
“The game is constantly lagging and it's just poorly optimized, which makes it unbearable to do the puzzle and communicate with people.”
“Even when the recommended hardware is a GTX 970, this game is hard to run. It's probably due to some bad optimization with the newest hardware, so don't take for granted that you will have 120fps+ constantly with a new GPU.”
“Performance is absolutely awful; some rooms drop the framerate to just 20, while others give you a slideshow until it magically recovers.”
emotional
17 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Players consistently highlight the game's profound emotional impact, with many expressing feelings of sadness and nostalgia, often shedding tears during pivotal moments. The combination of a compelling story, heartwarming interactions, and heartbreaking endings fosters a deep emotional investment, making the experience both powerful and memorable. However, some critiques mention that certain plot elements can feel disjointed, detracting from the overall emotional resonance.
“I had goosebumps, and we even shed a tear.”
“The story, ending, and everything about this game was enticing, powerful, and at times emotional.”
“Truly an incredible emotional experience.”
character development
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
67%
33%
Character development in the game is criticized for its confusing storytelling and poor character design, leading to a frustrating experience for players. However, some characters, like the jester, stand out positively, with players expressing excitement for their future appearances and merchandise. Overall, the character development is seen as inconsistent, with both notable strengths and significant weaknesses.
“The atmosphere, the world, character design, and story were good.”
“Slight spoiler: I'm so hyped to see the jester character in future games. His character design and personality are absolutely amazing. There's a t-shirt of him on TMG's website, and I'm so tempted to buy it. I need more merch of him in my life.”
“I don't recommend this game unless you somehow enjoy being constantly confused, with poor storytelling, bad character design, and a lot of trial and error due to a lack of explanations.”
monetization
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The monetization strategy includes common ads on the main page, which some users find enhances immersion by promoting community engagement through Discord.
“On the right, there are the common ads that newer games like to add to the main page.”
“The next button in the bottom right corner of the ads says 'Join 5000+ fellow explorers on our official Discord.'”
“It really adds a new layer of immersion to the experience.”