Settlement Survival
- October 24, 2022
- Gleamer Studio
- 18h median play time
"Settlement Survival" is a survival city-builder game where you lead your people to a new settlement, providing shelter, food, and protection while managing well-being, happiness, education, and employment. Shape your settlement layout near resources, build housing, recruit Mayors, and prepare for seasonal disasters and environmental threats. Attract residents from foreign cities and create a thriving, prosperous community.
Reviews
- Settlement Survival offers a deep and rewarding experience with a complex tech tree and various production chains.
- The game features beautiful graphics and a charming art style, making it visually appealing.
- Frequent updates from the developers show commitment to improving the game and addressing player feedback.
- The AI can be frustrating, with villagers often failing to perform tasks efficiently or getting stuck.
- The tech tree can feel convoluted and unbalanced, making it difficult to progress without making mistakes.
- There are numerous bugs and issues that can disrupt gameplay, including problems with saving and resource management.
- graphics235 mentions
- 34 % positive mentions
- 62 % neutral mentions
- 4 % negative mentions
The graphics of the game receive mixed reviews, with many players appreciating the charming, cartoonish art style and detailed environments, while others criticize the simplistic and sometimes low-poly visuals that can detract from the overall experience. Some users find the graphics soothing and enjoyable, particularly on lower-end systems, while others feel they lack the depth and polish seen in similar titles like "Banished." Overall, the aesthetic is generally considered pleasant, though opinions vary widely on its appeal and execution.
“Well done, graphics and setting are detailed.”
“The graphics are easy on the eyes with a bright color palette, the constructions are beautifully and impressively designed.”
“The graphics are very good.”
“Graphic design seems cute at the start but after a time it gets to an eye-hurting experience.”
“Unfortunately, the art style and gameplay were so bad that I had to seek a refund from Steam.”
“The graphics are very ugly, with blocky shapes and stiff animations, which makes staring at the game unpleasant.”
- gameplay233 mentions
- 28 % positive mentions
- 69 % neutral mentions
- 3 % negative mentions
The gameplay is often compared to "Banished," featuring a blend of city-building and survival mechanics that encourage players to develop complex supply chains and manage resources effectively. While many appreciate the depth and addictive nature of the gameplay, some criticize its steep learning curve, clunky mechanics, and occasional bugs that can disrupt the experience. Overall, the game offers a rich and engaging experience, though it may require patience to fully grasp its intricacies.
“The intricate systems and detailed mechanics offer a deep and rewarding experience, though the learning curve can be steep.”
“The gameplay is addictive and engaging, and I found myself constantly wanting to build and expand my settlement.”
“The technology research tree is a wonderful addition and adds a lot of depth to the gameplay.”
“The gameplay loop is a full repeat.”
“Did not get to the proper gameplay because the game feels clunky and not user-friendly to me.”
“Three hours of gameplay later, my new children were still in school and not yet old enough to do work, and I'm still struggling along shutting down one building so I can staff another.”
- music81 mentions
- 42 % positive mentions
- 52 % neutral mentions
- 6 % negative mentions
The music in the game receives mixed reviews, with many players appreciating its relaxing and cozy qualities, while others find it repetitive and lacking variety. Some users suggest muting the in-game music in favor of personal playlists, as the soundtrack can become monotonous over time. Overall, while the music is generally seen as pleasant, there is a strong desire for more diverse tracks to enhance the gaming experience.
“The music is cozy, and while it does take you a few tries to figure out what you're doing, it's honestly pretty fun.”
“The graphics are great and the music is really relaxing.”
“The music on this game is absolutely beautiful!”
“The music is kind of boring and repetitive; I had to turn it off and use Spotify in the background.”
“All you hear is the music loop, which is the same tune; there's zero variety.”
“The music needs a lot of work; basically, more music is needed.”
- grinding46 mentions
- 2 % positive mentions
- 9 % neutral mentions
- 89 % negative mentions
Reviews indicate that the grinding aspect of the game can be quite tedious, particularly in managing resources and farming, with players often feeling overwhelmed by the need for micromanagement and the slow pace of progress. While some appreciate the depth and replay value, many find the research chains and production management frustrating, leading to a sense of unnecessary grind, especially in the late game. Overall, while the game offers engaging mechanics, it can become burdensome due to the extensive micromanagement required.
“It had only minor bugs, is not as slow-paced as others such as the upcoming gridless foundation; kind of standard fare but enjoyable to expand and conquer your maps, and the achievements can be a challenge to get, for the most part not the tedious kind.”
“You'll need a second life for grinding.”
“The research chain is confusing and tedious; simply upgrading the building would work better, and there is no legend to explain what the icons mean.”
“My 40+ hours of playtime weren't without enjoyment, but in the end, the game becomes needlessly grindy and illogical.”
- story39 mentions
- 10 % positive mentions
- 77 % neutral mentions
- 13 % negative mentions
The game lacks a cohesive storyline, with many players expressing disappointment over the absence of a campaign mode or specific objectives, which leads to a sense of boredom after extended play. While players can create their own narratives through sandbox mode, the lack of structured missions or a compelling plot detracts from the overall experience. Overall, the consensus is that the game would greatly benefit from a more defined story-driven element.
“I would love if it would have a campaign/story mode with specific objectives, such as Frostpunk or Pharaoh, for example.”
“There isn't a particular story in-game, but after you pass the tutorial, you start your first city on a map generated by your preference, creating your 'own' story.”
“Storytelling at its best!”
“Unfortunately, the game does not have any plot, story, or specific tasks to be performed to meet any challenges.”
“My biggest gripe with the game is I eventually get bored because I don't have a storyline to follow.”
“But, with lack of a campaign, or even missions past a certain point, it's, for me, unenjoyable.”
- stability30 mentions
- 20 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 80 % negative mentions
Overall, the game's stability is a mixed bag, with many players reporting significant bugs and glitches, particularly related to AI pathfinding and saving issues. While it runs well on various systems and offers good graphics, the frequent bugs detract from the experience, especially given its early access status. Players express hope for improvements in future updates, but current stability issues are a notable concern.
“Runs great on my Radeon 2700X and RX 580X, so it doesn't require a beast of a machine to run.”
“The AI isn't buggy like it is in Banished, and the UI feels much more intuitive.”
“It runs great, looks great, and plays amazing.”
“Like Banished but more buggy and more features.”
“But it is so buggy, and the gameplay is uneven, and often illogical.”
“The game did work okay before the last update; now every time I go to save, it just freezes, and it does the same on the autosave.”
- optimization28 mentions
- 46 % positive mentions
- 43 % neutral mentions
- 11 % negative mentions
The optimization of the game has received mixed reviews, with some players praising its smooth performance and fast loading times, especially at lower population levels. However, many users report significant performance issues as city populations grow, leading to lag and stuttering, particularly during late-game scenarios. Overall, while there are positive aspects regarding graphics and initial performance, the game is seen as needing further optimization to handle larger settlements effectively.
“The game loads really fast, and is greatly optimized and has lots of things to specialize in.”
“Absolutely addicting game, well optimized, clear path of succession and advancement.”
“Optimized very well for larger population settlements.”
“In short, performance is awful.”
“It's cute-looking and may have some depth to it, but with the performance the way it is, I'll never know.”
“Severely lacking optimization options for a veteran city builder.”
- replayability18 mentions
- 33 % positive mentions
- 50 % neutral mentions
- 17 % negative mentions
Overall, the game is praised for its high replayability, bolstered by regular updates and new content that keep players engaged. While some users note mild to limited replayability, many highlight the enjoyable mechanics and production quality that contribute to its long-term appeal. The game's atmosphere and unique features, such as discovering seeds or livestock, further enhance its replay value, making it a recommended choice for players seeking extended gameplay.
“There's so much replayability, and with the constant updates coming to the game there's always something new to look forward to.”
“This game has super high replayability; I've downloaded and uninstalled it multiple times.”
“And while the price tag may seem steep, the amount of content and replayability offered by the game more than justifies the cost.”
“Limited replayability.”
“If you played Banished and thought it was a bit short on replayability, then get this.”
“Long time replayability I think will depend on how devs deal with the clunky UI aspects.”
- humor15 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The humor in the game is often derived from its absurd design choices and the comical ineptitude of its characters, such as children with adult proportions and the hilariously unreliable citizens who starve while performing mundane tasks. Players find the tech tree both confusing and amusing, with many aspects of the game eliciting laughter due to their broken mechanics and exaggerated scenarios. Overall, while the game has potential, its humor largely stems from its flaws and the ridiculous situations that arise during gameplay.
“The tech tree is hilarious in the sense that you have to do calculus to actually figure out how it all goes together.”
“There's no reason there should be issues from Banished in here, such as citizens being so hilariously unreliable while people starve to death lol.”
“Just, for the sake of your soul, don't zoom in on the people too much... it's hilariously awful how the kids are just shrunk down adults with adult proportions and full facial hair at 5 years old xd.”
- atmosphere5 mentions
- 60 % positive mentions
- 40 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The game excels in creating a captivating atmosphere, often compared favorably to classics like "Banished." Players appreciate its charming graphics, engaging complexity, and the replay value it offers, making it a standout in the city-building genre. Overall, the atmosphere is a significant highlight, enhancing the overall gaming experience.
“One of the few games that truly delivers on the atmosphere and style that it sells.”
“Best atmospheric city builder since Banished.”
“Overall, the atmosphere is captivating and there is enough replay value for multiple runs.”
- emotional3 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
Players report that the game's music and atmosphere evoke strong emotions, immersing them in a wilderness setting that feels both beautiful and perilous. The emotional weight of survival and the bleakness of winter contribute to a profound sense of vulnerability and tension throughout the experience.
“The music made me feel like I was deep in the wilderness, and the winters felt bleak and dangerous.”
“Settlement survival, emotional damage!”
- monetization2 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
The monetization strategy of the game has been criticized as feeling like an early access cash grab, with users suggesting that it is not worth the investment compared to other city builders. Additionally, while the developers have effectively utilized advertising, the overall impression is that the game lacks depth and quality.
“Spend your money on other city builders; this one is not worth it yet and it really does feel like an early access cash grab.”
“This feels like Banish but dumbed down. The devs have done a great job on ads; they even paid Skystorm to make a review video.”