Super Dungeon Maker
- February 14, 2022
- juwambo
- 18h median play time
Super Dungeon Maker is a solid, easy-to-use dungeon maker. Fans of the classic Zelda games will find plenty to do with this title, be it challenging player’s dungeons or challenging players with your dungeons.
Get on Steam"Super Dungeon Maker" is a game where you can build and design your own dungeons with various elements, traps, and enemies. Once completed, you can share your dungeon with others or explore dungeons created by other players. The game features a variety of customization options, allowing you to create unique and challenging dungeon experiences.
Nintendo Switch
PC
Windows
PlayStation
Xbox
Reviews
- The game offers a fun and creative dungeon-building experience reminiscent of classic Zelda games.
- The graphics and art style are charming, providing a nostalgic feel that appeals to fans of the genre.
- The developers are responsive to community feedback and actively working on updates and improvements.
- The game suffers from numerous bugs and lacks substantial content, making it feel unfinished.
- There is a limited variety of enemies, items, and mechanics, which can lead to repetitive gameplay.
- Development has reportedly stalled, leading to concerns about the game's future and potential abandonment.
- gameplay26 mentions
- 35 % positive mentions
- 54 % neutral mentions
- 12 % negative mentions
Gameplay reviews highlight a mix of enjoyment and frustration; while the dungeon editor and charming aesthetics are praised, many players feel the core mechanics are lacking and clunky. The game offers a decent variety of themes and puzzle mechanics, but users express a desire for more enemy types and polished controls. Overall, it appeals to fans of dungeon crawling and classic Zelda-style gameplay, but improvements are needed for a more satisfying experience.
“The game has a good few mechanics to make the dungeons of your dreams, and it also has a lot of charm. I would definitely recommend this to many people, especially as soon as the more annoying bugs are fixed.”
“After roughly 10 hours of learning the ropes and experimenting with the different mechanics of the editor, I can definitely say that it is worth picking up for any 2D Zelda fan; the dungeon editor is intuitive, satisfying to use, and yet retains the versatility needed to make something unique every time the game is booted up.”
“The gorgeous design, the cute and cheerful sprites, and the immensely fun gameplay.”
“Though the amount of mechanics, items, and tools you can use for your dungeons leaves a lot to be desired.”
“The gameplay was mediocre and felt off.”
“The clunky gameplay as your hero chicken; some controls just don't match what you'd expect or know from other games.”
- stability18 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
The game's stability has been widely criticized, with many users reporting significant bugs, crashes, and glitches that disrupt gameplay and level creation. While some players note that recent patches have improved the situation, the overall consensus is that the game remains a frustratingly unstable experience, particularly for a paid release. Despite these issues, a few users have found enjoyment in the game, indicating potential for future improvements.
“The game is a buggy mess; I made a dungeon, went back to edit it, saved it, and it fully corrupted the dungeon and editor. When editing dungeons, if you don't do things perfectly, it's liable to break. Honestly, it would be a super fun game, but it's so frustrating to do the one thing the game is built to do.”
“Really painful to say this, but it's just too buggy and rough for a paid release at present, even in early access.”
“Minimal updates; the game is buggy and broken.”
- graphics18 mentions
- 44 % positive mentions
- 39 % neutral mentions
- 17 % negative mentions
The graphics of Super Dungeon Maker are characterized by vibrant, retro 16-bit visuals that evoke a nostalgic feel, reminiscent of classic games like Zelda. Players appreciate the charming art style and intuitive design, although some note inconsistencies between the quality of dungeon graphics and the village hub. Overall, the game's aesthetic is well-received, contributing positively to the overall experience.
“Super Dungeon Maker relies on its bouncy, colorful, retro graphics, and beginner-friendly UI to carve out a place in the genre.”
“It is a top-down combat puzzle-oriented experience with pleasing 16-bit style graphics.”
“This game is amazing to say the least, and the developers have done a wonderful job of creating a Zelda-esque maker game with charming graphics and extremely fun maker mechanics.”
“The village hub, however, does not match the quality of the dungeon's graphics.”
“You only have a limited number of floors (3 if I'm not wrong) and tilesets; maybe in the future you can import graphics.”
“I'd like a variety of skins for building blocks in order to support immersion and the art style of my dungeons.”
- story17 mentions
- 18 % positive mentions
- 65 % neutral mentions
- 18 % negative mentions
The story aspect of the game is currently underdeveloped, with many reviewers expressing disappointment over the lack of unique enemies, key variety, and meaningful narrative elements. While there are hints of a storyline and potential for future updates, players feel that the game feels unfinished and lacks the depth needed for a compelling RPG experience. Comparisons to other titles, particularly "Quest Master," suggest that this game may not meet expectations for storytelling and world-building.
“This game is not finished as of late as the devs are continuing to work on adding a story mode as well as fixing any bugs as they work on the rest of this game.”
“NPCs and readable signs would allow the creator to add worldbuilding and story to their dungeons, which would be huge!”
“I heard there is a storyline that you can play through, but so far I am hooked to these community-made dungeons. Congrats to a fantastic game.”
“I can't confirm one way or the other, but Quest Master seems to be coming from a place of passion, while this game feels more like it was simply meant to cash in on the void of 'Zelda Maker'.”
“This game is not finished as of late, as the devs are continuing to work on adding a story mode as well as fixing any bugs as they work on the rest of this game.”
“Moral of the story, don't buy games in early access from small devs unless you know it is good.”
- music6 mentions
- 50 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 50 % negative mentions
The music in the game is generally considered underwhelming and repetitive, leading players to seek their own tunes for a more enjoyable experience. Reviewers express a desire for more diverse music options and thematic variety, as well as improvements to the audio dynamics during gameplay, particularly in boss encounters. Overall, the soundtrack fails to enhance the gaming experience significantly.
“The music and art used in the game is nothing crazy.”
“We need more theme and music options.”
“We need to fix the music going back to normal when only 1 of 2 bosses dies.”
“The music isn't going to blow you away or anything, and there's not much you can do as a level maker to ease the dreary dullness of the same sound effects. You're going to need to listen to your own music after a while.”
“Music and art used in the game is nothing crazy.”
“- need more theme and music options”
- emotional2 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
Players find the emotional aspect of the game to be heartwarming, drawing positive comparisons to the wholesome graphics reminiscent of Zelda. This combination fosters a nostalgic and uplifting experience that resonates deeply with users.
“The reception I got was heartwarming to say the least.”
“The graphics remind me of Zelda, but in a good wholesome way.”
- monetization1 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- -200 % neutral mentions
- 300 % negative mentions
Reviewers express frustration with the monetization strategy, particularly highlighting the introduction of a new enemy designed primarily for advertising purposes, which detracts from the overall experience.
“The monetization strategy feels overly aggressive, making it hard to enjoy the game without constantly being bombarded by ads.”
“I can't believe how many features are locked behind paywalls; it really ruins the experience for free-to-play users.”
“The constant push for in-game purchases detracts from the overall enjoyment and immersion of the game.”
- replayability1 mentions
- 300 % positive mentions
- -200 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The game is praised for its replayability, offering a charming and engaging dungeon-building experience that encourages players to return for multiple playthroughs.
“A charming and replayable dungeon builder that keeps you coming back for more.”
“The game's design encourages multiple playthroughs, making each experience unique.”
“Endless possibilities for dungeon creation ensure high replay value.”
- humor1 mentions
- 300 % positive mentions
- -200 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The humor in the game is characterized by its absurd and whimsical scenarios, such as a comical chicken battling a giant armored lizard, which adds a lighthearted and entertaining element to the gameplay.
“The game features hilarious moments, like a funny chicken fighting a giant lizard in armor.”
“I couldn't stop laughing at the absurdity of a chicken taking on a giant armored lizard!”
“The humor in this game is top-notch, especially the scene with the chicken and the lizard.”
- grinding1 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- -200 % neutral mentions
- 300 % negative mentions
Players find the grinding aspect tedious, particularly when minor mistakes in alignment lead to significant rework, resulting in either extensive level replacement or unsightly door placements.
“It's quite tedious to replace everything when you make a small mistake in the alignment of the doors that switch the floor, resulting in needing to replace a good chunk of the level or ending up with an ugly door placement.”
“Grinding feels like a never-ending chore that takes away from the enjoyment of the game.”
“The repetitive nature of grinding makes it feel more like a job than a fun gaming experience.”
- character development1 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 100 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
Reviewers appreciate the character development, highlighting the charming and appealing designs, particularly noting the endearing bird characters.
Critic Reviews
Super Dungeon Maker Review – Chicken-Sponsored Spelunking
Super Dungeon Maker is a solid, easy-to-use dungeon maker. Fans of the classic Zelda games will find plenty to do with this title, be it challenging player’s dungeons or challenging players with your dungeons.
80%Super Dungeon Maker review
Super Dungeon Maker has its fair share of issues, but if you want to make Zelda inspired dungeons with ease you'll have a lot of fun with it.
60%Super Dungeon Maker Review
Super Dungeon Maker has a lot of potential and perhaps with time it’ll become something great. For now, it feels like an egg that still needs significantly more time to incubate before it can hatch. Intuitive creator controls, an endless well of community-crafted content, and charming visuals are all big positives here, but the lack of any overarching progression, no touchscreen controls, and it feeling generally unfinished really hold this one back from being anything exceptional. If you have faith that the developers will eventually realize the full scope of their vision, then we’d certainly encourage you to crack this one open, but those who are more wary of early-access titles will want to wait and see. Super Dungeon Maker is just an average experience for now — here’s hoping that it eventually delivers on its promise.
50%
