Ms. Holmes: Five Orange Pips Collector's Edition

About

In "Ms Holmes: The Case of the Dancing Men Collector's Edition," players help Sharlotte Holmes and Oscar Watson solve the mystery of a threatening calling card and cryptic pips, while exploring hidden-object puzzles and earning unique achievements. This collector's edition also offers an additional bonus game and exclusive extras for a more immersive experience.

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Single-Player Play through the game's story or campaign solo

Ms. Holmes: Five Orange Pips Collector's Edition screenshot

94%

Audience ScoreBased on 16 reviews

music1 positive mentions

gameplay3 negative mentions

The game features high-quality visuals and a solid art direction, creating a cozy yet mysterious atmosphere.
The integration of hidden object gameplay with detective story elements is well-executed, providing engaging puzzles and mini-games that enhance the narrative.
The character of Ms. Holmes and the intriguing plot offer a fresh take on the classic Sherlock Holmes story, making it enjoyable and relaxing for players.

The game suffers from frequent cutscenes that interrupt gameplay, which can be frustrating for players looking for a more seamless experience.
There are reports of game-breaking bugs and crashes that can hinder progress, leading to a less enjoyable experience.
Some puzzles are overly simplistic or repetitive, relying heavily on finding correctly shaped items, which may not challenge all players.

story
11 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
27%
45%
27%
The game effectively combines a hidden object format with a detective narrative, allowing players to engage deeply with the story through attention to detail and context. While the plot features intriguing twists and a variety of mini-games that enhance the experience, some players noted a game-breaking bug that hindered progression. Overall, the story and characters are well-developed, offering a fresh take on classic detective tales, despite some pacing issues and an abundance of cut scenes.
- “The idea of mixing a hidden object game with a detective story is one that makes sense; most of Sherlock Holmes and other private investigator stories focus on attention to detail, noticing things that others would overlook and putting them into context.”
- “An elegant solution to integrate the story with the gameplay without taking the player out of it.”
- “Story and characters are better than most, and there are several unique puzzles.”
- “While I think the final plot twist might be a little 'out there' for people looking for an experience closer to the source material, it is still an enjoyable title that could be worth your time.”
- “I had played for enough hours that starting over seemed annoying but hadn't played far enough to be fully invested in the outcome of the story.”
- “- Bonus chapter is entertaining, although slightly short and not much plot (being generous).”
graphics
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
100%
The graphics are generally well-received, featuring an appealing artistic style that enhances the storytelling without complicating gameplay. However, some players noted issues with excessive cut scenes and encountered game-breaking bugs that detracted from the experience. Overall, the visuals are considered enjoyable and complement the classic narrative.
- “Enjoyable for the first few hours, nice enough graphics and an interesting take on a classic story.”
- “The graphic quality is the right mix of artistic that looks good, but doesn't make the hogs unnecessarily difficult.”
- “Good graphics, nice story.”
- “The graphics feel outdated and lack the polish expected from modern games.”
- “Character models are poorly designed and lack detail, making them look lifeless.”
- “The environments are bland and repetitive, which detracts from the overall immersion.”
gameplay
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
150%
The gameplay seamlessly integrates storytelling with engaging mini-games and puzzles, including unique mechanics reminiscent of Candy Crush and logic games akin to those in Sherlock Holmes titles. This variety keeps players invested and provides helpful context for the narrative, ensuring a cohesive and immersive experience.
- “An elegant solution to integrate the story with the gameplay without taking the player out of it.”
- “The mini-games and puzzles make sense in the context, and there are even fighting scenes with Candy Crush mechanics to shake things up. Other varied types keep the player engaged; at some points, there is a mini-logic game similar to Frogwares' Sherlock Holmes or Blazing Griffin's Hercule Poirot titles that also works as a small summary or catch-up, helping if the player isn’t too sure where the story is going.”
- “The mini-games and puzzles also make sense in the context, but there are even fighting scenes with Candy Crush mechanics that feel out of place. While there are varied types that keep the player engaged at some points, the overall execution can be frustrating.”
- “The gameplay often feels disjointed, with mechanics that don't seamlessly integrate into the overall experience. It can be jarring to switch between different styles, and it detracts from the immersion.”
- “While the story is intriguing, the gameplay mechanics can be repetitive and lack depth, making it hard to stay engaged for long periods.”
atmosphere
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
150%
The game's atmosphere is characterized by stunning visuals and a cozy yet mysterious ambiance, enhanced by a well-crafted sound design that features unobtrusive background music and enjoyable sound effects. While some moments may feel visually busy, the overall aesthetic remains pleasing and immersive.
- “Some titles can get busy at times or straining to look at, but everything in this game looks amazing and pleasing to the eye. The cool colors contribute to a cozy yet somewhat mysterious atmosphere.”
- “The sound design is very efficient, with background music that enhances the atmosphere without being too intrusive, and the sound effects are also enjoyable.”
- “The atmosphere feels flat and uninspired, lacking the depth and immersion that I expected from this game.”
- “Despite the beautiful visuals, the overall atmosphere is dull and fails to engage the player.”
- “The game tries to create a tense atmosphere, but it often falls short, leaving moments that should be suspenseful feeling bland and unexciting.”
music
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The music in the game is praised for its effective sound design, featuring background tracks that enhance the atmosphere while remaining unobtrusive, complemented by enjoyable sound effects.
- “The sound design is very efficient, with background music that enhances the atmosphere without being too intrusive, and the sound effects are also enjoyable.”