If you didn’t think you needed another Gears of War, you were wrong. Gears 5 is a barnstorming success, and a triumphant return for the series. This is the essential first party game the Xbox One desperately needed.
From one of gaming’s most acclaimed sagas, Gears 5’s celebrated campaign, refreshed multiplayer and Hivebusters expansion are optimized for the Xbox Series X|S.
Gears 5 Game of the Year Edition includes:
• Gears 5 base game
• Halo: Reach Character Pack
• 30 days of Boost
• Gears 5: Hivebusters expansion
Campaign: With all-out war descending, Kait Diaz breaks away to uncover her connection to the…
The story of "Gears 5" has received mixed reviews, with many players noting that while it attempts to expand the narrative and character development, it often falls short compared to the original trilogy. Critics highlight the game's shift to a semi-open world structure, which some feel detracts from the pacing and emotional depth of the story, leading to a more predictable and less engaging experience. Despite these criticisms, many players appreciate the character-driven elements and the continuation of Kait's journey, finding the overall narrative enjoyable, albeit with some flaws in execution.
“The story is engaging and interesting.”
“The campaign has tons of mentions and story elements from the previous games as well as lore addons on the previously unknown locations that you will enjoy if you're a big campaign player as I am.”
“The story is much better than 4 and also has some epic set-pieces and overall the scale of the events is larger by comparison to G4.”
“Bad story, bad characters, bad dialogue, and bad lore.”
“This game is literally an insult to the original trilogy; whoever decided on open world sections for this game is deluded, and whoever said this is the story we are going with should be saying one and done now.”
“The story is trash, the cast is unlikeable, and the fact that this game requires internet to function is actually criminal.”
gameplay
1,339 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
38%
55%
7%
The gameplay in Gears 5 is characterized by its classic cover-based shooting mechanics, which many players find enjoyable and familiar, though some criticize it for being repetitive and lacking innovation compared to earlier titles in the series. While the introduction of new elements like the robot companion Jack and semi-open world segments adds some variety, opinions are mixed on their effectiveness, with some players feeling they detract from the core experience. Overall, the game offers solid mechanics and engaging combat, but it struggles with pacing and can feel bogged down by bugs and design choices that some players find frustrating.
“The gameplay is awesome.”
“Each mission feels distinct and full of surprises thanks to the game's unique blend of cover-based gameplay, breathtaking graphics, and an engrossing plot.”
“Gears 5 is an exceptional co-op experience, blending dynamic team-based mechanics with the signature intense combat of the Gears of War series.”
“The gameplay is a mix of intense third-person shooting and cover-based mechanics, but it feels somewhat boring and repetitive.”
“The gameplay itself is frustrating, with a high level of randomness that can make matches feel unfair and unbalanced.”
“The core gameplay is the same as it ever was, shooting, timing reloads, and hitting a to hide in cover; and I couldn't tell you if the graphics are any better than they ever were.”
graphics
999 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
64%
33%
3%
The graphics of Gears 5 have received widespread acclaim for their stunning visuals and attention to detail, showcasing the capabilities of the Unreal Engine. Players have noted the game's ability to run smoothly on various hardware configurations, including lower-end PCs, while still delivering impressive graphical fidelity. However, some users have reported issues with graphical bugs and performance inconsistencies, particularly on certain graphics cards, which detracts from the overall experience.
“The graphics are stunning, I was playing on a several years old laptop and I was stunned by how well it looked.”
“The graphics are absolutely beautiful in the campaign, playing co-op campaign with your friends searching for all the collectibles is fantastic and makes the story and gameplay seem new and exciting.”
“Gears 5 offers the best visuals and graphics options in any Gears game to date.”
“The game's graphics and sound design are also underwhelming.”
“It feels like an early last-gen game with a fresh coat of paint and that semi-open world.. I still don't understand what was the reason for that.. it feels pointless.”
“The graphics are exactly as advertised.”
optimization
357 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
57%
27%
16%
Overall, "Gears 5" is praised for its strong optimization, delivering excellent performance across a range of hardware configurations, including lower-end PCs. While many players report smooth gameplay and stunning visuals, some have experienced occasional stuttering and performance issues, particularly during cutscenes or in multiplayer modes. Despite these hiccups, the game is generally regarded as one of the best-optimized titles in its genre, with a solid balance of graphics and performance.
“The game runs smoothly and is very well optimized.”
“This game is highly optimized for PC, and has the best multiplayer I have played in a Gears game.”
“The optimization on PC is so good (60 fps on 750 2GB).”
“The game is littered with performance issues.”
“This game has major stuttering issues and for a triple-A developer, that is simply unacceptable, especially for a fast-paced multiplayer title.”
“Most importantly, the game is an absolute pig, sporting some of the worst optimization I've seen in any PC title.”
stability
265 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
13%
1%
86%
The game's stability has been widely criticized, with numerous players reporting a plethora of bugs, glitches, and crashes that significantly hinder gameplay. While some users have noted that the game runs well on certain platforms, particularly PCs, many others have experienced frustrating issues, especially in the campaign and multiplayer modes. Overall, the consensus is that the game is plagued by stability problems, making it a challenging experience for many players.
“Amazing game, runs great and still fun in 2025.”
“Game runs great on PC, and ranked is fun and competitive.”
“Graphics are stunningly good (Unreal Engine after all), gameplay is smooth and no glitches (stable), the storyline is unique and fast-paced without any difficult puzzles to break the flow of fun in the game.”
“The game is plagued by bugs and glitches (feels like playing a beta).”
“I am playing with a $3400 PC, 32 GB of RAM, i12 CPU, RTX 3080 with 10 GB of RAM, and all updated drivers, and this buggy game has hard crashed my PC at least 15 times.”
“The campaign is buggy and crashes often.”
monetization
264 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
4%
72%
24%
The monetization in Gears 5 has drawn significant criticism for its heavy reliance on microtransactions, particularly for cosmetic items, which many players feel are overpriced and intrusive in a full-priced game. While some reviewers appreciate that these microtransactions are not pay-to-win, the overall sentiment is that the aggressive monetization strategy detracts from the gaming experience, with complaints about excessive ads and a grind-heavy progression system. Despite some improvements over previous titles, the game's monetization practices are viewed as a cash grab, leading to frustration among players.
“Microtransactions are not pay to win, which is a big plus.”
“There are heavy microtransactions in the game, but they're mostly cosmetic and can be unlocked very easily.”
“While yes, the microtransactions suck, Gears 5 has the best story in a Gears game period with an amazing visual style and satisfying shooting mechanics.”
“The game has a ridiculous amount of microtransactions for a $60 game, and in its current state where iron is unearnable aside from a minuscule amount of the 'premium' currency (500, or $5 worth), with over $800 of microtransactions nothing is fun to earn, grind is ridiculous, and the character roster is currently the lowest at-launch for a Gears title ever.”
“This game is also riddled with empty lobbies despite 'crossplay', and also has terrible microtransactions that mimic the newfound battle pass gimmick and the Fortnite-style store, and on top of that you get a supply drop every once in a while which only contains one item which is usually some filler garbage like a blood splatter or a banner.”
“The monetization of this game makes me want to vomit.”
grinding
161 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
2%
6%
92%
The grinding aspect of Gears 5 has received mixed reviews, with many players finding it excessively tedious and frustrating, particularly in the open-world segments and during character unlocks. While some enjoy the grind for multiplayer progression and cosmetic rewards, others criticize the game for its heavy reliance on microtransactions and a convoluted progression system that detracts from the overall experience. Overall, players agree that the game requires a significant time investment to achieve meaningful rewards, which can feel more like a chore than an enjoyable challenge.
“You'll need a second life for grinding.”
“Large free-roaming maps with secondary objectives that are not too tedious to do and give great rewards in the form of Jack upgrades.”
“The open-ended world aspects are not bad either; they don't drag down the story and aren't tedious like some other recent games.”
“Gears 5 is unimaginative as, in the obvious pursuit of trying to do something different, they failed and used many tropes from other games, e.g. instead of killing behemoths with the Hammer of Dawn, the player has to run about and shoot lava-filled cracks in the backs of the behemoth berserks after freezing them and go through the horrendous amounts of unimaginative grinding in extremely boring, tedious, and meaningless boss fights.”
“The open world aspect was grindy and to be honest it was boring.”
“The tour of duty is far too grindy and gives out lackluster rewards.”
music
124 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
45%
52%
3%
The music in the game has received mixed reviews, with some praising the soundtrack as excellent and immersive, particularly during key moments and explorations, while others find it forgettable or lacking in originality, often relying on remixes of older tracks. The sound design is generally regarded as strong, enhancing the overall atmosphere, though technical issues have been reported that affect audio playback. Overall, while some players celebrate the musical score for its emotional impact and quality, others criticize it for being uninspired or disconnected from the gameplay experience.
“The world design is very beautiful and some of the best music is from when you are traveling on the skiff in the icy biome.”
“The music ebbs and flows with the action, heightening moments of tension and triumph.”
“The game has beautiful graphics and scenery, great characters, fantastic story, an absolutely great and incredible musical score.”
“The game's sound design is also uninspired, with forgettable music and unremarkable sound effects.”
“I didn't care for the music either; I really couldn't tell you a single track that got my heart pumping.”
“The music is disconnected and weak.”
emotional
91 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
92%
8%
The emotional aspect of "Gears 5" receives mixed reviews, with some players appreciating the deeper character development and personal arcs, particularly that of Kait Diaz, which evoke genuine emotional responses. However, many feel that the game lacks the impactful storytelling and heart-wrenching moments that defined the original trilogy, leading to a less engaging experience overall. While some moments resonate strongly, the narrative is often criticized for being predictable and lacking the emotional weight of its predecessors.
“The campaign is an emotional rollercoaster that will have you on the edge of your seat, with a gripping storyline that keeps you invested from start to finish.”
“The narrative is engaging, with strong character development and emotional moments that enhance the overall experience.”
“I literally cried a few times throughout the campaign because of those heartfelt moments.”
“Even ignoring the generic feel of a military shooter, this is a very boring story.”
“Boring game, boring story, and all of the good characters from the previous games are an afterthought.”
“What went from a testosterone-fueled adventure turned into a boring story.”
humor
83 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
96%
4%
The humor in the game is a mixed bag, with some players finding the dialogue sharp and filled with clever banter, while others criticize it as forced or lacking depth. Many enjoyed the comedic moments and character interactions, particularly in co-op modes, but some felt that the humor often undermined the game's darker themes. Overall, while there are genuinely funny moments, the execution varies widely, leading to a polarized reception among players.
“The dialogue is sharp, filled with humor and tension, reflecting the emotional stakes of the plot.”
“Game introduces some really funny banter at times.”
“The writing of the relationship between Kait and Del is charming and funny, but they both also nail the more dramatic turns when they need to.”
“Gears 5 achievements: 1/10 (Gears 5 should be renamed to Grinds 5, unfunny and unrewarding)”
“Del, the unfunny robophil.”
“No, they're not funny and they're not interesting.”
replayability
64 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
39%
53%
8%
Overall, "Gears 5" offers a mixed bag of replayability. While modes like Horde and Escape provide significant replay value and varied gameplay experiences, the campaign is criticized for its limited replayability and short length. Players appreciate the multiplayer and co-op options, but some feel that the game lacks depth in character unlocks and progression, impacting long-term engagement.
“Thanks to its varied modes, 'Gears 5' offers high replay value.”
“Overall, Gears 5's horde mode is incredibly replayable, and it's the main reason why I keep coming back.”
“The game has AAA budget co-op campaign, various competitive versus modes, and two PvE game modes which not only increase the replay value but are also a good value for your money.”
“I disliked the campaign, and to me, it doesn't have any replayability.”
“The only mercy is that the campaign is short (10-12 hours if you 'explore' everything) and has no replay value, so at least you'll be out of your misery in a weekend.”
“No replayability once you've done the campaign.”
atmosphere
56 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
45%
5%
The atmosphere in the game has received mixed reviews, with many players noting a significant departure from the dark, immersive environments of the original trilogy. While some praise the stunning graphics, dynamic lighting, and detailed settings that create a visually appealing experience, others lament the loss of the gritty, suspenseful tone that characterized earlier installments. Overall, the game's atmosphere is described as vibrant and visually impressive, but lacking the depth and emotional weight that fans of the series have come to expect.
“The lighting, especially in dark environments, heightens the tension and atmosphere, making firefights feel more intense.”
“The audio design is excellent, with immersive sound effects and a powerful musical score that enhances the game’s atmosphere.”
“The game is simply gorgeous with highly detailed models, dirty textures, imposing atmospheric lighting, and a unique chromatic palette that makes it stand out.”
“This game completely loses the atmosphere of the original games and made it into a walking/driving simulator for two acts.”
“The atmosphere didn't feel anything like the first few games (dark, dreary, underground).”
“Moreover, the picture palette used in Gears 4-5 is quite bright which goes against the previously established gore, dark, old-school atmosphere of the first original three Gears of War games.”
character development
40 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
23%
64%
13%
Character development in the game receives mixed reviews, with some praising it as nuanced and engaging, particularly highlighting the growth of characters like Kait and JD, while others criticize it for being superficial or poorly executed, often overshadowed by humor or disjointed storytelling. Many players feel that despite some strong moments, overall character arcs are either lacking depth or feel rushed, leading to a disconnect with the narrative. Ultimately, while there are standout instances of character development, the execution varies significantly across different characters and storylines.
“This focus on Kait's character development is refreshing, presenting a more nuanced approach to storytelling.”
“The narrative is engaging, with strong character development and emotional moments that enhance the overall experience.”
“If you love the series then you'll really love this game, the story is strong and the character development is hands down some of the best in the series.”
“Any potential character development is immediately shut down by some poor attempt at humor.”
“Instead of allowing for meaningful character development, the focus on upgrading the robot companion feels superficial.”
“There could have been real character development and dialogue, but instead, it legit happens off screen.”