Thick As Thieves

The gameplay offers a solid core stealth experience reminiscent of classic immersive sims like Thief and Dishonored, with enjoyable co-op mechanics and a compelling stealth loop. However, it is hampered by limited content, repetitive objectives, some unbalanced or leftover PvP mechanics, and technical issues that affect polish and immersion. While fun and engaging for its price, the game would benefit greatly from more maps, refined systems, and additional gameplay depth to reach its full potential.

The game's graphics feature a distinctive, charming art style reminiscent of Dishonored, praised for its atmosphere, lighting, and level design, though visuals can appear muddy or grainy at times. However, players frequently note the lack of basic graphics settings—such as key remapping, FOV adjustment, and advanced options like DLSS—and report performance issues and limited customization, which detract from the overall experience despite recent patches addressing some concerns.

The game offers solid replayability through its large, non-linear maps, randomized trap placements, multiple difficulty levels, and diverse missions, providing fresh experiences despite having only two maps currently. Co-op mechanics, gadgets, and character abilities add depth, though players desire more content such as additional maps, characters, and gadgets to further enhance replay value. Overall, it is praised as a well-constructed, enjoyable stealth experience with good replay potential, especially given its price point.

The game's optimization is inconsistent, running smoothly on modern hardware but struggling on lower-end PCs with occasional stuttering, crashes, and muddy textures. While some users report solid performance, many highlight unpolished aspects, bugs, and a need for further performance and quality-of-life improvements. Overall, the game feels somewhat unfinished and could benefit from better optimization before a full release.

The game consistently delivers a moody, immersive atmosphere that effectively captures the steampunk, stealth-inspired vibe reminiscent of classics like Thief and Dishonored. While it may lack some depth and sound design complexity of its inspirations, its art direction, dynamic audio, and level design create a compelling and enjoyable environment. Overall, the atmosphere is praised for enhancing the stealth gameplay and providing a richly immersive experience.

The game's stability is notably inconsistent, with frequent bugs, glitches, and occasional immersion-breaking issues reported by users. While some find the bugs minor and fixable, others describe the game as feeling more like an early beta, with odd movement and unpredictable behavior that impact gameplay. Despite these issues, players acknowledge its potential and fun mechanics, recommending waiting for updates and polish.

The game's humor is highlighted through its amusing glitches, quirky features like the "insult fairy," and comical gameplay moments, especially during cooperative play. Some users find the developers' presentation of familiar mechanics ironically funny, while others enjoy the lighthearted tone despite certain frustrations. Overall, humor adds a playful charm to the experience.

The music in the game is widely praised for its quality and ability to set a fitting, immersive mood with ambient and moody tracks reminiscent of Dishonored. Players appreciate how the soundtrack complements the game's aesthetics and weather conditions, enhancing the overall wholesome and satisfying experience. However, some find certain random Scottish music from in-game phonographs to be out of place and distracting.

Users are skeptical of the game's monetization, suspecting it to be a cash grab due to its price and perceived lack of content variety. However, others appreciate the absence of microtransactions and bugs, noting the reasonable value for a $5 price point. Overall, opinions are mixed, with distrust toward corporate motives balanced by recognition of fair pricing and no added microtransactions.

Grinding in the game becomes tedious due to repetitive map layouts and minimal variation across difficulty levels. The lock-picking minigame is a particular pain point, as increased difficulty extends the task without adding meaningful challenge. Additionally, holding down keys for interactions and lack of key rebinding options contribute to the overall frustration during grinding.

Players appreciate the game's aesthetics, music, and wholesome vibes for creating an engaging emotional experience, but some find the forced head bob and movement mechanics uncomfortable, causing motion sickness. The tense stealth moments, such as quick pick-locking and using smokescreens to evade guards, add to the game's emotional intensity.

The character development features cartoonish and expressive designs that maintain the painterly aesthetic reminiscent of Dishonored, creating a visually engaging and distinctive style.