All Guns On Deck

The graphics of the game receive mixed reviews, with some praising the colorful art style, detailed visuals, and engaging animations that enhance the gameplay experience. However, others criticize the overall quality, describing it as "ugly" or "meh," suggesting that while there is evident passion in the design, the execution falls short of expectations. Overall, the visuals are seen as a highlight for some players, but the game's current state and mechanics detract from its potential.

The game's story is largely criticized for being almost non-existent, with players noting a lack of objectives, memorable characters, and meaningful progression. While some appreciate the steampunk setting and ship combat mechanics, many feel that the absence of a compelling narrative detracts from the overall experience, making it feel unfinished and repetitive. Overall, the focus on battles over storytelling leaves players wanting more depth and engagement.

The music and sound design in the game are generally praised for their quality, enhancing the overall experience with impressive weapon sounds and explosions. However, some users noted that the music can be repetitive, which detracts from the enjoyment, especially in the game's current incomplete state. Overall, while the sound design is a highlight, the lack of variety in the soundtrack is a common criticism.

The game's stability is a significant concern, with numerous glitches and bugs hindering gameplay, particularly during critical moments like the final fight. Despite being in early access for nearly two years, players report a lack of substantial updates to address these issues, making it largely unplayable.

Players find the grinding aspect of the game to be excessive, often requiring them to repeat the same battles multiple times due to initial difficulty and inadequate currency rewards. While some may appreciate the challenge of grinding, many feel it detracts from the overall experience, especially with issues like inaccurate weapons and insufficient coin earnings per battle.

The game offers a complex optimization system where personnel can be assigned specific roles to enhance performance in various ship sections. However, players note that there is significant potential for further optimization and adjustments to make the game more accessible to casual gamers.

The game is praised for its humor, featuring amusing weapons like a gift cannon that shoots presents at enemies and a cannon that launches crew members, adding a comedic twist to the gameplay. However, players also note that the game can be challenging.

The consensus among users is that the game lacks replayability, with multiple reviews explicitly stating that there is no incentive to play it again.

Players report a strong emotional impact, often feeling deeply moved and experiencing tears during pivotal moments in the game, particularly when the stakes become clear. This highlights the game's ability to evoke powerful feelings and connect with players on a personal level.