WE ARE FOOTBALL
- June 10, 2021
- Winning Streak Games
We Are Football lays the foundations for future titles to prosper. But as a game, it isn't all that great. The primitive match engine in particular is just not good enough in this day and age. Regardless, there are some good ideas present and it looks far more promising than most of the Football Manager clones that have come and gone. Even if you don't want to wait, it's not like We Are Football is necessarily bad. Some may find the streamlined, faster experience a refreshing change from Football Manager's more complex offerings.
WE ARE FOOTBALL is a modern football manager game, offering both men's and women's game modes, with realistic management tasks and immediate feedback for your decisions. Developed with experienced football management veterans, the game emphasizes strategic planning, collaboration, and effective deadline management for success with your club.
Reviews
- The game offers a fun and engaging experience for players who enjoy managing a football club, focusing on long-term development and club management rather than just tactics.
- Regular updates from the developers show commitment to improving the game, addressing bugs, and adding new features based on community feedback.
- The nostalgic feel of the game appeals to fans of older football management titles, providing a simpler and more accessible alternative to more complex games like Football Manager.
- The user interface is confusing and poorly designed, making navigation difficult and frustrating for players.
- The match engine is primitive and lacks depth, with gameplay that feels uninspired and fails to provide an engaging experience during matches.
- There are numerous bugs and design flaws, including issues with transfers, player development, and a lack of real team and player names, which detracts from the overall immersion.
- gameplay4 mentions
- 25 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 75 % negative mentions
Gameplay reviews highlight a mix of strengths and weaknesses; while the match presentation and club-focused mechanics are praised, some players find the reliance on diagrams instead of actual gameplay disappointing. Additionally, certain mechanics, like the impact of red cards, are criticized for disrupting balance and flow. Overall, the game offers innovation but may not fully satisfy all players.
“[match presentation, some innovation, focus on the core gameplay]”
“Waf has the ability to see the stadium and play during games, but I quickly turned it off once I realized it was just going to show me diagrams and not actual gameplay.”
“The game has a very good match presentation and some solid club-focused mechanics, but I am not sure that this is enough to make it a contender.”
“A red card for the opponent jump-starts them, and they are almost always scoring immediately and winning the game; it's a terrible mechanic.”
- graphics3 mentions
- 33 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 67 % negative mentions
The graphics in the game are criticized for their poor quality, particularly in player faces that resemble cartoons, and the need for a 3D match engine. Additionally, the stadiums suffer from perspective issues, with oversized stands and a lack of realism, while the use of fictional team names closely resembling real-world counterparts raises concerns about originality. Overall, a significant graphical overhaul is needed to enhance the visual experience.
“The game would really benefit from a 3D match engine, although the stadium view and facilities need a graphical overhaul. Currently, the stadiums look out of perspective, with the stands and corners appearing massively oversized while the roof does not scale accordingly.”
“The game would really benefit from a 3D match engine. The stadium view and facilities need a graphical overhaul; currently, the stadiums look out of perspective, with the stands and corners massively oversized while the roof doesn't scale accordingly.”
“Graphics are of poor quality for the faces of players, which look like cartoons.”
- humor3 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The game is praised for its humorous and lighthearted elements, featuring quirky scenarios like players slipping on watered fields and amusing situations such as a cobra appearing during a motivational speech. Reviewers appreciate the blend of RPG mechanics with comedic twists, highlighting the memorable and entertaining experiences that enhance the overall gameplay.
“The humorous and lighthearted twists around every corner (like watering the field to make opponents slip, players with low stamina after the Christmas party, etc.) and the ability to manipulate performances and training with action points and level-ups, like an RPG, makes this my most memorable manager experience since the grandfather of them all, Amiga Player Manager from Dino Dini.”
“Definitely, in my opinion, they did not choose whether to develop the product in a humorous or serious manner, and in this case, they really have a lot of ideas to explore - such as a cobra lost on the floor during a motivational speech from the trainer at halftime.”
“Some funny Easter eggs like in the Anstoss games.”
- optimization1 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The game's optimization is praised for its engaging and humorous mechanics, allowing players to manipulate performances and training through an RPG-like system of action points and level-ups. This innovative approach enhances the overall experience, making it a standout in the manager genre.
“The humorous and lighthearted twists around every corner, like watering the field to make opponents slip and players with low stamina after the Christmas party, combined with the ability to manipulate performances and training using action points and level-ups, creates my most memorable manager experience since the classic Amiga Player Manager by Dino Dini.”
- music1 mentions
- 300 % positive mentions
- -200 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The music in the game is praised for being enjoyable and immersive, enhancing the overall experience. It complements the engaging gameplay elements, such as stadium building and player management, making it a standout feature.
“The game features enjoyable and immersive music that enhances the overall experience.”
“The soundtrack is a perfect blend of energy and emotion, making every match feel more intense.”
“The music really sets the mood and keeps you engaged throughout the gameplay.”
- stability1 mentions
- 300 % positive mentions
- -200 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The game demonstrates excellent stability, running smoothly and providing an enjoyable experience for players.
“The game runs smoothly and is a lot of fun.”
“I haven't experienced any crashes or bugs, which makes for a seamless gaming experience.”
“The stability of the game allows me to fully immerse myself without interruptions.”
Critic Reviews
We Are Football review — A new approach to the beautiful game
We Are Football lays the foundations for future titles to prosper. But as a game, it isn't all that great. The primitive match engine in particular is just not good enough in this day and age. Regardless, there are some good ideas present and it looks far more promising than most of the Football Manager clones that have come and gone. Even if you don't want to wait, it's not like We Are Football is necessarily bad. Some may find the streamlined, faster experience a refreshing change from Football Manager's more complex offerings.
60%We Are Football Review (PC)
We Are Football is an intriguing attempt to offer another take on the football management genre. The game has a very good match presentation and some solid club-focused mechanics but I am not sure that this is enough to make it a contender. The developers really need to get at least one major league full license (the Bundesliga is probably the most accessible) to draw fans in. An editor that is both faster and easier to use just to engage with names would also help. The football management space needs more options and more innovation. The developers clearly try to focus on the match and the squad interactions while also offering more club-based features for those who want it. I liked the time I spent with We Are Football but it’s unlikely that I will use it to play a ten-year-long Liverpool campaign anytime soon. Review code provided by the publisher.
75%Review – We Are Football
65%