Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk

About

"Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk" is a surrealistic puzzle game where players interact with bizarre and constantly changing environments. The game features a unique art style with hand-drawn graphics and a soothing, atmospheric soundtrack. Players must navigate through unconventional obstacles and absurd situations to progress through the game's dreamlike world.

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Single-Player Play through the game's story or campaign solo

Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk screenshot

98%

Audience ScoreBased on 11,958 reviews

story388 positive mentions

grinding34 negative mentions

story
1,180 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
65%
2%
The story of "milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk" serves as a direct continuation of its predecessor, delving deeper into the psychological struggles of the main character, often portrayed through surreal and haunting imagery. Players appreciate the game's ability to evoke empathy and introspection regarding mental health issues, though some find the narrative abstract and challenging to follow. Overall, the storytelling is praised for its emotional depth, artistic presentation, and the way it invites personal interpretation, despite its short length and occasional vagueness.
- “The art, soundtrack, core message, and storytelling are all fantastic.”
- “The story is simply unique and thought-provoking.”
- “This game continues the story of a very young girl with serious mental illnesses that are never directly stated with evidence, but instead expressed through horrific imagery and certain animated sequences that are shown as if filtered through her own mind.”
- “The only thing I will mention, as a warning, is this is more of a short story than a game; there is next to no gameplay and the runtime is very short.”
- “Additionally, the abstract nature of the story and sometimes out-of-place dialogue can leave players feeling confused and disconnected, especially if they haven’t played the first game.”
- “The story does not give you enough elements to be able to not feel incredibly confused during the endings, which is funny because (after doing multiple runs) I think that's exactly the point of them...”
graphics
932 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
46%
53%
1%
The graphics of "Milk Outside a Bag of Milk Outside a Bag of Milk" have received significant praise for their unique and improved art style compared to its predecessor, featuring vibrant colors, detailed character designs, and even animated sequences that enhance the overall experience. While some players appreciated the shift towards a more approachable aesthetic, others felt it detracted from the original's unsettling atmosphere. Overall, the visuals are described as hauntingly beautiful, effectively complementing the game's themes of mental illness and emotional turmoil.
- “This game feels like a lucid dream with its sound and visuals and made me feel anxious but overall a game that I would recommend people play.”
- “The visuals are masterfully done, the music is so eerie and off-putting, and I mean this fully positively.”
- “The graphics have improved since the last game: characters, objects and locations are now far more detailed and easier to identify but the game kept its stylized visuals, mostly in tones of red, that fit the psychological horror theme.”
- “Visually, the game lacks polish, with bland graphics and uninspired art direction that fail to immerse players in its world.”
- “The inconsistent background graphics, the lack of color variety and graphical definition, the abstraction of each nightmare, the randomness of each thought the girl has - f*****g everything.”
- “Note that I said 'change' and not 'improvement', since I feel that the graphics of the first game got the feeling of seeing the world through the protagonist's eyes better, while in this game you are more clearly an expectator, a third one who is just witnessing the situation from outside.”
music
736 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
51%
49%
1%
The music in "Milk Outside a Bag of Milk Outside a Bag of Milk" has received widespread acclaim for its haunting and atmospheric qualities, effectively enhancing the game's emotional depth and unsettling themes. Reviewers highlight the soundtrack's ability to evoke a range of feelings, from anxiety to comfort, with standout tracks like "I'll Be Here for a While" resonating deeply with players. Overall, the combination of eerie soundscapes and beautiful compositions contributes significantly to the game's immersive experience, making it a memorable aspect of the title.
- “The soundtrack is amazing, a perfect mix of eerie sounds and hopeful tunes.”
- “The music, the visuals, the atmosphere all tie together to create a one of a kind experience.”
- “The soundtrack is just… mwah, chef’s kiss.”
- “The soundtrack uses creepy and eerie atmospheric background music which doesn't really fit the tone and atmosphere of the game well as it feels as if it's trying to push a more disconcerting and spine-chilling feel than the rest of the game actually conveys.”
- “The music is not there to fill dead air.”
- “The soundtrack is once again, very disturbing.”
emotional
286 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The emotional impact of this game is profound, with many players reporting feelings of anxiety, discomfort, and deep empathy for the protagonist. It effectively explores heavy themes related to mental health, making players feel seen and understood, often leading to tears and personal reflection. The combination of heartfelt storytelling, beautiful visuals, and a haunting soundtrack creates a unique experience that resonates deeply with those who have faced similar struggles.
- “This game is an amazing emotional trip; I'd definitely recommend it!”
- “There has never been a game that has made me cry this much for a character. This game is genuinely amazing in the way it portrays mental illness; also, the music is 10/10.”
- “Milk outside a bag of milk is deeply emotional and thorough in its analysis of the troubled psyche of a young girl.”
atmosphere
238 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
42%
57%
1%
The atmosphere of the game is widely praised for its haunting, unsettling, and immersive qualities, effectively blending minimalist visuals with a powerful soundtrack to evoke psychological tension. Reviewers highlight the unique art style and sound design, which together create a surreal and emotionally charged experience that resonates deeply with players. Overall, the atmosphere is considered the game's standout feature, enhancing its storytelling and thematic depth.
- “The atmosphere in this game is so good and haunting!”
- “"A bag inside of milk" offers a unique and unsettling experience, blending minimalist visuals with a haunting soundtrack to create an atmosphere of psychological tension.”
- “The atmosphere created by the art and sound only further improved the experience :)”
- “Instead, the persistent uneasiness, the dismal oniric atmosphere and the suggestion that this experience represents the everyday life of the protagonist will leave you haunted.”
- “The cryptic dialogues and distorted graphics contribute to a trippy and disorienting atmosphere, while the oppressive soundtracks add to the game's overall sense of tension and unease.”
gameplay
172 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
14%
84%
2%
The gameplay of "Milk Outside a Bag of Milk Outside a Bag of Milk" is primarily a visual novel with limited point-and-click mechanics, resulting in a short experience that some players feel lacks depth and engagement. While the art style, music, and narrative are praised for their emotional impact, many reviewers note that the gameplay is minimal and often feels repetitive, with choices that do not significantly alter the outcome. Overall, it appeals to those who prioritize story and artistic expression over traditional gameplay mechanics.
- “The gameplay is good, the endings and twists are fabulous and the art style and animations are amazing!”
- “The gameplay and interaction is limited, since it’s a visual novel, but the choices you make will have an impact on the ending you get, and there are 5 different ones.”
- “It’s got such a beautiful art style and I love the gameplay!”
- “The only thing I will mention, as a warning, is this is more of a short story than a game; there is next to no gameplay and the runtime is very short.”
- “The gameplay is just clicking through dialogue and occasionally getting to make a decision that either means absolutely nothing or arbitrarily decides what ending you get.”
- “In terms of gameplay, it’s where it lacks the most since it’s just an interactive story/novel.”
humor
76 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
97%
4%
The humor in the game is described as a blend of dark, whimsical, and absurd elements, often reflecting on themes of mental illness and existential confusion. Players appreciate the engaging and relatable dialogue, with many finding the main character's antics both funny and endearing. Overall, the humor is seen as a key component that enhances the game's unique narrative experience, making it both compelling and entertaining.
- “The developers have injected just the right amount of humor into this lactose-laden nightmare.”
- “In conclusion, "milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk" is a hilarious romp through the dairy aisle for those of us who'd rather sip on soy than risk a lactose-induced disaster.”
- “The balcony scene, spoilers by the way, play the game you rat where Milk-chan jumps off and then interrupts her falling monologue by her dying with the text, "I'm cold, let's go inside" was simultaneously bone chilling and hilarious.”
- “A clever but unfunny pun.”
- “The humor falls flat and feels forced.”
- “I expected more laughs, but the jokes just didn't land.”
grinding
44 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
5%
18%
77%
The grinding aspect of the game is widely criticized for being tedious and repetitive, particularly due to the inability to skip previously seen dialogue and a cumbersome save system. Players often find themselves replaying the game multiple times to achieve different endings or complete achievements, which can feel like a chore rather than an engaging experience. While the initial playthrough may be enjoyable, subsequent attempts to explore all content are generally viewed as laborious and unfulfilling.
- “You'll need a second life for grinding.”
- “A bit grindy sometimes.”
- “Its gameplay mechanics are dull and unoriginal, revolving around mundane tasks that quickly become tedious.”
- “The game has 10 achievements which are very tedious to get due to the game having an atrocious save system with only one save slot, the inability to speed up or skip dialogue altogether, key decisions being gated behind cutscenes which can't be skipped, and the optional scenes and endings having very precise yet seemingly disjointed triggers.”
- “There are multiple unique endings that you can go back for, but it is very tedious to navigate through the game over and over again to achieve them.”
replayability
16 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
25%
56%
19%
The game offers significant replayability due to its multiple endings and variations in progression based on player choices, encouraging players to experience different outcomes. The engaging story and dialogue, along with randomly assigned background images for scenes, further enhance the replay value, making it worthwhile to play through multiple times. Overall, players find the game fulfilling and rich in replay opportunities compared to its predecessor.
- “The endings also improve on replayability, as despite the general novel part of the game staying the same, I found the game worth playing through five times to experience each ending.”
- “It expertly handles the themes within, and unlike its predecessor, it offers a ton of replayability.”
- “The story and dialogue do a fantastic job of keeping my interest all the way through, and there's good replayability to experience each ending.”
- “The endings also improve on replayability as despite the general novel part of the game staying the same, I found the game worth playing through five times to experience each ending.”
- “This game has replay value because of all the endings.”
- “Multiple interesting endings to go for, which helps with replay value.”
character development
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
50%
Character development in the game is highly praised for its strong writing, appealing character designs, and immersive art style, which collectively enhance the overall experience despite some minor criticisms. The visuals and ambiance contribute significantly to the depth and engagement of the characters.
- “The writing, character designs, art style, ambiance, etc. really made the game worthwhile despite the qualms I had with it.”
- “I love the visuals, the graphics, and the character design.”
monetization
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The monetization strategy of the game has been criticized for feeling like a cash grab, especially with a significant price increase compared to its predecessor. Players express frustration over intrusive advertisements that disrupt gameplay, contributing to a sense of monotony and dissatisfaction.
- “It really didn't compare to the game before it, and the price going way up does make it feel like a cash grab.”
- “Slipping into different worlds where infinite mornings devolve into mind-cracking monotony, sprawling heights with a vertigo-laced dare to jump, and having your mid-teenage-life crisis interrupted by a buy 2 get 1 free pizza advertisement.”
stability
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game suffers from significant stability issues, with players reporting frequent and unpredictable freezes, including a black screen at startup and a subsequent unresponsive white screen. These problems appear to be persistent and detract from the overall gameplay experience.
- “Now when I start the game up, it immediately freezes on a black screen with the in-game cursor frozen. After about 30 seconds, it suddenly shifts to a white screen with the in-game cursor movable but nothing to interact with.”
- “However, like the first game, it froze constantly and seemingly at random intervals. I would understand if it was a gameplay feature, but it is so frequent and unpredictable that I think the game just freezes constantly due to some sort of issue.”
optimization
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
50%
The optimization of milk2 is praised for its ability to effectively convey the girl's state of mind, showcasing a detailed and accurate performance that adds depth to the experience.
- “The performance effect of milk2 shows the girl's state of mind in a detailed, accurate, and quite intriguing way.”