Fate/EXTELLA: The Umbral Star is a single-player Hack and Slash game set in the virtual realm of SE.RA.PH, where Masters and Servants fight for the Holy Grail. With good graphics, enthralling story, and an epic soundtrack, players control Nero and her allies to defend against an uprising of Servants and uncover an ancient secret. However, be prepared for a lot of grinding.
Engaging story with well-written dialogue that appeals to Fate fans.
Fun and fast-paced musou-style gameplay with a variety of characters to play.
No online requirement, allowing for offline play once installed.
Repetitive gameplay with limited enemy variety and similar mission objectives.
Graphics are dated and can feel rough around the edges.
Lock-on targeting can be finicky, making combat frustrating at times.
story
613 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
29%
65%
6%
The story of "Fate/Extella" is generally well-received, particularly by fans of the Fate franchise, as it features engaging character interactions and a narrative that expands on the lore established in previous games. While some players find the storytelling to be lengthy and repetitive, with a significant amount of dialogue overshadowing gameplay, many appreciate the emotional depth and complexity of the plot, especially in the context of its visual novel elements. Overall, the narrative is seen as a strong point of the game, though it may be less compelling for those unfamiliar with the Fate universe.
“Fortunately, we get a rather intriguing story with endearing characters as well as a fun and fast musou-styled hack and slasher holding it all together like super glue!”
“The story is surprisingly good, knowing what type of game Extella is; it almost felt this game is more of a visual novel instead of hack and slash, you'd spend hours reading the dialogues (if you care about it).”
“This game has a phenomenal story, as expected with a Nasu-written Fate product.”
“The story is serviceable, though it won't be winning any awards for groundbreaking storytelling.”
“The story can drag on, and the pacing is inconsistent, making it feel tedious at times.”
“The story is filled with plot holes and lacks depth, making it hard to stay engaged.”
gameplay
239 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
23%
62%
15%
The gameplay of Fate/Extella has received mixed reviews, with many players noting its repetitive nature and similarities to the Dynasty Warriors series. While some enjoy the fast-paced, hack-and-slash mechanics and find them fun and stress-relieving, others criticize the lack of depth and variety, leading to a monotonous experience over time. Overall, the gameplay serves primarily as a vehicle for the story, which is often highlighted as the game's stronger aspect.
“The gameplay is versatile and fast-paced, and you get a lot of characters to choose from, providing hours of entertainment.”
“Gameplay is fun 'musou' action, though it can get somewhat mindless, but I've cleared all the main and side stories with pleasure.”
“The gameplay itself is solid and surprisingly intricate, the story is actually pretty good, and the various servants on display all have amazing voices and very satisfying gameplay.”
“The gameplay is very repetitive, with using pretty much a small map rotation for all of the scenario.”
“Gameplay is constantly interrupted for scripted cutscenes that play whenever you make any kind of progress.”
“The gameplay feels like a terribly watered down clone of dynasty warriors, but without any of the good mechanics, the characters all usually only have 1 optimal combo and it is what you'll be spamming for the majority of the game.”
graphics
87 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
25%
65%
10%
The graphics of the game receive mixed reviews, with many users noting that they appear dated, reminiscent of older consoles like the PSP or PS Vita. While some praise the character designs and artwork as stunning, others criticize the overall visual quality as subpar for a 2017 release, with issues like blocky models and a lack of graphical settings. Despite these criticisms, some players find the visuals acceptable and well-optimized for various hardware configurations.
“The visuals shine like a polished gem, though none can match my radiant glory.”
“Visuals are top-notch and the character design is fantastic, with detailed and beautifully animated characters that are true to the original source material.”
“The port runs great, with a standalone launcher to configure resolution, and various graphic options; you can even select 4K resolution if your PC can handle it.”
“The graphics are laughably bad for a 2017 game with models that look like Play-Doh and action figures.”
“The graphics, if I must say, were a bit awful.”
“It seems that the original developer team was using some sort of 2010 version software that they couldn't afford much more detailed graphics.”
music
53 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
43%
49%
8%
The music in the game has received largely positive feedback, with many players praising its ability to enhance the gaming experience through fitting and immersive soundtracks that align well with the game's themes and action. While some tracks are noted as recycled from previous titles in the Fate series, the overall composition is described as beautiful and engaging, contributing significantly to the atmosphere and enjoyment of gameplay. However, a few reviews mention that certain battle themes are less memorable and that the music can become repetitive over time.
“The soundtrack is beautiful.”
“The music fits the game really well, just like the ambient noises.”
“The soundtrack is fantastic, there's a compelling story that even non-fate fans can follow with relative ease, and the gameplay is great fun.”
“The music in the NPCs is cut badly.”
“Music is also lackluster.”
“Most of it is recycled or remixed from 'Fate/Extra CCC'; as for the direct Extella music pieces, a lot of it is serviceable, but very few are really good, like the music for the final boss in each campaign.”
grinding
20 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Players generally find the grinding aspect of the game to be tedious and repetitive, often leading to boredom as they repeatedly tackle the same levels and battles. While some appreciate the core gameplay and story, many express frustration with the grind required for achievements and leveling up, suggesting that it detracts from the overall enjoyment. Despite the grind, the engaging music and combat mechanics provide some motivation to push through the repetitive tasks.
“I really wanted to enjoy this game; however, the fights and the overall gameplay became unbearably boring and tedious.”
“The pain of grinding the same 6 maps 4 times is more than enough for me to give this a negative review.”
“It can get quite repetitive later, especially when grinding for certain achievements.”
emotional
13 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Players find the game emotionally engaging, with a beautiful story that evolves into a touching experience, often eliciting strong feelings such as love and heartbreak. The combination of stunning art and music enhances the emotional depth, while the well-crafted narratives and character arcs keep players invested. Despite some initial confusion, many reviewers appreciate the emotional rollercoaster and the wholesome elements woven throughout the plot.
“However, it has a pretty good story that gets pretty emotional at times; at least for me, it was.”
“The art in this game is beautiful, and combined with the OST, it can be emotional.”
“The game offers a rich story that is very easy to get emotionally invested in, with characters recognizable from across the Fate franchise.”
character development
10 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
20%
30%
Character development in the game has received mixed reviews, with many praising the standout character design and voice acting, particularly for characters like Nero and Jeanne. However, critics argue that the writing lacks depth, with characters often feeling like one-dimensional stereotypes and interactions being minimal, leading to a perception of missed opportunities for meaningful development. Overall, while the visuals and character aesthetics are strong, they do not compensate for the shortcomings in narrative and character growth.
“For starters, the character design is a standout, especially if you're into characters that bring a lot of personality (and yes, attractiveness) to the table.”
“Visuals are top-notch and the character design is fantastic, with detailed and beautifully animated characters that are true to the original source material.”
“It's fate (and I love fate), so it comes with good character design, voice acting, and personality.”
“Moving on, apart from missing character development or interactions, the main plot is way too long for its own good.”
“The writing is just so terrible, every character is just a cheap rip-off of anime with no character development.”
“Fate Extella completely wipes any character development Tamamo ever got and replaces it with a generic 'I love you, Master, please accept me' stereotype while leaving her on the side.”
optimization
9 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
78%
22%
The game's optimization is highly praised, with users reporting smooth performance even on older PCs, such as those with i3 processors, and consistently high frame rates on more powerful setups. The PC port is well-optimized, allowing for a range of graphics settings while maintaining excellent performance, often exceeding 60fps on max settings. Overall, it delivers a comparable experience to the original PS4 release, with full controller support enhancing gameplay.
“The fight sequence is just smooth; you can even play it on an older generation PC like an i3 Gen 2 or 3. The game is well optimized for playing on older PCs.”
“The port is greatly optimized and allows for a decent graphics selection.”
“Even though my graphics card is a low-tier graphics card, the game runs smoothly at 60fps+.”
“It's like Dynasty Warriors, minus the poor optimization. The game doesn't dip below 140 FPS maxed out running at my ultrawide monitor's resolution with an RX 5700, usually staying in the 180 FPS range.”
“You can see a direct comparison of graphics and performance between this PC release and the original PS4 release here: https://youtu.”
humor
7 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The humor in the game is widely praised, with players enjoying the witty banter between characters like Nero and Tamamo, as well as the overall comedic tone that enhances the gameplay experience. While the story may not reach the heights of other entries in the franchise, the funny and unique character interactions contribute significantly to the game's charm and enjoyment. Overall, the humor adds a delightful layer to the hack-and-slash mechanics, making it a fun experience for players.
“Also... the back and forth between Nero and Tamamo is funny as all hell.”
“This game is so funny to play and enjoyable; in FGO gacha, I was so frustrated with zero luck, but in this game, your favorite servant is free.”
“Also, the main character Nero is so funny and cute!”
replayability
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
17%
50%
The game offers significant replayability through multiple difficulty levels, a variety of equipment and passives, and diverse characters, although the narrative focus limits the depth of some characters. Players appreciate the free play modes and express excitement for future installments that promise enhanced features and more content.
“It has a lot of replayability with scores, 4 difficulty levels, and a lot of equipment/passives to equip.”
“+ large cast of diverse characters (all of which are playable!)”
“I found the game mostly narrative, and while all servants are playable, only three are focused on.”
“You'll have fun with the inane story, and the free play modes offer a lot of replay value.”
“I'm excited for the sequel (Fate/Extella Link) as it promises more playable servants, more storyline, better graphics, and improved mechanics.”
stability
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
67%
Overall, the game's stability is mixed; while the port runs well with a standalone launcher for configuration and supports high resolutions, users have reported bugs, particularly with name input and enemy interactions that can disrupt gameplay.
“The port runs great, with a standalone launcher to configure resolution and various graphic options. You can even select 4K resolution if your PC can handle it.”
“The name input is buggy; use keyboard controls first before switching to the controller, or else you will not be able to proceed or enter your name.”
“It's buggy; there is a glitch where you can push enemies off the map into the void of the game.”
monetization
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The monetization of the game is criticized as a blatant cash grab, especially when compared to other titles like Saber Venus, CCC, and Foxtail. Reviewers express disappointment, suggesting that the game feels poorly executed and primarily designed to extract money from players.
“Especially Saber Venus was pretty good, but compared to CCC and Foxtail, this game is clearly a cash-grabbing scam.”
“What did you expect from a half-ass cash grab game made for the PS Vita?”
atmosphere
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
The atmosphere of the game is heavily influenced by its music, which can enhance the experience for players who appreciate the style. Overall, the right musical choices contribute significantly to creating an immersive environment.
“The music style really enhances the atmosphere of the game, creating an immersive experience.”
“The game's atmosphere is captivating, drawing you into its world with every detail.”
“The combination of visuals and sound design creates a hauntingly beautiful atmosphere that lingers long after playing.”