Thick As Thieves

The gameplay offers a solid and enjoyable stealth experience inspired by classics like Thief and Dishonored, with well-designed maps, intuitive mechanics, and cooperative elements that enhance tension and strategy. However, it is criticized for its limited content, repetitive objectives, basic and sometimes clunky mechanics, leftover multiplayer features that feel out of place, and lack of depth or meaningful progression. While the core stealth loop is satisfying and fun, more maps, characters, and refined systems are needed to fulfill the game's promising potential and maintain long-term engagement.

The game's graphics feature a charming, cartoonish art style reminiscent of titles like Dishonored and Thief, which many players find appealing and fitting to the stealth gameplay and setting. However, performance issues such as poor optimization, muddy visuals, lack of advanced graphical options (e.g., DLSS, FOV adjustment), and limited keybinding support are common complaints, though recent patches have begun addressing some of these technical shortcomings. Overall, the visuals are praised for their unique aesthetic and atmosphere, but the technical execution and graphical customization currently hold the experience back.

The game offers solid replayability through large, sprawling maps with randomized traps, varied objectives, multiple difficulties, and co-op mechanics, making each run feel fresh despite there being only two levels. Players appreciate the core gameplay loop and the potential unlocked by gadgets, loot collection, and experimentation, though many desire more maps, characters, and expanded features to further enhance longevity. Overall, at its $5 price point, the game delivers good replay value but would benefit from future updates to deepen content and variety.

Optimization for the game is highly inconsistent, with many users reporting performance issues, crashes, and stuttering, especially on older or low-end hardware. While some players experience smooth gameplay and solid performance on high-end setups, others find the visuals blurry and the game poorly optimized overall, indicating a need for significant performance and quality-of-life improvements.

The game consistently impresses with its rich, moody, and immersive atmosphere that captures a classic stealth vibe reminiscent of Thief and Dishonored. Thoughtful level design, evocative audio, and detailed worldbuilding contribute to a compelling and polished experience, particularly praised within its cooperative gameplay. While some note occasional repetitiveness and sparser environments, the overall atmospheric presentation remains a standout and core strength.

The game's stability is widely criticized for frequent glitches, bugs, and performance issues, including crashes and problematic mechanics like the grappling hook and vaulting. While some players find it playable with minor annoyances, many describe it as a buggy, unpolished experience that disrupts immersion and enjoyment. Overall, it shows potential but requires significant updates and fixes for improved stability.

The game's humor is widely appreciated, featuring funny animations, entertaining voice acting, and amusing glitches that add charm rather than disrupt gameplay. Players often enjoy lighthearted moments, witty extras like the insult fairy, and humorous multiplayer interactions, making it a fun and engaging experience despite some technical quirks.

The game's music is widely praised for perfectly capturing the world’s atmosphere and enhancing the immersive, stealthy gameplay with a great soundtrack and sound effects. Its blend of ambient and thematic tunes sets the mood effectively, though some find certain random music choices, like the Scottish-themed phonographs, a bit odd. Overall, the music significantly contributes to the game's charm and vibe.

The grinding aspect is widely criticized for being slow, repetitive, and tedious, with limited map variety and unlocks that require excessive leveling. Gameplay elements like lock picking and item interaction are seen as monotonous, exacerbated by control issues such as unchangeable key bindings. Overall, the grind detracts from the experience, making progression feel more like a chore than engaging gameplay.

Users criticize the game's monetization as a likely cash grab with overpriced content, questionable pricing strategies, and excessive microtransactions, while also expressing frustration over forced PvP and broken updates. However, some note that the game lacks microtransactions and bugs, suggesting the developers may have simply abandoned the project rather than improve or properly market it. Overall, the monetization approach leaves players feeling exploited and undervalued.

Users find the game emotionally engaging with its tense stealth moments and strategic use of smokescreens, complemented by appealing aesthetics, wholesome vibes, and well-designed music and maps.

Character development is highlighted by cartoonish yet expressive designs that maintain the painterly aesthetic reminiscent of Dishonored, enhancing the visual appeal and personality of the characters.