Thick As Thieves

The gameplay offers a solid and enjoyable stealth experience reminiscent of classics like Dishonored and Thief, featuring well-designed levels, responsive mechanics, and cooperative play that adds strategic depth. However, it is limited by a small amount of content—only two maps—and relatively basic, repetitive mechanics with few innovations or meaningful decision-making, making the loop feel grindy over time. Despite some bugs and rough edges, the core stealth gameplay and atmosphere receive strong praise, especially at its low price, with potential for improvement as new content and refinements are added.

The game's graphics feature a distinctive, stylized art style heavily inspired by titles like Dishonored and Thief, offering a charming, immersive world with appealing aesthetics and level design. However, many users report performance issues, muddy or blurry visuals, and a lack of advanced or customizable graphics settings such as DLSS, FOV adjustments, and key rebinding. Despite these technical shortcomings, the visuals successfully convey the game's stealth atmosphere and have been improved with recent patches enhancing graphics options and fixes.

Despite having only two main maps, the game offers strong replayability through varied enemy placements, randomized traps, multiple contracts, and co-op mechanics that encourage experimentation and different playstyles. While some criticize its limited content and desire more maps, characters, and gadgets, the core gameplay loop and strategic design provide satisfying, engaging replay value—especially considering its low price point and ongoing updates.

Optimization for the game is mixed, with many users reporting poor performance, stuttering, crashes, and blurry visuals, especially on lower-end systems, while others experience solid, smooth gameplay on mid to high-end setups. The game appears to need performance improvements and better polish, with some suggesting it may be better suited as an early access title until optimization and quality-of-life issues are addressed. Overall, optimization is a notable drawback that currently holds back the otherwise enjoyable experience.

The game excels in creating a rich, moody, and immersive atmosphere that strongly evokes classic stealth titles like Thief and Dishonored. Its detailed art direction, dynamic sound design, and thoughtfully crafted levels contribute to a compelling and engaging stealth experience. While some note a lack of depth compared to its inspirations, the atmosphere consistently stands out as a major strength, enhancing both solo and cooperative gameplay.

The game suffers from frequent bugs, glitches, and unpolished mechanics that can hinder immersion and gameplay, including problematic AI behavior, awkward movement, and inconsistent tool functionality. While some players find it playable with minor troubleshooting, the overall stability is unreliable and feels closer to an early beta state, with potential for improvement through future updates.

The humor in the game is widely appreciated for its clever character animations, witty voice acting, and amusing extras like the insult fairy, creating many genuinely funny and memorable moments. Players often enjoy the lighthearted tone combined with humorous glitches and playful mechanics, especially during cooperative play. While some find certain jokes or references amusingly ironic, the overall comedic charm adds to the game's engaging and entertaining atmosphere.

The music in the game is widely praised for enhancing the atmosphere, perfectly matching the stealth gameplay, and contributing to an immersive, wholesome vibe reminiscent of titles like Dishonored and Sly Cooper. While most find the soundtrack and sound effects engaging and mood-setting, a few users note that some random music choices, like the Scottish tunes from phonographs, can feel out of place.

Grinding in the game is widely regarded as slow and tedious, with repetitive map layouts and little variation leading to monotony. Mechanically, tasks like lock picking and item interaction are seen as unnecessarily time-consuming and frustrating, detracting from the overall experience.

Users criticize the monetization for feeling like a cash grab, with forced PvP, frequent disruptive updates, and exploitation through microtransactions. They also express distrust in the developers' explanations and frustration over high prices that don't align with the content's value. However, some appreciate titles that avoid microtransactions and offer fair pricing.

Users find the emotional experience engaging and tense, appreciating moments of stealth and quick decision-making like using smokescreens to evade guards. They also highlight the game's wholesome vibes, appealing aesthetics, music, and map design as enhancing the overall atmosphere.

Character development features cartoonish and expressive designs that maintain the painterly art style reminiscent of Dishonored, blending vibrant personality with artistic appeal.