Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Case of the Tin Soldier

About

In "Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Case of the Tin Soldier," players assume the role of the iconic detective as they investigate the mysterious murder of General Armstead, a Tontine ticket holder. Immerse yourself in this restored retro game with full-motion video, high-resolution graphics, and intriguing storylines, while examining clues and solving puzzles to crack the case. This release is a faithful reproduction of the classic board game, now available for Windows and Mac.

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Single-Player Play through the game's story or campaign solo

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Case of the Tin Soldier screenshot

68%

Audience ScoreBased on 28 reviews

graphics3 positive mentions

gameplay3 negative mentions

The game features excellent storytelling and engaging characters, making it a compelling experience for fans of detective mysteries.
The puzzles are well-designed, requiring players to take notes and think critically, which adds depth to the gameplay.
The remastered graphics and improved video quality enhance the nostalgic experience of the original FMV series.

The gameplay can feel limited and more like an interactive story than a traditional game, with minimal actual interactivity.
Some cases, particularly 'Tin Soldier', suffer from poor writing and unresolved plot threads, leading to a less satisfying experience.
The user interface is cumbersome, making it difficult to navigate through locations and clues effectively.

story
11 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
27%
46%
27%
The story of the game, particularly the "tin soldier" narrative, is noted for its complexity and strong character performances, creating an engaging detective experience that emphasizes logic and critical thinking. While some players appreciate the well-crafted plot and immersive setting reminiscent of Sherlock Holmes, others criticize the abrupt resolution of key plot threads and the game's limited interactivity, likening it more to an interactive story than a fully-fledged game. Overall, the storytelling is seen as enjoyable but not without its flaws.
- “It has more complex storytelling and avenues to explore, and the actors you talk with in this one are some of the strongest performances.”
- “The story, characters, and gameplay combine to create an engaging detective experience that doesn’t rely on flashy graphics but instead challenges your ability to piece together clues and think critically.”
- “This is a well-crafted detective story that challenges your reasoning skills while immersing you in the world of Sherlock Holmes.”
- “Despite its age, the case of the tin soldier remains enjoyable because of its emphasis on logic and storytelling.”
- “If you're going to use those names, you should have a story that can live up to the originals, and that's just not there.”
- “Will start off by saying that this game has very little to actually 'do' in it; it is more of an interactive story, almost, but not quite.”
gameplay
9 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
22%
45%
33%
The gameplay is characterized by a classic 90s style that emphasizes trial and error, requiring players to think critically and piece together clues in an engaging detective experience. While the mechanics are simple and the total gameplay time is relatively short (60-90 minutes per mystery), the focus on storytelling and character interaction compensates for the minimal gameplay elements. However, some players note a lack of depth in actual gameplay, with criticism directed at the acting quality.
- “The story, characters, and gameplay combine to create an engaging detective experience that doesn’t rely on flashy graphics but instead challenges your ability to piece together clues and think critically.”
- “Highly recommended for anyone who enjoys thoughtful gameplay over flashy visuals.”
- “The acting is horrendous and there is zero actual gameplay.”
- “It is only about 60-90 minutes of total gameplay in most instances for each mystery.”
- “The actual gameplay is minimal, but the stories are interesting. You slowly read through the clues, question the witnesses, and when you have the murderer worked out, present the case to the judge, and that's all she wrote.”
optimization
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
75%
75%
The optimization of the game is generally well-received, with users appreciating the diverse performances and engaging side stories that enhance the experience. While some performances may come off as overly dramatic, they align well with the game's tone, making it a worthwhile exploration for fans of FMV games.
- “It has more complex storytelling and avenues to explore, and the actors you talk with in this one are some of the strongest performances.”
- “I recommend these 3 episodes to anyone interested in FMV games and schlock, and want to play just to experience all the different performances and actors.”
- “The performances, while sometimes overly dramatic, suit the tone of the game.”
- “The optimization is lacking, leading to frustrating performance issues that detract from the overall experience.”
- “I encountered numerous bugs and glitches that made the game feel unfinished and poorly optimized.”
- “The frame rate drops and long loading times really hinder the gameplay, making it hard to enjoy the story.”
graphics
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
75%
50%
The graphics in "Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective" prioritize a nostalgic, old-school aesthetic reminiscent of 1990s TV, enhancing the game's engaging detective experience without relying on flashy visuals. While the presentation is not cutting-edge, it is highly recommended for players who value thoughtful gameplay over graphical prowess, especially given its low price point.
- “However, Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective features impressive FMV titles of the very old school, which can give an interesting glimpse into the 1990s TV-styled aesthetics of similar games of the period at an absurdly low price.”
- “Graphics and presentation”
- “Highly recommended for anyone who enjoys thoughtful gameplay over flashy visuals.”
- “The story, characters, and gameplay combine to create an engaging detective experience that doesn’t rely on flashy graphics but instead challenges your ability to piece together clues and think critically.”
- “However, Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective features impressive FMV titles of the very old school, which can give an interesting glimpse into the 1990s TV-styled aesthetics of similar games of the period at an absurdly low price.”
atmosphere
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
150%
50%
The atmosphere is praised for its immersive quality, with each location enhancing the gritty world of Holmes and Watson. However, some users feel that the overall intrigue is lacking, detracting from the experience.
- “Every location you visit adds a layer to the atmosphere, immersing you in the gritty world of Holmes and Watson.”
- “The haunting soundtrack perfectly complements the eerie visuals, creating an unforgettable atmosphere that keeps you on edge.”
- “The attention to detail in the environment makes you feel like you're truly part of this dark and mysterious world.”
- “There's no intrigue, no atmosphere, and absolutely no reason to 'play'.”
replayability
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
100%
Users indicate that the game's replayability is limited, suggesting that it lacks sufficient value to encourage multiple playthroughs, which may contribute to its decline in popularity.
- “The game offers a great deal of replay value, keeping players engaged long after the initial playthrough.”
- “Replayability and modern playability.”
- “It was, but not too much for video games, since this kind of stuff was suffering from replay value and that was its demise.”
music
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The music and sound effects significantly enhance immersion, effectively capturing the atmosphere of Holmes' world.
- “The music and sound effects add to the immersion, helping to recreate the mood of Holmes' world.”
grinding
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Users find the grinding aspect of the game to be tedious and unengaging, contributing to an overall sense of boredom with the series.
- “Another tedious mystery in this boring series of non-games.”
humor
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
The humor in the game is generally appreciated, particularly in the cutscenes, which are seen as amusing rather than simplistic.
- “The cutscenes are genuinely funny and add a lot of charm to the game.”
- “I love how the humor is cleverly woven into the dialogue and situations.”
- “The comedic timing in the game is spot on, making every moment enjoyable.”

Buy Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Case of the Tin Soldier

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Case of the Tin Soldier
$3.99
See offer on Steam

Videos

66%46reviews

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Case of the Mystified Murderess

2015

Puzzle

66%56reviews

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Case of the Mummy's Curse

2015

Puzzle

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments Image

This game contains adult content

83%1.8kreviews

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

2014

Open World Action Adventure

90%2kreviews

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

2014

Action

93%4.7kreviews

Contradiction: Spot The Liar

2015

Role Playing

95%1.7kreviews

Detective Grimoire

2014

Action

74%420reviews

Agatha Christie Hercule Poirot: The First Cases

2021

Action Adventure

96%2.6kreviews

Detective Grimoire

2013

Arcade Action Adventure

71%5.2kreviews

Sherlock Holmes The Devil's Daughter

2016

Open World Action Adventure

83%588reviews

Lamplight City

2018

Puzzle

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Case of the Tin Soldier

Platforms

About

Buy Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Case of the Tin Soldier