Hylics 2
- June 22, 2020
- Mason Lindroth
- 13h median play time
In Hylics 2, players navigate a surreal world of claymation-style graphics and tweet-inspired dialogue. As the protagonist Wayfarer, you'll explore various landscapes, solve puzzles, and engage in turn-based battles. The game features a unique combat system that incorporates a variety of unconventional weapons and abilities, adding a layer of strategy to the RPG genre.
Reviews
- Absolutely beautiful art style, animations, and music that create a mesmerizing experience.
- Combat system is engaging and requires strategic thinking, making battles feel rewarding.
- Significant improvements over the first game in terms of polish, gameplay mechanics, and overall coherence.
- Platforming mechanics can be frustrating and clunky, leading to tedious navigation.
- Some battles can feel drawn out and unbalanced, especially with enemies that can heal themselves.
- The story, while more coherent than the first, may feel too straightforward and lacks the surreal charm of the original.
- music974 mentions
- 48 % positive mentions
- 51 % neutral mentions
- 2 % negative mentions
The music in "Hylics 2" has been widely praised for its psychedelic and experimental qualities, with many reviewers highlighting the contributions of composer Chuck Salamone alongside creator Mason Lindroth. The soundtrack is described as a significant improvement over the first game, featuring a mix of chill, groovy, and upbeat tracks that enhance the game's surreal atmosphere and visuals. Overall, the music is considered a standout element, elevating the gameplay experience and resonating with players long after they finish the game.
“Lindroth is a creative powerhouse when it comes to striking, vibrant visual art, and Salamone's comprehensive contribution to the groovy, surf-y, and psychedelic melodies that Lindroth gravitates to result in simply beautiful music.”
“The bizarre art style, unique and original world, and transcendent music is enough to inspire and entertain throughout the entire game.”
“The music further contributes, eschewing a lot of the overwhelming discordance and griminess with something far more ethereal and psychedelic, which while less of a bold decision, is one that ultimately benefits this game due to its vibe being softened a bit in general, still retaining the harsher guitar tones to maintain some degree of its slacker rock edge.”
“The largest part of the zone, hylemxylem, has basically the same track the entire time, that's two hours of the same music, and I found myself bouncing along with it the entire time.”
“The in-game music doesn't nearly do Chuck justice, either.”
“The overworld music was very, very annoying.”
- graphics682 mentions
- 47 % positive mentions
- 52 % neutral mentions
- 1 % negative mentions
The graphics of *Hylics 2* are widely praised for their stunning and unique art style, characterized by surreal claymation and vibrant visuals that create a psychedelic experience. Many reviewers highlight the game's exceptional soundtrack, which complements the visuals beautifully, enhancing the overall atmosphere. However, some players note that the intricate art design can occasionally hinder gameplay, particularly in platforming sections where depth perception becomes challenging.
“The visuals are so mesmerizing, the music is fantastic, and the gameplay is just real fun overall.”
“The art style and general direction is out of this world, literally.”
“The graphics are phenomenal as expected.”
“I really wanted to like this game because the overall art style of the game is very pretty and unique, but having finished the game, much of it ended up just feeling like a chore.”
“Clunky controls, baffling collision physics, and visuals that do a poor job distinguishing foreground from background.”
“The revamped combat system has its ups and downs from the normal RPGM standards, such as not having any clear turns or initiative order, but the simplistic design and mind-blowing visuals easily make up for it, even if you can't tell what some of those visuals are.”
- gameplay488 mentions
- 34 % positive mentions
- 63 % neutral mentions
- 4 % negative mentions
The gameplay of "Hylics 2" has been described as a significant improvement over its predecessor, featuring a mix of turn-based combat, platforming, and exploration that keeps the experience fresh and engaging. While many players appreciate the unique mechanics and charming visuals, some have noted frustrations with clunky platforming controls and a lack of polish in certain gameplay elements. Overall, the game offers a blend of enjoyable mechanics and artistic presentation, though it may not appeal to everyone due to its occasional jankiness and steep learning curve.
“Not only does this game feature lovely artwork and an outstanding soundtrack, the gameplay is incredible.”
“The gameplay is easy to learn, difficult to master--from the platforming to combat, Hylics 2 is an upgrade from the first game and better balanced than a lot of RPGs out there.”
“The gameplay is super intriguing but if anything, get it for the sick soundtrack and animation.”
“However, the platforming sections have some of the most frustrating gameplay I've ever experienced in my life.”
“Unfortunately, forced platformer mechanics (which are clunky at best) made this one unplayable for me.”
“The gameplay seems overdeveloped when compared to Hylics 1; there's a lot of things this game attempts and sadly not all of them work out.”
- story308 mentions
- 23 % positive mentions
- 71 % neutral mentions
- 6 % negative mentions
The story of *Hylics 2* is generally seen as an improvement over its predecessor, offering a more coherent and engaging narrative, though it remains relatively simple and straightforward. While some players appreciate the surreal and artistic presentation, others feel the plot lacks depth and imagination, often comparing it unfavorably to the chaotic charm of the first game. Overall, the game combines quirky characters and a whimsical world with a familiar RPG storyline, making it enjoyable for those who appreciate its unique aesthetic, even if the narrative itself is not the main draw.
“The story is simple but intriguing; you play as Wayne, who was the main protagonist from the first game, as he heads on a journey to stop the revival of Gibby, the antagonist of Hylics 1!”
“The art style and all is still great; the story makes more sense and is interesting, and even the boss fights aren't as bad because they are uniquely designed.”
“Hylics 2 is the continuation of the adventures from the first game, with the same team of characters and surreal storyline, only now it's shown in a more three-dimensional way.”
“The story is practically nonexistent.”
“The lack of imagination in the story department is honestly shocking to me considering these same guys made the first game which was nothing but imaginative.”
“Instead you removed everything that made the first game special and replaced it with a generic mediocre at best plot and tons of dogshit platforming.”
- humor84 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The humor in the game is described as bizarre, surreal, and often absurd, with players enjoying the quirky characters, funny dialogue, and whimsical scenarios, such as a croissant man blowing up the moon. While some reviews note a lack of character development in sequels, the overall comedic tone and visual style contribute to a charming and entertaining experience. The game effectively blends humor with gameplay elements, creating memorable moments that resonate with players.
“Came for the soundtrack, stayed for the amazing soundtrack, surreal visuals and funny characters and world.”
“The world-building is bizarre and fun, matching the aesthetic with a strange sense of humor.”
“The strengths and charms of the game more than make up for its shortcomings though, and more often than not Lindroth uses the game's limitations to its own advantage, often cleverly turning a clunky element into a bit of absurdist humor (one favorite example: the way Wayne climbs ladders by simply jumping straight upward with a totally stiff body is pure gold).”
- grinding74 mentions
- 3 % positive mentions
- 3 % neutral mentions
- 95 % negative mentions
Reviews indicate a mixed experience with grinding across the two games. The first game is praised for its strategic combat and minimal grinding, allowing players to progress without feeling overwhelmed, while the second game suffers from tedious battles and platforming, leading to a more grindy experience that detracts from enjoyment. Overall, while some players appreciate the lack of mandatory grinding, others find certain aspects of combat and exploration to be frustratingly repetitive.
“No grinding, but you never feel starved for more fighting.”
“Appealing even for people who aren't fans of JRPGs because the combat is challenging but not grindy or luck-based.”
“The second game changes all of that with horrible top-down platforming; confusing and nauseating exploration; slower, more tedious, and dragged out combat; and overall many aspects that make the game feel stretched out for the sake of making it somewhat longer despite that extra time not being so enjoyable.”
“The game is pretty, but every minute spent outside of the combat feels incredibly tedious.”
“This is just a subpar indie platformer with a bunch of gimmick minigames that give me a headache and some bog-standard JRPG combat that's so tedious that it makes the Shin Megami Tensei games feel like quick Game Jolt projects!”
- atmosphere62 mentions
- 58 % positive mentions
- 37 % neutral mentions
- 5 % negative mentions
The atmosphere of the game is widely praised for its surreal, psychedelic qualities, enhanced by a unique multimedia art style and an evocative soundtrack that deeply complements the experience. Reviewers highlight the bizarre visuals and immersive soundscapes, which create a dreamlike environment that captivates players, despite some criticisms regarding gameplay polish. Overall, the game's distinctive atmosphere is considered its standout feature, making it a memorable experience for those who appreciate the strange and artistic.
“An incredible game that will stay in your brain forever; it's got a highly unique vibe and atmosphere thanks to its unique multimedia art style and amazing soundtrack.”
“Fantastic atmosphere, from the incredible visuals and music to the mysterious world building.”
“Amazing surreal atmosphere that captivates with its music, bringing something quite unique to a lot of RPGs by incorporating stop-motion animation, 3D-scanned clay models, and pixel art.”
“But if you have any expectations of a substantial gaming experience, then be forewarned that there is very little to chew on here besides the visuals and freakish atmosphere.”
“I wouldn't be writing this worthless review if the game was just a horrid mess gameplay-wise, but everything having this eye-burning filter over it makes it painful to look at for too long, and the whole atmosphere and feel of the first game feels replaced by something that went through a 'sharpen', 'increased contrast' and 'brighten' filter-blender, making everything look nothing like the first game, aside from the texture itself, which at least still looks like clay and other DIY things.”
“The art style, atmosphere, and story all contribute to the feeling of being in a dream.”
- character development26 mentions
- 46 % positive mentions
- 42 % neutral mentions
- 12 % negative mentions
While the game features stunning visuals, unique character designs, and an incredible soundtrack, many reviewers express disappointment in the lack of character development for both the protagonists and the player. The characters, despite their appealing designs, are described as lacking personality, which detracts from the overall experience, especially in a sequel where expectations for growth were higher. Overall, the artistic elements are praised, but the absence of meaningful character progression is a significant drawback.
“Seeing and feeling the love and passion that the creators pour into every detail, from the character designs to every animation, set piece, and music choice.”
“The soundtrack is incredible, and the character design from the main party to the enemies, to even the NPCs are all unique and charming.”
“Everything from the hybrid clay/CGI visuals, the experimental soundtrack, and the appealing character designs are all a surreal treat that the developer deserves so much credit for.”
“Notwithstanding their fabulous visual designs, our four heroes are seriously devoid of personality, and while the first time around, their unassuming natures were a humorous counterpoint to their bizarre appearances, for a sequel I really was expecting more character development.”
“Zero character development (both for you and your party).”
“Again, don't get me wrong, that style of art/graphics is amazing and right up my alley along with the dialogue or the character designs, but I cannot recommend either due to the actual gameplay of the game itself needing somewhat of an update.”
- emotional14 mentions
- 86 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 14 % negative mentions
The emotional aspect of the game is mixed; while some players find it charming, strange, and unexpectedly moving, others feel that the story lacks the depth needed to create a strong emotional connection, making the challenging combat feel out of place. The contrast between the game's whimsical world and the steep difficulty of its battles leaves some players feeling disappointed and disconnected from the characters and narrative. Overall, the emotional journey varies significantly among players, with some experiencing heartfelt moments and others feeling let down.
“Hylics 2 is a charmingly strange, emotional and even funny game.”
“Wow, I was not expecting such an emotional journey.”
“Obviously I am still going to finish the game, but I was so looking forward to this game, and it turning out to be a downgrade in pretty much every way except music is heart-breaking.”
“Annoying platforming and annoying combat to progress a boring story in a kind of cool game world.”
- replayability12 mentions
- 25 % positive mentions
- 50 % neutral mentions
- 25 % negative mentions
Replayability in the reviewed games varies significantly; while "Hylics 1" is praised for its open exploration and character acquisition, "Hylics 2" is noted to be more playable but still lacks sufficient challenge and variety for repeated playthroughs. Some users express disappointment in the overall gameplay loop, suggesting that without further development, certain titles may not offer lasting engagement.
“Hylics 1 was actually quite replayable; aside from some mandatory roadblocks, you can basically visit any area any time you want and get any character in any order.”
“Hylics 2 is infinitely more playable than 1, and maybe 3 would finally be an enjoyable game to play.”
“Once you figure out what the statuses and enemies do, the combat becomes far too easy; it needs more variety and a much higher difficulty for replayability, perhaps a new game plus?”
“Neither have any replayability whatsoever.”
“Honestly if the game would have kept being developed for a bit longer it could have been a masterpiece, sadly it lacks any replay value when it comes to the gameplay loop.”
“Once you figure out what the statuses and enemies do, the combat becomes far too easy; it needs more variety and a much higher difficulty for replayability, maybe a new game plus?”
- optimization10 mentions
- 10 % positive mentions
- 60 % neutral mentions
- 30 % negative mentions
The game's optimization has received mixed feedback, with some users noting poor performance issues despite the use of a new engine designed to enhance capabilities. Additionally, controls are better suited for a controller rather than a keyboard, which may affect the overall gameplay experience.
“[h1]Performance & Improvements[/h1]”
“Combat: the only real big con of this game, other than kind of poor optimization.”
“The controls seem to be optimized for a controller, not so much for a keyboard.”
“Instead of this game being made in RPG Maker, it's a completely new engine that helps this game expand more in performance.”
- stability4 mentions
- 50 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 50 % negative mentions
The game is generally stable and performs well on the Steam Deck, but users have reported some glitches, particularly during running sequences.
“Great sequel to Hylics 1, runs great on Steam Deck.”
“There are some glitches when running.”
“There are some glitches when running.”