The music in this game is generally praised for its quality, with many calling the soundtrack a "banger" and an essential highlight, often described as phenomenal and addictive. However, compared to the first game, the soundtrack is seen as less memorable and more repetitive due to shorter looping tracks and frequent reuse in battles, which some players find diminishes the music's impact and uniqueness. While the combat and music remain strong selling points, the lack of emotional connection and story integration in the music reduces its overall resonance for many.

Everhood 2's gameplay is widely regarded as a significant improvement and evolution over the original, featuring deeper mechanics, smoother controls, and a more engaging combat system that rewards skill and strategy. Many praise the expanded rhythm-bullet-hell elements, additional weapons, combo-building, and RPG-style progression, which add variety and depth, although some find the added RPG mechanics unnecessary or underwhelming. However, frequent reuse of battles and some pacing issues lead to repetitiveness, and the gameplay's easier difficulty compared to the first game has divided opinions; overall, if you enjoyed Everhood 1 for its gameplay, you'll likely appreciate Everhood 2's refined and expanded combat experience.

The graphics in Everhood 2 are widely praised for their psychedelic, colorful, and trippy aesthetic that builds upon and improves the visual style of the first game with enhanced animations, detailed spritework, and expanded 3D elements. While many find the visuals vibrant and engaging, some players note inconsistency in art style and that the intense, flashy effects can be overwhelming or distracting during combat. Overall, the game's unique and dynamic graphics strongly complement its music and gameplay, making it a standout aspect despite mixed opinions on presentation consistency.

The humor in the game is widely described as whimsical, goofy, and often genuinely funny, featuring random, quirky jokes and charming characters that appeal to fans of offbeat and surreal comedy. However, opinions vary greatly—some find the humor creative and a highlight that enhances the experience, while others feel it falls flat, being repetitive, unfocused, or overshadowing the narrative, resulting in mixed reactions regarding its integration and overall effectiveness.

While Everhood 2 features improved combat, visuals, and an expanded soundtrack, many players feel its emotional impact and storytelling fall short compared to the original. The sequel's story is often seen as confusing, lacking clear character development, emotional depth, and a satisfying resolution, leaving some players feeling disconnected or disappointed. Nonetheless, its abstract themes, occasional touching moments, and gameplay still resonate with fans who appreciate the game's unique style.

Grinding in the game is widely viewed as tedious and repetitive, with frequent reuse of the same enemy encounters and drawn-out battles that add little meaningful progression. The RPG-style leveling system feels practically cosmetic, offering minimal impact on gameplay and making grinding largely unnecessary but unavoidable in certain sections. While some players appreciate the inclusion of replay mechanics and achievement-focused grinding, the overall experience often leads to frustration and monotony.

Character development in the game is widely criticized for being weak or nearly absent, with many reviewers noting a lack of meaningful growth or connection with the characters compared to the first installment. While the game features a wide variety of unique and visually striking character designs, the story and character arcs often feel underdeveloped or sidelined, resulting in minimal emotional engagement. Nonetheless, some characters receive minor development, and the artistic design and animations are generally praised.

Replayability in this game is mixed, with strong points including mod support, replaying battles, and arena achievements that appeal to completionists and those who enjoy mastering combat mechanics. However, some find the overall content limited due to a single ending and repetitive battles, resulting in a less satisfying experience compared to its predecessor. While the game offers more replay value than the first, it may eventually feel underwhelming once key content is exhausted.

The atmosphere in the game is highly praised for its unique, trippy, and unsettling vibe that effectively enhances the narrative and world-building. Its sound design and strange, zany settings create a captivating and immersive experience that surpasses or builds upon the original game. Players appreciate the blend of weirdness, unease, and creative world exploration, making the atmosphere a standout aspect overall.

The game suffers from numerous bugs and visual glitches that affect gameplay and immersion, including disappearing character elements and issues requiring resets. Despite a larger scope than its predecessor, the stability feels lacking and undermines the overall experience. While some visual effects in glitch fights are praised, the prevalence of technical problems is a significant drawback.

The game's optimization is generally praised for smooth performance and lack of framerate issues, though some feel it prioritizes streamer-friendly features over player-focused optimization.

The monetization relies heavily on repetitive ad encounters tied to the leveling system, resulting in a monotonous experience where players must repeatedly face the same ads with minimal variation.