Beyond a Steel Sky
- July 16, 2020
- Revolution Software Ltd
- 10h median play time
A worthy 3D follow-up of one of the best 2D adventure games around.
Beyond a Steel Sky - a cyberpunk thriller game by Charles Cecil and Dave Gibbons - puts you in the role of Robert Foster, searching for a kidnapped child in Union City, a utopian metropolis with a dark secret. This game features a dynamic world with responsive characters and puzzles that drive the story, offering a mix of humor, drama, and intrigue. Explore the political underbelly of this AI-controlled city and unravel its twisted mysteries.
Reviews
- The game features a captivating story that builds on the original, with engaging characters and witty dialogue.
- The graphics are beautifully rendered in a comic book style, creating an immersive atmosphere.
- The hacking mechanic adds a unique twist to puzzle-solving, making it enjoyable and interactive.
- The game suffers from numerous bugs and glitches, including camera issues and NPC pathfinding problems that can disrupt gameplay.
- Some puzzles are overly simplistic and lack the challenge that fans of the original might expect.
- The ending feels rushed and does not deliver the emotional impact that the buildup suggests.
- story489 mentions
- 44 % positive mentions
- 52 % neutral mentions
- 3 % negative mentions
The story of "Beyond a Steel Sky" is generally well-received, praised for its engaging narrative, character development, and atmospheric setting that builds on the original game. While some players noted linearity and predictability in the plot, many appreciated the humor and social commentary woven throughout the storyline. Overall, it serves as a compelling continuation of the original, though familiarity with "Beneath a Steel Sky" enhances the experience.
“Players unravel a complex story through detailed environments and puzzles, all while exploring a richly developed futuristic city.”
“Beautiful graphics, immersive atmosphere, sense of humor of the characters, and especially little Joey's jokes :) A rich and quite exciting story that makes you empathize with the characters and feel emotion.”
“The story is gripping, the graphics are great, the interactions are fun, (especially the hacking) you get attached to certain characters for sure!”
“The story is pretty linear, with no meaningful choices and consequences.”
“The story tries to save it all in the end but it's not strong enough to carry this mess to the finish; it gets an 'okay' but that's it.”
“The story is functional but it wasn't great.”
- graphics211 mentions
- 57 % positive mentions
- 42 % neutral mentions
- 1 % negative mentions
The graphics of the game have received a mixed but generally positive reception, with many praising the vibrant comic book art style and immersive environments that enhance the storytelling. While some users noted minor graphical glitches and clunky animations, the overall aesthetic is considered appealing and well-suited to the game's themes. The transition from 2D to 3D has been appreciated, with many highlighting the beautiful visuals and attention to detail that evoke nostalgia for classic adventure games.
“The graphics are beautiful; it was neat to see Union City rendered in 3D.”
“Gorgeous graphics and an amazing cityscape provide a backdrop to the story - with a good looking lead character and an entertaining and amusing sidekick Joey, including a good level of humor.”
“The comic art style is great, and the story is too.”
“Graphics were simplistic, character movement was lacking and overall slow.”
“The graphics are too bright and happy-go-lucky, the world is empty...”
“Graphics in this game are kinda subpar, but I did not go into this game expecting S-tier graphics in the first place (saw the trailer, images, was not click-baited).”
- gameplay129 mentions
- 37 % positive mentions
- 59 % neutral mentions
- 4 % negative mentions
The gameplay of this title is a blend of traditional point-and-click mechanics with innovative features like a hacking tool, which adds a unique twist to puzzle-solving. While many players appreciate the improved graphics and intuitive design, some find the puzzles to be overly simplistic and the reliance on the hacking mechanic to be underwhelming. Overall, the experience is described as enjoyable but occasionally marred by bugs and a lack of depth in certain gameplay elements.
“Dystopian cyberpunk world, it combines a gripping narrative with point-and-click adventure mechanics.”
“The gameplay is a mixture of detective work and puzzle solving with a fun twist that allows you to hack machines to aid you on your mission.”
“Awesome visuals, solid puzzles, and the hacking mechanic is interesting without being overly complicated.”
“Has a gameplay crashing bug which hasn't been fixed since 2020.”
“But the second part of the game is obnoxious, it mostly consists of cutscenes, hardly any gameplay is present.”
“The gameplay had serious issues in how the information was released; you could talk about things that you still didn't know and solve puzzles that you didn't even know what they were for.”
- humor90 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The humor in the game is widely praised for its clever dialogue, quirky characters, and engaging interactions, often drawing comparisons to classic adventure games like "Sam and Max" and "Monkey Island." While many players appreciate the witty banter and humorous references, some feel that the humor can be inconsistent, with certain characters or jokes becoming repetitive or less effective as the game progresses. Overall, the game successfully blends humor with its narrative, providing both laughs and social commentary, though some fans of the original may miss its darker comedic tones.
“The dialogue is great and the dry wits are particularly funny, especially Tarquin and Chipworth.”
“The story is funny, the characters are quirky, and the puzzles are just challenging enough to keep you engaged without making you want to pull your hair out.”
“Foster and Joey are back in all their glory, tossing witty and funny remarks while trying to unravel a new mystery behind Union City.”
- music60 mentions
- 48 % positive mentions
- 47 % neutral mentions
- 5 % negative mentions
The music in the game has received widespread praise for its quality and integration, with many reviewers highlighting its cinematic feel and ability to enhance the overall experience. The soundtrack, often described as majestic and beautifully produced, adapts seamlessly to the game's scenes, adding depth to the storytelling. While some found the music occasionally mismatched with the narrative tone, the majority appreciated its contribution to the game's atmosphere and emotional impact.
“Engaging story and beautifully crafted world with visuals and soundtrack to support it.”
“The music is fantastic too.”
“The soundtrack is as grand as the city itself.”
“I didn't see the music discussed quite enough when the game was being reviewed.”
“Sometimes the music didn't feel quite right, but that may just be my preferences, and on the whole, I can't complain.”
“Wonderful game, I enjoyed almost every minute of it (the minutes I didn't enjoy involved a smug poet and loud music).”
- stability43 mentions
- 5 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 95 % negative mentions
The game's stability has been a mixed bag, with numerous players reporting various bugs and glitches, particularly related to NPC animations, character movement, and camera issues. While many acknowledge that the game has improved since its initial release, minor graphical problems and occasional freezes still persist, leading to a recommendation to save frequently. Overall, despite the stability issues, players find the game enjoyable and worth playing, especially for its engaging storyline and visuals.
“This review is based on the release code, and the experience hasn't been completely bug-free.”
“Even though the game looks and runs great, there does seem to be a general lack of polish, at least on the PC version.”
“There were a few annoyances, especially with the pathing of the NPCs, and their animations in conversations are sometimes quite buggy and often look awkward or just broken.”
“Everything looks pretty, but there were some bugs and weird glitches. I had to load older saves at least 3 times due to a weird issue with a character getting stuck in animation.”
“Unfortunately, at launch it suffers from more than a couple of bugs, including minor clashing of NPCs, odd wardrobe changes on the main character, glitches into solid objects, and one fatal crash to desktop.”
- atmosphere25 mentions
- 52 % positive mentions
- 36 % neutral mentions
- 12 % negative mentions
The atmosphere of the game is widely praised for its engaging storyline, beautiful graphics, and immersive world-building, which effectively evoke emotions and empathy for the characters. While some players noted a shift from the darker tones of the original game, many appreciated the modern art style and humor that still capture the essence of the narrative. Overall, the game successfully blends compelling storytelling with a rich, atmospheric experience, making it a standout in the genre.
“Beautiful graphics, immersive atmosphere, sense of humor of the characters, and especially little Joey's jokes :) a rich and quite exciting story that makes you empathize with the characters and feel emotion.”
“Draping the classic point-and-click in modern livery, this return to one of the most unique cyberpunk settings largely fails to deliver challenging puzzles, but makes up for it with wonderful characters, story, and atmosphere.”
“Man, this demo changed my world - a gripping story, amazing setting, brilliant pixel art, and an atmosphere unlike anything else I'd ever seen in a game!”
“It does not have any semblance of atmosphere.”
“I am also kind of disappointed that this game lacks the dreary atmosphere that the first game had, definitely give this game a go.”
“I must add that up until the second half of the game, I was kind of away from the Beneath a Steel Sky atmosphere; I felt different with all the glory and colorful views of Union City.”
- optimization11 mentions
- 27 % positive mentions
- 45 % neutral mentions
- 27 % negative mentions
Overall, the game's optimization is a mixed bag; while many players report a smooth and bug-free experience, others highlight performance issues such as slow character movement, animation glitches, and pathfinding errors that can disrupt immersion. Despite these concerns, the game's strong narrative and character performances are praised, suggesting that the core experience remains enjoyable for most players. Some reviews indicate that performance complaints may be exaggerated, particularly on lower-end systems.
“Minor immersion break = sometimes the background characters just get in between your conversation with the unique NPCs, but other than this, the game runs smoothly and bug-free.”
“Aside from that, the art style, music, and voice performances are all well done, and I do hope these small issues get fixed; then it will be close to perfect.”
“I feel as though in many cases these opinions seemed exaggerative and harsh as to how much the bugs really detract from the experience (it seems a bit nit-picky to me to be honest), and I'm just downright puzzled by the mention of performance problems.”
“The character moves and runs slowly.”
“The performance is sub-par; there are many unfortunate animation and pathfinding errors that will break the illusion.”
“Edit: I just thought I'd mention that I notice other reviews talking about performance issues and bugs.”
- grinding10 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
Players generally find the grinding aspects of the game, particularly the hacking minigame and puzzles, to be tedious and repetitive, often leading to frustration and reliance on hints or walkthroughs. While some elements, like the art style, provide a visual reprieve, the overall experience can feel monotonous, detracting from the enjoyment of the adventure.
“The hacking minigame was sometimes quite tedious, and I found myself using the in-game hint system because it became such a pain to try to experiment with different solutions.”
“The hacking mechanic that is introduced is fun at first but gets tedious quickly as you just have to figure out where to stand to link up the right objects.”
“Some of the puzzles are a little repetitive, and it would've been nice to see a mix of things in there; constantly hacking to get into places was a bit tedious.”
- emotional9 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The emotional aspect of the game is highlighted by its heartfelt character interactions and the effective balance between dark and comedic elements, which resonate deeply during serious moments. While some players feel that certain characters lack emotional depth and consistency, the witty dialogue between the main characters is often praised for its touching and humorous qualities. Overall, the game evokes a range of emotions, though some players found it fell short of their expectations compared to earlier titles in the series.
“It may be because I know the original game, but their interaction is more heartfelt and more intimate than others.”
“This time, they found the perfect balance between the dark and comic elements, so I was constantly amused, but when the serious moments came, they hit you with the correct emotional weight.”
“And speaking of dialogue, the back and forth between Foster and Joey is the real heart of the game—funny, witty, and very touching at times.”
- replayability7 mentions
- 29 % positive mentions
- 29 % neutral mentions
- 43 % negative mentions
Overall, "Beyond a Steel Sky" is perceived to have limited replayability due to its linear structure and lack of player agency, with many reviewers expressing disappointment over missed opportunities for alternate solutions and endings. While some appreciate the added developer commentary, the consensus is that the game does not encourage multiple playthroughs.
“There's some replayability, without being bombarded with an infinite amount of endings, and the added developer commentary is a nice touch so long as you took in the story and conversations the first time around.”
“I wish it offered some replay value too.”
“Zero player agency, zero replayability.”
“Overall, a game I am glad I played, but with zero replayability as it is entirely linear.”
“It just seems like there was a whole lot of potential for alternate solutions and replayability that were missed here.”
- character development4 mentions
- 75 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 25 % negative mentions
Character development in the game is noted for its excellent writing and engaging dialogue, contributing to a rich narrative experience. While the gameplay focuses primarily on puzzle-solving with minimal combat, the character design and artistic presentation enhance the overall immersion. However, some reviews indicate a lack of depth in character progression, suggesting that the emphasis is more on storytelling and visual appeal than on evolving characters.
“Brilliant adventure, excellent writing, and character development.”
“In general, the character design and comic book style cell shading are pretty fantastic.”
“The character design, art style, and dialogue are quite good, contributing to a well-rounded experience.”
“Just like its predecessor, this is similar to a 'point and click' type adventure game where gameplay is relatively simple, composed almost exclusively of puzzle-solving, with no combat, no character development, and a simple inventory.”
- monetization1 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
The monetization aspect has seen improvements since the initial release, with fewer graphical issues reported, although some minor bugs related to advertisements during gameplay still persist.
Critic Reviews
Beyond a Steel Sky review
Filled with what made the original game great, this second trip to Union City has been worth the 26-year hiatus.
81%Beyond A Steel Sky review
After 26 years, Beyond A Steel Sky is a strange yet welcome sequel. Not quite fresh enough to stand alone nor nostalgic enough to stir the memory, it nevertheless manages to thoroughly entertain if not thrill.
70%Beyond a Steel Sky review – A Joey to play, with some caveats
Beyond a Steel Sky has some technical issues but its excellent writing and interesting storytelling make it well worth experiencing.
70%