Games like Spell Toaster
Looking for games like Spell Toaster? Here are top puzzle recommendations with a comedy focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Circular Fallacy, Understand or SHUT IN.
1 View GameCircular Fallacy is a card-based narrative puzzle game with 3D scene perspective switching. The story is set in an unknown space where you wake up, having forgotten why you came here, and begin your journey to find yourself... But as the story unfolds, the interwoven layers of time and space make the world increasingly elusive. Can you uncover your original self? Perspective switching bring…
View Game2 View Game91%Game Brain Scoregameplay, graphicsgrinding, story91% User Score 578 reviews"Understand" is a single-player adventure puzzle game with unique level-specific rules and experimental mechanics. Players must figure out the meaning of each rule through trial and error and draw lines to satisfy all rules in over 100 language-independent levels. The game boasts "think outside the box" puzzles, terrible artwork, and an unexplored puzzle genre, encouraging players to join their Discord community at .
View Game3 View Game92%Game Brain Scorehumor, storygraphics, gameplay92% User Score 122 reviews"SHUT UP" Summary: In SHUT IN, a free content update of the dark comedy/psychological horror game, players are trapped in their own dirty and threatening house, tasked with going outside for fresh air. Facing strange puzzles, uncomfortable obstacles, and a judgmental narrator, players must overcome their own personal demons and isolation. The game explores depression, anxiety, and the difficulty of seeking help.
View Game4 View Game97%Game Brain Scorestory, gameplaygraphics, grinding97% User Score 303 reviewsCreepy Redneck Dinosaur Mansion 3 is a wild match-3 survival horror comedy RPG metroidvania that blends puzzle combat, lockpicking, and quirky interactions into a fast-paced adventure. Players explore a bizarre world filled with lore, debating robots, and daring gem heists. It’s an unconventional, genre-bending experience that’s as rad as it is bizarre.
View Game5 View Game94%Game Brain Scorehumor, storygrinding, replayability97% User Score 9,663 reviewsCritic Score 88%5 reviews"There Is No Game: Wrong Dimension" is a Point&Click comedy adventure that takes you through unexpected video game universes in 3D graphics that are flat and pixelated. Solve riddles with the help of a hint system, and prepare for motion sickness-free bug-filled journey, shorter than an MMORPG.
View Game6 View Game97%Game Brain Scorehumor, storyreplayability97% User Score 116 reviewsNot Another Weekend is a humorous point-and-click adventure game with beautiful 80's-inspired pixel art graphics. Players assume the role of Mike Melkout, an eccentric bellboy on a mission to clear out a high-class hotel over a wild weekend. The game features hilarious characters, funny situations and dialogues, satisfying puzzles, and an original soundtrack. Enjoy the unique story and 80's pop culture references as you play through this quirky gaming experience.
View Game7 View Game93%Game Brain Scorestory, musicstability, optimization95% User Score 6,072 reviewsCritic Score 88%4 reviews"Wandersong" is a single-player Fantasy Real Time Strategy game with an interesting plot, good mechanics, and sensational graphics. As a singing bard, players interact with the world using music, solving puzzles and meeting 150+ characters. With exceptional music, wholesome story, and accessible design, it provides 10-12 hours of whimsical adventure, despite being quite buggy and requiring some grinding.
View Game8 View Game69%Game Brain Scorestory, graphicsgameplay69% User Score 84 reviews"Odysseus Kosmos and his Robot Quest" is a pixelated adventure game set on the spaceship San-Francisco. Thirty years after the crew's disappearance, only engineer Odysseus and robot Barton remain. When equipment malfunctions and rats threaten, Odysseus must solve puzzles to rescue his crew, uncover mysteries, and get back home. The game features intelligent puzzles, a humorous storyline, and references to classic sci-fi titles.
View Game9 View Game83%Game Brain Scoregameplay, storygrinding, monetization88% User Score 240 reviewsCritic Score 78%13 reviewsSigns of the Sojourner is a narrative card game where your deck represents your character and influences relationships. Travel to diverse locations to acquire goods for your mother's store, engaging in optimistic stories and card game conversations. Your choices impact your connections, creating a personalized journey in a world affected by climate change.
View Game10 View GameWhat is "Maybe a Witch Hunter"? "Maybe a Witch Hunter" is a game made in Python by me, GlassFrog, for the 2023 Itch.io My First Game Jam: Winter 2023, which encouraged emerging game makers to create something new and simple in two weeks. Its theme was revealed to be growth. therefore I thought to make a "Princess Maker"-inspired raising simulator as my first game. Considering I'm very bad at draw…
View Game










