Whisper of a Rose

About

Whisper of a Rose is a single player role playing game. It was developed by RosePortal Games and was released on November 14, 2014. It received neutral reviews from players.

"Whisper of a Rose" is a classic point-and-click adventure game that follows a young girl named Rose on her journey to save her kidnapped sister. Along the way, she discovers a magical world filled with puzzles and intrigue. The game features hand-drawn graphics and a hauntingly beautiful soundtrack, immersing players in a surreal and dreamlike atmosphere.

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Single-Player

Skip User Reviews

47%

Audience ScoreBased on 78 reviews

story21 positive mentions

grinding15 negative mentions

The game features beautiful hand-drawn graphics and a captivating fairy tale-like story that immerses players in its world.
The soundtrack is well-composed and enhances the emotional depth of the game, making it enjoyable to listen to even outside of gameplay.
With over 30 hours of gameplay, including side quests and multiple classes to choose from, the game offers significant value for RPG fans.

The game suffers from tedious grinding and repetitive enemy encounters, which can detract from the overall experience.
The main character, Melrose, is often perceived as unlikable and immature, which can make it difficult for players to connect with her journey.
Navigation can be frustrating due to poorly designed mazes and the constant respawning of enemies, leading to a cumbersome gameplay experience.

story
86 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
24%
69%
7%
The game's story is a mixed bag, featuring a fairy tale-like narrative with emotional depth and beautiful visuals, but it suffers from pacing issues and a lack of coherence, often feeling disjointed and overly reliant on fetch quests. While some players appreciate the character development and thematic elements related to mental health, others criticize the protagonist and the overall execution as juvenile or cringeworthy. Ultimately, the story's potential is overshadowed by tedious gameplay mechanics and a convoluted plot that struggles to maintain focus.
- “The story is emotionally powerful, and the characters and settings still seem to live on in my mind afterwards.”
- “The dream landscapes start from childhood-like and grow more mature/sinister, and things in the dream world correspond to things in her actual life - Diamond's whole backstory for example.”
- “As far as the story goes, this game is one of the best I've played; it is not your typical 'save the world' narrative.”
- “The storyline is still a completely cringey high school anime club fan fiction that should be avoided at all costs.”
- “The story is clunky and disjointed, and instead feels like one long fetch quest.”
- “The slow opening for this fantasy/scifi mixed RPG fails with its shotgun approach to its plot as an attempt to hook the player.”
music
36 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
39%
53%
8%
The music in the game is widely praised for its beauty and variety, with each area featuring unique tracks that enhance the overall experience. Many players find the soundtrack soothing and reminiscent of classic RPGs, making it enjoyable for casual listening as well. However, some users noted that certain tracks can become repetitive over time, though the overall composition remains a highlight of the game.
- “The music itself is very typical of RPG games: melodramatic & catchy.”
- “This game has great music; I could honestly see myself just listening to it casually while working or going to sleep as it is also very soothing.”
- “All the music fits great with the scenes and the battle themes are just amazing.”
- “The music itself is very typical of RPG games: melodramatic and catchy.”
- “It gives you the option to mute everything, which you will want to do quickly as the sounds and music get very repetitive very fast.”
- “Reused music.”
graphics
25 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
48%
40%
12%
The graphics in the game are widely praised for their vibrant, colorful artwork and detailed pixel art, showcasing a unique and imaginative style that enhances the overall experience. While some users noted minor issues and a lack of top-tier polish, the custom graphics and thoughtful design of various locations contribute significantly to the game's charm. Overall, the visuals are considered a standout feature, elevating the game beyond typical RPG Maker titles.
- “The graphics appealed to me for their bright, colorful, child fantasy-like themes, and the locations all fit into these themes effectively, such as Valentown and its contrasting Hallowtown, the desert regions contrasting the jungles, and many more.”
- “The in-game art style is beautiful and shows a lot of consideration has been put into designing areas, characters, etc.”
- “The art style is impressive and the music is amazing; the gameplay is reminiscent of old school Final Fantasy with some current day practices.”
- “Whisper of a Rose is an interesting entry in the genre of completely craphouse RPG Maker games in that the developer used some MSPaint-tier custom artwork instead of just asset flipping the default RPG Maker assets.”
- “The only shortcoming I can think of is that the graphics are okay, but not top-notch.”
- “Don't buy, unless your machine is a 486 MX with a 2MB graphics card.”
gameplay
24 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
25%
54%
21%
The gameplay has received mixed reviews, with players noting a lengthy playtime of around 30 hours but criticizing the combat mechanics as basic and slow-paced. While some appreciate the interesting elemental damage system and beautiful art style, many feel that the gameplay is hindered by repetitive grinding, poorly executed tutorials, and a lack of engaging action. Overall, the game showcases RPG Maker's potential but falls short in delivering a captivating gameplay experience.
- “Expect no less than 30 hours of gameplay.”
- “The combat mechanics are interesting as you play with different forms of elemental damage (fire, water, air, earth) which are resisted by different degrees by different monsters.”
- “The art style is impressive and the music is amazing; the gameplay is reminiscent of old school Final Fantasy with some current day practices.”
- “The game had an issue with fullscreening, correctly cropping out a small part of the user interface and gameplay area at the screen edges.”
- “Then the game turns heavily to the grinding part with the super annoying mechanic where already cleared places are re-populated once you change level.”
- “What I didn't like about the game was the painfully slow gameplay, lack of action, and overall 'meh' story.”
grinding
15 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Reviews indicate that grinding in the game is often viewed as tedious and unnecessary, detracting from the overall experience. While some players appreciate the RPG elements and the rewards from grinding, many find the repetitive battles and slow story progression frustrating, especially as the game progresses. Overall, the grinding mechanics seem to overshadow the enjoyment of the game for a significant number of players.
- “But contains some grinding which technically really isn't necessary for a good game that's long already in the first place.”
- “Then the game turns heavily to the grinding part with the super annoying mechanic where already cleared places are re-populated once you change level.”
- “The first 30 minutes or so are decent, then the game becomes incredibly tedious because of dungeon design.”
emotional
5 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game is noted for its emotionally powerful narrative, featuring deeply impactful characters and settings that linger in players' minds. Heartbreaking moments, such as Melrose's tragic experiences and the contrast between despair and uplifting scenes, resonate strongly, particularly for those who are sensitive and willing to invest emotionally. Many players report shedding tears during pivotal scenes, highlighting the game's ability to evoke genuine emotional responses.
- “The story is emotionally powerful, and the characters and settings still seem to live on in my mind afterwards.”
- “There are some heartbreaking moments that really stick with you.”
- “If you are a sensitive person and can invest yourself emotionally into the game, you'll find many scenes genuinely moving.”
humor
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The humor in the game is characterized by a blend of sadness and hilarity, featuring awkward bathroom jokes and a lighthearted tone that provides a refreshing change of pace. Players find the comedic elements engaging enough to inspire playful thoughts, such as taking a day off work to enjoy the game.
- “The ending was sad and funny at the same time.”
- “It was mildly hilarious and a good change of pace.”
- “I even got the funny idea to call my boss tomorrow and tell him that I'm sick so I can have a day off to spend on playing this fabulous game!”
replayability
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
67%
The game offers significant replayability through its 50+ achievements, card drops, and a New Game+ mode, encouraging players to complete all achievements and side quests. Players will need to complete the game at least twice to unlock everything, including a unique side quest that rewards the best summon, enhancing the overall replay value.
- “The game also features 50+ achievements and card drops, which both have stunning artwork, and there is a New Game+ mode that provides replayability for fully completing achievements and side quests.”
- “To get all achievements, you will need to play this game twice, giving it more replay value.”
- “There is some replay value since you get new content on a second run, and there's one side quest that can only be finished on the second playthrough, which nets you the best summon in the game.”
- “To get all achievements, you will need to play this game twice, hence giving it more replay value.”
- “There is some replay value though since you get some new stuff on a second run, and there's one side quest that can only be finished on the second playthrough, which nets you the best summon in the game.”
monetization
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The reviews do not provide specific insights into the monetization aspect of the game, focusing instead on the quality of the art and the effectiveness of the game's marketing. Overall, there is no clear consensus or detailed feedback regarding monetization strategies or practices.
- “The monetization system feels overly aggressive, making it hard to enjoy the game without spending extra money.”
- “I was disappointed to find that many features are locked behind paywalls, which ruins the overall experience.”
- “It's frustrating that progress is heavily gated by in-game purchases, making it feel like a cash grab rather than a fair game.”
atmosphere
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
50%
The game's "colored pencil" aesthetic enhances its overall atmosphere, creating a unique and relaxing environment for players. While the slow start may deter some, it provides an opportunity to fully immerse oneself in the game's tranquil ambiance.
- “It had a 'colored pencil' appearance that I thought added to the atmosphere of the game.”
- “The only downside to the game is that the beginning is a little bit slow, but it also allows you to sit back and take in the atmosphere and relax.”
optimization
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The optimization of the game is criticized for poor framerate in specific areas, likely due to excessive special effects and event handling, a common issue with RPG Maker titles. This performance problem is attributed to the engine's inherent limitations rather than the player's hardware.