Thick As Thieves

The gameplay offers solid, enjoyable stealth mechanics reminiscent of classic immersive sims like Thief and Dishonored, with a rewarding cooperative experience and well-designed maps. However, it currently suffers from repetitiveness, limited content, minor bugs, and some unpolished or leftover mechanics from earlier multiplayer designs, making it feel basic and somewhat shallow. Overall, it provides good value for its price and shows strong potential if expanded and refined.

The game features a charming, cartoonish art style often compared to titles like Dishonored and Thief, with generally well-received aesthetics, lighting, and atmosphere that enhance its stealth gameplay. However, it lacks robust graphical options—such as DLSS, FOV sliders, and advanced settings—resulting in performance issues and limited customization, though recent updates have begun addressing some of these concerns. Overall, while the visuals are praised for their unique style and mood, technical shortcomings in graphics settings and optimization detract from the experience for some players.

The game offers solid replayability through its large, detailed maps, randomized traps, multiple difficulty levels, and engaging co-op mechanics, despite currently featuring only two maps and limited characters. While some players note the need for more content like additional maps, gadgets, and characters to sustain long-term replay value, the core gameplay loop and mission variety provide a rewarding experience at its price point. Overall, it's praised as a well-crafted, replayable stealth game with strong potential for future expansions.

Optimization for the game is mixed, with many users reporting solid performance on modern and mid-range systems, while others experience crashes, stuttering, and poor visuals, especially on older or lower-spec PCs. The game feels somewhat unpolished, leading some to suggest it would benefit from an early access phase focused on performance improvements and quality-of-life fixes before adding more content. Overall, while performance is decent on newer hardware, optimization issues and bugs currently hold the experience back for many players.

The game's atmosphere is consistently praised for its dark, moody, and immersive qualities that effectively capture a thief-like, steampunk vibe reminiscent of classic stealth titles. While some note occasional repetitiveness or emptiness in level design, the detailed world-building, dynamic audio, and art direction create a compelling and engaging environment that enhances the overall stealth gameplay experience.

The game is notably buggy and unpolished, with frequent glitches and awkward movement that can disrupt immersion and gameplay. While some bugs are minor or humorous, others cause frustration and occasional game-breaking moments. Despite these stability issues, there is potential for improvement through updates.

The music is widely praised for its excellent soundtrack, immersive ambient sounds, and perfect mood setting, often compared to titles like Dishonored and Sly Cooper. It complements the game's stealth mechanics and aesthetic vibes well, though some find the random Scottish music from phonographs oddly out of place. Overall, the sound design greatly enhances the gaming experience.

The humor in the game is widely appreciated, characterized by entertaining voice acting, funny glitches, and amusing extras like the insult fairy. Players find many moments genuinely funny and enjoy the lighthearted atmosphere, though some comedy is noted as unintentionally ironic or self-aware. Overall, humor positively enhances the gameplay experience, contributing to memorable and enjoyable sessions.

Users express strong skepticism about the monetization, suspecting it to be a cash grab due to perceived unfinished content and high pricing. However, they also note the absence of microtransactions and bugs, suggesting that despite its flaws, the game offers clear value for its $5 price. Overall, opinions are mixed between distrust of pricing and appreciation for a straightforward, low-cost experience without additional charges.

Grinding in the game is often described as tedious and repetitive, with little variation between contracts and difficulty levels, leading to monotony. Specific mechanics like lock picking and holding the interaction key add frustration without meaningful challenge, further contributing to the grind’s lack of engagement.

Users find the emotional experience engaging and immersive, appreciating the tension of stealth mechanics alongside the game's wholesome vibes, aesthetic appeal, music, and map design. The combination creates a satisfying blend of suspense and charm.

Character development is highlighted through cartoonish and expressive guard designs that maintain the painterly visual style reminiscent of Dishonored, effectively balancing distinctiveness with artistic appeal.